Editor in Chief Bill  | 20 Oct 2026 3:34 p.m. PST |
With its own class of nuclear-powered attack submarines, the ROK Navy would be more operationally independent. It would also be a stronger and more versatile ally. Proceedings magazine: link |
John the OFM  | 20 Oct 2026 7:03 p.m. PST |
So they can join the Kool Kids Klub? |
Oberlindes Sol LIC  | 20 Oct 2026 8:37 p.m. PST |
That does make more sense than "Social Security Number", I suppose. |
| Andrew Walters | 21 Oct 2026 8:54 a.m. PST |
I'm glad they're doing it and I'm glad we're helping. They want it because North Korea is dabbling in subs, and while up to a couple of years ago South Korea could have relied on the US to help with that we have now communicated to the world that we are not a reliable partner. It will definitely give them more status in the world, and that's not necessarily bad. A good SSN not only helps you keep North Korean SSBNs under control they're a great way to keep an eye on things. I may or may not have overheard a USN SSN crewman mention going into a North Korean harbor, raising a periscope, and counting ships. Not to mention cutting and tapping undersea cables. It makes a lot of sense for South Korea to want an SSN. |
| OSCS74 | 21 Oct 2026 1:17 p.m. PST |
Andrew, What war did NATO fight that US did not? An example: • Yugoslavia / Kosovo (1999): NATO carried out Operation Allied Force, a 78-day air campaign against the Federal Republic of Yugoslavia to stop human rights abuses and the ethnic cleansing of Kosovo Albanians. The US did 80% of the sorties the other 13 NATO countries did 20%. Is that fair? Does not seem to be fair at all. Even I was flown over there. How did Yugoslavia threaten NATO? Why protect people that refuse to protect theirselves? Example Bundeswehr 500,000 troops during the Cold War in the 1980s, dropped sharply following reunification and the suspension of conscription, and currently stands at approximately 186,000 active-duty soldiers. Is Germany a dependable ally? South Korea should be able to protect itself form North Korea. The US should not have any troops stationed there. |
| Striker | 21 Oct 2026 2:22 p.m. PST |
I haven't got my issue handy but is an ssn that much more useful than a diesel sub, cost, training, support? If they are only going after the North, who probably aren't sailing the ocean blue in numbers or range, a coastal boat should work and be cheaper, numbers matter. It would be a prestige point but considering costs is it worth that much. Does the morth even have ssbns? According to wiki they have midgets, romeos, and whiskeys. Maybe an unmanned submersible sub hunter/suicide drone would be better? |
John the OFM  | 21 Oct 2026 8:59 p.m. PST |
Let's not treat the North Korea as a comic opera, shall we? 🙄 |
| David Manley | 22 Oct 2026 12:00 p.m. PST |
Does Japan want an SSN? If yes then the ROKN will want one too |
Grattan54  | 22 Oct 2026 12:54 p.m. PST |
Striker, You confuse me. You complain that Germany isn't doing enough militarily and is a poor ally but then you seem to oppose South Korea from strenghtening it's military and becoming a better ally. Do I have that right? |
| Striker | 23 Oct 2026 2:03 a.m. PST |
Where did I say I opposed Korea being a stronger ally? I'm asking why they would go through the trouble of making an SSN. If you want to take questioning defense plans as being a poor ally then that's your problem. Looking at my post please show where I mention Germany, who btw has diesel subs and makes them pretty well from the little I've read. I was hoping somwone would have info on their strategic goals regarding the sub choice, but appaerntly asking about military projects brings up loyalty? Korea should e as strong as possible to lessen US support if nothing else, maybe others should follow their lead. |
| OSCS74 | 23 Oct 2026 4:07 p.m. PST |
Striker +1 I also want SK to have a strong navy. Not only a deterent to NK but also China. I want the same for Japan. Both countries have very good Navies. Compare SK to Germany. • South Korea (ROKN): • Active Ships: ~150 to 160 ships • Destroyers: 13 (including heavy AEGIS-equipped Sejong the Great-class) • Frigates: 18 (Chungnam, Daegu, Incheon classes) • Submarines: 20 to 22 diesel-electric and AIP boats (including indigenous KSS-III ballistic/attack submarines) • Amphibious/LPD Ships: 9 to 21 units (including Dokdo-class LPH landing platform docks) • Personnel: ~70,000 active personnel (plus ~29,000 marines) • Germany (Deutsche Marine): • Active Ships: ~72 ships • Destroyers: 0 (Germany operates no multi-mission anti-air/ballistic missile destroyers) • Frigates: 11 active (expanding via new MEKO A-200 DEU / F128 programs) • Submarines: 6 Type 212A diesel-electric boats • Amphibious Ships: 0 dedicated amphibious assault/landing ships • Corvettes / Patrol / Mine Warfare: 6 corvettes, 10 patrol craft, 12 mine warfare ships, plus auxiliaries. I would like to see the Germans double their Navy instead of depending on US. |