Help support TMP


"Horse Foot and Guns" Topic


Horse, Foot and Guns

13 Posts

All members in good standing are free to post here. Opinions expressed here are solely those of the posters, and have not been cleared with nor are they endorsed by The Miniatures Page.

For more information, see the TMP FAQ.


Back to the Horse, Foot and Guns Rules Board


Areas of Interest

18th Century
Napoleonic
American Civil War
19th Century
World War One

Featured Hobby News Article


Featured Profile Article

Land of the Free: Elemental Analysis

Taking a look at elements in Land of the Free.


442 hits since 2 Jan 2017
©1994-2020 Bill Armintrout
Comments or corrections?

Hagar the Horrible25 Nov 2011 3:34 a.m. PST

I saw this prototype set of Rules on Phil Barkers website. Has anyone ever played these? If so, how did it go?

Bob the Temple Builder25 Nov 2011 3:44 a.m. PST

I played them many years ago … And they worked quite well although they are probably a bit too abstracted for some people.

Maddaz11125 Nov 2011 4:05 a.m. PST

Played them, enjoyed them, will buy them on release, and play them.

Feel very good for Napoleonic, suitable for big battles, produce good results. I am less certain that they will feel realistic for Colonial actions, and I think they will simulate the early wars of the 20th century less well.

I am assured that SYW-FPW period is best part of the rules, and would probably not play WSS with them.

MajorB25 Nov 2011 4:17 a.m. PST

The early versions were promising, but over time as PB has responded to every critic they have got more and more clunky. I would recommend DBA-HX as a better alternative.
link

Martin Rapier25 Nov 2011 6:44 a.m. PST

I played the early versions (late 90s) a lot, but lost interest when it turned into DBM with muskets/rifles.

There are a lot of really, really good ideas in there, sadly now buried under page after page of modifiers, exceptions, additions and general crap.

The earlier versions used 1 base to a division (roughly), the newer ones are more 'detailed' which is half the problem. There is a decent game in there if you work at it, we've done WSS, Napoleonics and APW with them.

Ammianus25 Nov 2011 6:53 a.m. PST

For simple straighforward Napoleonic rules, I recommend DBN (cousin of DBA).
dbnwargaming.co.uk

I use it to play corps on corps games.

Be sure to look in their downloads section; contains a conversion for ACW too.

Whirlwind25 Nov 2011 7:15 a.m. PST

I've played them a few times and enjoyed them. It pays to spend a bit of time working out which bits you need to totally ignore for any given period, that makes the game a bit smoother (this isn't hard to do, most periods only use a couple of the troop types on offer). I ended up improvising a couple of QR sheets which helped.

The free army lists are okay as well.

Martin Rapier25 Nov 2011 9:12 a.m. PST

Yes, do a QR sheet and eliminate all the non essential stuff. You can fit the whole thing onto a couple of sides of A4, one side with a small font.

Just doing the sheet helps understand the logic and you can tailor it to period specific troop types.

pink panzer25 Nov 2011 3:35 p.m. PST

Been playing its various versions since the early 90s, but as Martin has commented, as more period-specific 'chrome' has been added (which the market demands) some of the fun has gone out of it. That said, give it a try.

Toy Soldier Green25 Nov 2011 5:16 p.m. PST

I like them. Also use HOTT for gunpowder rules too.

Hagar the Horrible27 Nov 2011 12:20 a.m. PST

Thanks for all the comments. They were helpful and enlightening!

Rob

Personal logo Narratio Supporting Member of TMP28 Nov 2011 11:44 p.m. PST

I liked them, after I went through and deleted anything and everything that was not relevent to the period I was playing that is.

As is usual, Phil needs a translator to take it into into common English and then an editor to sort the mess out. But there are some neat ideas hidden away in the If's, But's and Alternates.

Allan Mountford29 Nov 2011 5:20 a.m. PST

There will also be more detailed companion sets, initially "Tricorne & Musket" covering 1701-1790, "Shako and Bayonet" for 1791-1850, and "Kepi & Rifle" for 1851-1914.

I understand that "Kepi & Rifle" already exists in draft.

There is also an unoffical "Shako & Bayonet" on the Yahoo HFG site.

- Allan

Sorry - only verified members can post on the forums.