Help support TMP

"What do you think of quidditch?" Topic

23 Posts

All members in good standing are free to post here. Opinions expressed here are solely those of the posters, and have not been cleared with nor are they endorsed by The Miniatures Page.

For more information, see the TMP FAQ.

Back to the Movies Plus Board

Back to the Books Plus Board

Back to the Sports Plus Board

514 hits since 16 Apr 2016
©1994-2018 Bill Armintrout
Comments or corrections?

Winston Smith Supporting Member of TMP16 Apr 2016 10:08 a.m. PST

Or however it's spelled. …

The Harry Potter game played by wizzards on broomsticks.

Let me see if I get it right…
A bunch of guys do all the hard work, accumulating points through skill and force, and at the last minute a skinny little runt who has been hanging on the edges, Flashman like, can swoop in at the last minute and win the whole thing, regardless of the score. Is that about right?

Personal logo Saber6 Supporting Member of TMP Fezian16 Apr 2016 10:59 a.m. PST

Got it in one

Terrement Supporting Member of TMP Inactive Member16 Apr 2016 1:44 p.m. PST

Yep. It, like many other things in the world of mug glens, is unfair and probably rigged by the power brokers not even in the game.

platypus01au16 Apr 2016 1:57 p.m. PST

Two words. Plot device.

Winston Smith Supporting Member of TMP16 Apr 2016 3:20 p.m. PST

Plot distraction that fills many tedious pages.

Mr Elmo16 Apr 2016 5:04 p.m. PST

Goals score 10 points
Catching the snitch scores 50 points and ends the game

So if the +50 doesn't put you in the lead, don't catch the snitch!

StarfuryXL516 Apr 2016 7:16 p.m. PST

Catching the snitch scores 150 points.

zoneofcontrol16 Apr 2016 7:19 p.m. PST

Snitches get stitches! Jes' sayin'

platypus01au16 Apr 2016 8:13 p.m. PST

Winston thinks it is a plot distraction, which to some degree it is, but Hogwarts is just a copy of any English Public School. Rowling has to make Potter a "Hero", and while he can't be a muscle-bound jock, he has to excel in the School Sport. So Quidditch had to have a rule that allows Potter to be a sporting hero, but at the same time be a bit nerdy. This is why the Snitch is a plot device. I actually suspect Rowling came up with the Snitch thing first (because of what Harry has to do in one of the rooms in the Philosopher's Stone), and came up with the rest afterward because a game where people have to hunt down a flying, golden golf-ball would be a trifle boring.

Personal logo etotheipi Sponsoring Member of TMP17 Apr 2016 4:15 a.m. PST

Actually, it's a really good victory point system for wargaming – having one objective that significantly (but not totally) overbalances the rest of the VP system. It keeps players working a two part strategy (as the means of the objectives are very different) and creates a shift in the timbre (dramatic tension) of the game if the VP delta gets close to the overbalancing objective.

The only problem I had with it was the 150 points compared to the sum and pattern of the 10 pointers in a typical game. If you routinely expected 70 or 80 goals and it was typical to be eight to ten goals ahead, then the 150 points works.

Streitax Inactive Member17 Apr 2016 8:41 a.m. PST

Yeah, but a dragon really wouldn't heat a goblin.

Waco Joe17 Apr 2016 9:16 a.m. PST

BTW here is the link to the US Quidditch Cup tournament. link

My Aggies are still in it! grin

Winston Smith Supporting Member of TMP17 Apr 2016 5:11 p.m. PST

It may be a really good victory point system for wargaming, but as a sport it sucks.

45thdiv18 Apr 2016 12:05 p.m. PST

Well, if you don't like it, why are you reading a book written for young teens? It is a plot device just like a y other plot device in any other book. And this one is for kids.

Just saying.

And why does Sam keep pestering that guy to eat green eggs and ham? Don't even get me started on a fish out of water.

Personal logo Parzival Supporting Member of TMP18 Apr 2016 3:53 p.m. PST

I'm a huge fan of Rowling's work on the HP series, but I've always thought she didn't quite think the snitch rules through, but tossed out "150" points to be a cool-sounding arbitrarily high number. She later had to go through considerable effort to make catching the snitch a ploy that sometimes doesn't produce instant victory.

Of course, there's one additional effect no one considers: a game of quidditch cannot end until the snitch is caught, which more than allows for the standard goals to exceed the value of a caught snitch, given a long enough game. All one has to do is score 16 goals!

Smokey Roan19 Apr 2016 6:24 p.m. PST

"A bunch of guys do all the hard work, accumulating points through skill and force"

I think you are making very liberal use of "skill" and "hard work".

The ONLY thing worse than the movie version of the sport? The REAL sport, where they hop around on broomsticks pretending to fly….well…futbol is worse, I admit.

Any sport where Harry Potter is a physical specimen and top athlete is NOT a sport.

Then again, the NFL is on track to make quidditch look like Rollerball….

Hafen von Schlockenberg Supporting Member of TMP19 Apr 2016 8:47 p.m. PST

That's right,Smokey, we need more head cases in the NFL,not less.

The points disparity in Quidditch reminded me of Magic: "Here comes my Total Invicibility Card!"

If I wanted to play a sport from a movie,it would be this:

Buff Orpington Inactive Member20 Apr 2016 3:05 a.m. PST

Makes more sense than baseball.

ScottWashburn Sponsoring Member of TMP25 Apr 2016 12:11 p.m. PST

I'll stick with 43-man Squamish! (how many recognize that?)

Xintao Supporting Member of TMP12 May 2016 8:35 a.m. PST

My twin daughters play Qudditch in college. They run around holding a broom. They have loads of fun.

In the movie, the rules don't work. In the muggle sport, grabbing the snitch(a player running around with a flag football ribbon) ends the game and gets you 30 points. Works pretty well. The 150 point book version is stupid.

Old Wolfman13 May 2016 6:47 a.m. PST

I remember that one,Scott. Mad Magazine from way back.

Great War Ace Inactive Member13 May 2016 7:59 a.m. PST

She learned the lesson, "take six pages to describe something that should take place in one", very well from the "King" of blather, his heinous, Stephen….

Great War Ace Inactive Member13 May 2016 8:00 a.m. PST

Go ahead and accuse me of envy, I will plead guilty….

Sorry - only verified members can post on the forums.