"Tankiest Tank - Hurt or Heal game" Topic

I ran one of these a few years ago about wargaming periods. I was going to do an airplane one, but the winner would obviously be the Spitfire

From this thread

TMP link

I've culled the suggestions that seemed to keep popping up.
Remember IT IS NOT the best/fastest/most armoured/best gun, but the one when you look at it screams TANK; The spirit, avatar even, of all that is tank.

The rules
Copy the list from the entry immediately above your next one (ie the last entry on the thread), and paste as a new comment. All tanks taking part start with a score of 10

You must HURT TWO tanks (must be 2 different) by reducing their score by 1
You must HEAL ONE tank by increasing its score by 1.
(So after the first round 1 tank will be on 11, 2 will be on 9, and the rest will still be on 10)

Note at the top of the list what you are doing.

If you take away the last point, mark it as K/O (instead of 0) – these can't be healed.

You may not take part again until at least 3 other people have had a go (comments, interjections etc. do not count)

The list

10- Panzer IV
10- Panther
10- M3
10- M24
10- M48
10- M60
10- Abrams
10- Mk IV Male
10- Churchill
10- Centurion
10- T34
10- T55
10- Char B

Huh? I must be really tired, 'cause this makes no sense to me….

Example
Hurt M24 and Abrams
Heal Panzer IV

11- Panzer IV
10- Panther
10- M3
9- M24
10- M48
10- M60
9- Abrams
10- Mk IV Male
10- Churchill
10- Centurion
10- T34
10- T55
10- Char B

IGNORE THIS AS PART OF THE GAME – Next person to use original list to start the game proper.

OK, I'm in. The last one was fun.

Hurt M3 and Char B
Heal T34

10- Panzer IV
10- Panther
9- M3
10- M24
10- M48
10- M60
10- Abrams
10- Mk IV Male
10- Churchill
10- Centurion
11- T34
10- T55
9- Char B

Hurt Mk IV Male and M24, Heal Panther.

10- Panzer IV
11- Panther
9 – M3
9 – M24
10- M48
10- M60
10- Abrams
9 – Mk IV Male
10- Churchill
10- Centurion
11- T34
10- T55
9- Char B

I'm mad because the Tiger's not on there.

I would take my toys and go home, but I am home, so I'll just go to bed.

Hurt M3 and Churchill.
Heal Centurion.

10- Panzer IV
11- Panther
8 – M3
9 – M24
10 – M48
10 – M60
10 – Abrams
9 – Mk IV Male
9 – Churchill
11 – Centurion
11- T34
10 – T55
9 – Char B

Hurt Char B and Abrams.
Heal PzIV.

11- Panzer IV
11- Panther
8 – M3
9 – M24
10 – M48
10 – M60
9 – Abrams
9 – Mk IV Male
9 – Churchill
11 – Centurion
11- T34
10 – T55
8 – Char B

Hurt char B and Abrams
Heal Centurion

11- Panzer IV
11- Panther
8 – M3
9 – M24
10 – M48
10 – M60
8 – Abrams
9 – Mk IV Male
9 – Churchill
12 – Centurion
11- T34
10 – T55
7 – Char B

Hurt M3 and Mk IV Male
Heal Centurion

11- Panzer IV
11- Panther
7 – M3
9 – M24
10 – M48
10 – M60
8 – Abrams
8 – Mk IV Male
9 – Churchill
13 – Centurion
11- T34
10 – T55
7 – Char B

Heal MKIV Male
Hurt Abrams & T55

11- Panzer IV
11- Panther
7 – M3
9 – M24
10 – M48
10 – M60
7 – Abrams
9 – Mk IV Male
9 – Churchill
13 – Centurion
11- T34
9 – T55
7 – Char B

Heal Centurion
Hurt Panzer IV & T34

10- Panzer IV
11- Panther
7 – M3
9 – M24
10 – M48
10 – M60
7 – Abrams
9 – Mk IV Male
9 – Churchill
14 – Centurion
10- T34
9 – T55
7 – Char B

Heal M3 (I am assuming this is the Lee, and not the Stuart)
Hurt Abrams and Churchill

10- Panzer IV
11- Panther
8 – M3
9 – M24
10 – M48
10 – M60
6 – Abrams
9 – Mk IV Male
8 – Churchill
14 – Centurion
10- T34
9 – T55
7 – Char B

