
"Game terrain" Topic
7 Posts
All members in good standing are free to post here. Opinions expressed here are solely those of the posters, and have not been cleared with nor are they endorsed by The Miniatures Page.
Remember that you can Stifle members so that you don't have to read their posts.
For more information, see the TMP FAQ.
Back to the WWII Discussion Message Board Back to the Cold War (1946-1989) Message Board
Areas of InterestWorld War Two on the Land Modern
Featured Hobby News Article
Featured Link
Featured Ruleset
Featured Showcase Article A pair of Schwimmwagen pass through my workbench as they get rebased.
Featured Workbench Article The Editor dabbles with online printing.
|
UshCha  | 25 Oct 2026 1:06 p.m. PST |
First the caveats. This addresses only those players who as a guide use ground scales of 1mm on table representing 1m or less. Second probably only WW2 onwards since there were earlier wars but representing for instance in England the current field layouts originated sonly from 1760 when the enclosure acts started. It may apply earlier but I have insufficient information to make any useful affirmation. The post only applies to real world fantasy/exercises that take place where real world terrain is an assumption. In addition rules that use say exponential range allocation are excluded as they cannot model real world situations. I can provide a boring explanation for this but it seems unnecessary. So, given these caveats if there is anybody out there that even recognises the requirement/Intention what do you consider??
So the question how representative of the real world are you table layouts? As an example we restrict sight line to a maximum of about 1500m or less based on a Brassies statement that intravisibility is limited to about 10% above that figure generally for northern Europe where we set our scenarios. Typically or hedge and ditch lines are spaced based on typical map analysis of the situation. Villages are spaced about 2000m apart based on BAOR assumptions. Typically we reflect sight lines but contour heights are not. represented accurately (model to ground scale discrepancies). Road spacing is based on that of a representative area of real map. Our observation based on limited experience is that many tables have far to few hedges, ditches and villages than the real world. So what in game terms (not just in artistic models but in tactical terms) do you model and why? |
John the OFM  | 25 Oct 2026 4:27 p.m. PST |
I primarily game in "horse and musket" 28mm. Some regimental scale (to me that means that each "unit" is regimental size) and skirmish. Some consider that a Brigade or Division level game. Define it at your peril. I've always followed the dictum that hills, most trees, dragons, etc are "indeterminate scale". In a regimental game, trees go on a "template", meaning they can be moved to "make room". In a skirmish game, I USUALLY, but not always, treat a tree as an immovable thing. If it gets in the way, it cannot be moved. It gets in the way! Buildings in a skirmish game are real. I made some remarks about their insides in a Western game a few days ago. But in a regimental game… it's scenario dependent. Perhaps "scenario dependent" is a universal key. |
| Martin Rapier | 26 Oct 2026 12:03 a.m. PST |
For most battles, regardless of period, I base the terrain on whatever maps are available (assuming they are historical) but the actual terrain representation depends on the level of game. For very tactical stuff (eg 12" = 100 yards) I will try and position each hedge, building etc correctly although most 1:25000 maps only show wood boundaries, so that is area terrain. For grand tactical and up, the terrain becomes more representational, just the militarily significant features. Watersheds, watercourses, bad going, roads, BUAs etc and terrain density is factored into the maximum location ranges so if there are small fields bordered by tall hedges, units can't see very far! Ultimately though, it is a game, not an excercise in military map reading so I abstract more stuff the higher it goes, particularly eg location distance bonuses for occupying higher elevations. |
UshCha  | 26 Oct 2026 12:56 a.m. PST |
Those were a suprising and interesting responces. I was expecting more abstrsct replies. Thankyou. Our woods are a template as others with moveable trees. In a recent study, yes I am that sad, I read up on UK forestry roads of todays standard and was surprised, they ar built to take 44 tonnes, Forestry machinary typical max I guess. That made me look harder ar the maps, I have 1;25000 for the UK (cycling is anothet passion)and realised the tracks are often around 400m between them give or take. I now try to get that density about right, Before I never put tracks in. Simple experinec told be there were tracks but never really got an impression of how dense thet were. Too me wargames is about understanding a bit of the world. When I built my first Fold flat card buildings I realised how little I looked at buildings, I now look more at achitecture and appreciate it far more than I used to , just because of wargames. Intersting to see other folk take terrain layouut seriously. |
| Murvihill | 26 Oct 2026 4:15 a.m. PST |
I think of model buildings on the game table to be aglomerations of buildings, roads to include the cleared aprons on either side and streams to include the flood plain. |
John the OFM  | 26 Oct 2026 7:40 a.m. PST |
I played in a 1920 IRA game, in a village where the buildings were "real". Someone tried to move a building so his Crossley Tender coukd "fit down the alley". 🙄 He was universally admonished. The poor Governor General was successfully ambushed. |
Mister Tibbles  | 29 Oct 2026 3:43 p.m. PST |
I game WWII in 15mm at a 1:1 scale, with individually based figures. Most of my gaming focuses on France after the D-Day landings, and much of the countryside and many of the villages haven't changed all that much. I like using Google Maps (I used to use Google Earth) to get a feel for what the villages and terrain actually look like. I often compare modern satellite imagery with wartime aerial reconnaissance photos to see what's changed and what hasn't. One of my favorite tools is Google Maps Street View. I'll follow the same roads the troops traveled, which not only gives me ideas for painting my buildings (all of which are 3D printed), but also provides some amazing insight into lines of sight and how the terrain affected combat. Seeing the Normandy hedgerows from ground level really drives home just how intimidating they must have been. That's something I'm trying to capture on my tabletop. Ditches are another important feature, although they're much harder to represent convincingly on a flat gaming table. |
|