Heal Panzer IV
Hurt M60 and Abrams

11- Panzer IV
11- Panther
8 – M3
9 – M24
10 – M48
9 – M60
5 – Abrams
9 – Mk IV Male
8 – Churchill
14 – Centurion
10- T34
9 – T55
7 – Char B

heal M60
hurt panzer vi and centurion

10- Panzer IV
11- Panther
8 – M3
9 – M24
10 – M48
10 – M60
5 – Abrams
9 – Mk IV Male
8 – Churchill
13 – Centurion
10- T34
9 – T55
7 – Char B

Heal Panther
Hurt Char B and M60

10- Panzer IV
12- Panther
8 – M3
9 – M24
10 – M48
9 – M60
5 – Abrams
9 – Mk IV Male
8 – Churchill
13 – Centurion
10- T34
9 – T55
6 – Char B

As hard as it is to believe, neither my wife or daughter in law have a favourite tank.

I know, unbelievable.

Heal Char B
Hurt Churchill and Abrams

10- Panzer IV
12- Panther
8 – M3
9 – M24
10 – M48
9 – M60
4 – Abrams
9 – Mk IV Male
7 – Churchill
13 – Centurion
10- T34
9 – T55
7 – Char B

As hard as it is to believe, neither my wife or daughter in law have a favourite tank.

I know, unbelievable.

Ain΄t they got no culture???

Okay – I'm up for it

Heal Panther
Hurt M3 and M24

10- Panzer IV
10- Panther
10- M3
10- M24
10- M48
10- M60
10- Abrams
10- Mk IV Male
10- Churchill
10- Centurion
10- T34
10- T55
10- Char B

Ok. Have corrected Frederick's reset!
Heal Panther.
Hurt Centurion & T-34.
10- Panzer IV
14- Panther
7 – M3
8 – M24
10 – M48
9 – M60
4 – Abrams
9 – Mk IV Male
7 – Churchill
12 – Centurion
9 – T34
9 – T55
7 – Char B

Heal M-24
Hurt Panther & Churchill
10- Panzer IV
12- Panther
7 – M3
9 – M24
10 – M48
9 – M60
4 – Abrams
9 – Mk IV Male
6 – Churchill
12 – Centurion
9 – T34
9 – T55
7 – Char B

heal M60
hurt panzer vi and centurion

9- Panzer IV
12- Panther
7 – M3
9 – M24
10 – M48
10– M60
4 – Abrams
9 – Mk IV Male
6 – Churchill
11 – Centurion
9 – T34
9 – T55
7 – Char B

heal Mk IV Male
hurt M60 and Abrams

9- Panzer IV
12- Panther
7 – M3
9 – M24
10 – M48
9 – M60
3 – Abrams
10 – Mk IV Male
6 – Churchill
11 – Centurion
9 – T34
9 – T55
7 – Char B

Heal – Panzer IV, Hurt Mk IV Male, T55
10-- Panzer IV
12- Panther
7 – M3
9 – M24
10 – M48
9 – M60
3 – Abrams
9 – Mk IV Male
6 – Churchill
11 – Centurion
9 – T34
8 – T55
7 – Char B

Hurt Panther and T34
Heal Centurion
10-- Panzer IV
11- Panther
7 – M3
9 – M24
10 – M48
9 – M60
3 – Abrams
9 – Mk IV Male
6 – Churchill
12 – Centurion
8 – T34
8 – T55
7 – Char B

Heal – T55, Hurt – Abrams, M3

10 – Panzer IV
11 – Panther
6 – M3
9 – M24
10 – M48
9 – M60
2 – Abrams
9 – Mk IV Male
6 – Churchill
12 – Centurion
8 – T34
8 – T55
7 – Char B

Heal M3
Hurt Abrams and Churchill

10 – Panzer IV
11 – Panther
7 – M3
9 – M24
10 – M48
9 – M60
1 – Abrams
9 – Mk IV Male
5 – Churchill
11 – Centurion
8 – T34
8 – T55
7 – Char B

Hurt Panther and Centurion
Heal M24

10 – Panzer IV
10 – Panther
7 – M3
10 – M24
10 – M48
9 – M60
1 – Abrams
9 – Mk IV Male
5 – Churchill
10 – Centurion
8 – T34
8 – T55
7 – Char B

Hurt Abrahams and Churchill
Heal Centurion
10 – Panzer IV
10 – Panther
7 – M3
10 – M24
10 – M48
9 – M60
k/o – Abrams
9 – Mk IV Male
4 – Churchill
11 – Centurion
8 – T34
8 – T55
7 – Char B

Hurt Panther and Churchill
Heal Centurion
10 – Panzer IV
9 – Panther
7 – M3
10 – M24
10 – M48
9 – M60
9 – Mk IV Male
3 – Churchill
12 – Centurion
8 – T34
8 – T55
7 – Char B

Abrams is the first casualty! Just shows- they don't make 'em like they used to. That will help concentrate the 'Hurt'.

Hurt Panther and Panzer IV
Heal M48
9 – Panzer IV
8 – Panther
7 – M3
10 – M24
11 – M48
9 – M60
9 – Mk IV Male
3 – Churchill
12 – Centurion
8 – T34
8 – T55
7 – Char B

Heal= M-3, Hurt – T-55, Churchill
9 – Panzer IV
8 – Panther
8 – M3
10 – M24
11 – M48
9 – M60
9 – Mk IV Male
2 – Churchill
12 – Centurion
8 – T34
7 – T55
7 – Char B

Heal M3
Hurt Churchill and Panther

9 – Panzer IV
7 – Panther
9 – M3
10 – M24
11 – M48
9 – M60
9 – Mk IV Male
1 – Churchill
12 – Centurion
8 – T34
7 – T55
7 – Char B

Hurt M3 and M48
Heal Churchill
9-PzIV
7-Panther
8-M3
10-M24
10-M48
9-M60
9-Mk IV Male
2-Churchill
12-Centurion
8-T34
7-T55
7-Char B

Well, Churchill and Panther were both on my original group of Tanky Tanks.

Number of posts together – that's thrown the sums out a bit!

Hurt M3 and T55
Heal Centurion
10-PzIV
9-Panther
5-M3
10-M24
9-M48
9-M60
9-Mk IV Male
4-Churchill
13-Centurion
8-T34
7-T55
7-Char B

Heal Churchill. Hurt M-3 (Stuart), M-48.

9 – Panzer IV
9 – Panther*
7 – M3
10 – M24
10 – M48
9 – M60
9 – Mk IV Male
3 – Churchill
12 – Centurion
8 – T34
7 – T55
7 – Char B

*Correcting a double hit on the Panther.

Well, edited my scores to match TJs version, meanwhile 2 new posts appeared!

HOLD FIRE – While I double check scores

Ok, Checked all the way back to my last post – 6 posts.

This is correct. If it isn't lets take it as correct!

9 – Panzer IV
7 – Panther
6 – M3
10 – M24
9 – M48
9 – M60
9 – Mk IV Male
3 – Churchill
13 – Centurion
8 – T34
6 – T55
7 – Char B

@ Last Hussar- So is the M3 the Lee or Stuart?

On my vote, I took it be the Lee/Grant.

Repeating my previous
Heal= M-3, Hurt – T-55, Churchill
9 – Panzer IV
7 – Panther
7 – M3
10 – M24
9 – M48
9 – M60
9 – Mk IV Male
2 – Churchill
13 – Centurion
8 – T34
5 – T55
7 – Char B
The M-3 designation is the most confusing thing the U.S. Army ever did; I take it as the Lee/Grant which is confusing as well.

HEal – Churchill
Hurt – M48, M60

9 – Panzer IV
7 – Panther
7 – M3
10 – M24
8 – M48
8 – M60
9 – Mk IV Male
3 – Churchill
13 – Centurion
8 – T34
5 – T55
7 – Char B

Ok, Checked all the way back to my last post – 6 posts.

This is correct. If it isn't lets take it as correct!

It wasn't. There was a mistake right after my post. Correct is:-

9 – Panzer IV
8 – Panther
7 – M3
10 – M24
8 – M48
8 – M60
9 – Mk IV Male
3 – Churchill
13 – Centurion
8 – T34
5 – T55
7 – Char B

I didn't even think about the 2 different M3's. Its the Pentagon's fault for the confusion. Assume the Lee/Grant, based on what the majority here seem to think (and it was Monty's command tank, with false 37mm

Hurt Centurion and Panzer IV
Heal M24

8 – Panzer IV
8 – Panther
7 – M3
11 – M24
8 – M48
8 – M60
9 – Mk IV Male
3 – Churchill
12 – Centurion
8 – T34
5 – T55
7 – Char B

Hurt Centurion and Churchill
Heal Panther

8 – Panzer IV
9 – Panther
7 – M3
11 – M24
8 – M48
8 – M60
9 – Mk IV Male
2 – Churchill
11 – Centurion
8 – T34
5 – T55
7 – Char B