
"China Needs Russia in the Fight" Topic
36 Posts
All members in good standing are free to post here. Opinions expressed here are solely those of the posters, and have not been cleared with nor are they endorsed by The Miniatures Page.
In order to respect possible copyright issues, when quoting from a book or article, please quote no more than three paragraphs.
For more information, see the TMP FAQ.
Back to the Ultramodern Warfare (2016-present) Message Board
Areas of InterestModern
Featured Hobby News Article
Featured Recent Link
Featured Workbench Article
Featured Profile Article The Editor heads for Vicksburg...
|
Please sign in to your membership account, or, if you are not yet a member, please sign up for your free membership account.
| Tango01 | 09 Oct 2026 12:43 p.m. PST |
"During a four-hour meeting in Brussels in July 2025, Chinese Foreign Minister Wang Yi reportedly told the European Union's top diplomat, Kaja Kallas, that China could not afford a Russian defeat in Ukraine. This was a simple power calculus: if Russia lost, the United States would be free to shift its full attention to Beijing. The remark came more than three years into the Sino-Russian "no-limits partnership" that Presidents Xi and Putin declared on the eve of the full-scale Russian invasion of Ukraine in 2022. The exchange, first reported by the South China Morning Post and omitted from the Chinese government's official account of the meeting, showed how Beijing actually views the war. China has long presented itself as a neutral party interested in peace. In private, however, its foreign minister in effect acknowledged that Russia's survival as a fighting power serves its global interests. Beijing's siding with Moscow goes beyond rhetoric, and it goes beyond simply buying a great deal of Russian energy. China has largely replaced Europe as the principal market for Russian hydrocarbons. Before 2022, Russia's energy infrastructure and commercial relationships were heavily oriented toward Europe. Western sanctions and Europe's diversification forced Moscow to redirect enormous volumes eastward, and China absorbed much of it, often at a discount on Russian crude. Since February 2022, mineral fuels have accounted, on average, for about 70% of the value of China's imports from Russia. The result is a complementary trade: Russia sells commodities, above all energy, and China sells manufactured goods…" link Armand |
| Tango01 | 12 Oct 2026 4:59 p.m. PST |
China is Not Just Claiming the South China Sea. It is Learning to Govern It link
Armand |
SBminisguy  | 13 Oct 2026 7:41 a.m. PST |
"During a four-hour meeting in Brussels in July 2025, Chinese Foreign Minister Wang Yi reportedly told the European Union's top diplomat, Kaja Kallas, that China could not afford a Russian defeat in Ukraine.This was a simple power calculus: if Russia lost, the United States would be free to shift its full attention to Beijing. Huh -- and people still wonder why Trump wants to end the war in Ukraine…stop the killing, reduce tensions and promote stability in Europe, disrupt the Russian-Chinese alliance and shift attention and resources to position against China… |
Grattan54  | 13 Oct 2026 8:52 a.m. PST |
Then why is he buying diesel from the Russians, which gives them more money to fight Ukraine? How is having an aggressive dictator win his war helping the US? |
SBminisguy  | 13 Oct 2026 9:11 a.m. PST |
The US is not the end point for Russian diesel, the end point is the global market. Diesel is a fungible product. Even though the US produces more diesel than it needs to domestically consume, the fuel is sold on the global market -- so if a buyer in France will pay more than a buyer in Texas, the sale goes to France. So that drives prices up in Texas as that buyer needs to pay more than the French buyer to meet their demand needs. So by INCREASING global supply, you REDUCE demand pressure on the global diesel fuel market. Prices in the US will fall as more US produced diesel is sold to domestic buyers rather than global buyers. And a question for YOU: Shortly after the Russian invasion of Ukraine it became obvious that Putin's blitzkrieg had failed and he wanted out before the failure became prominent. Putin basically wanted to declare victory and go home and Zelensky wanted the war to end before it got worse. So Russia and Ukraine were both in peace talks brokered by Turkey and Israel, and the then PM of Israel has said that a deal was being negotiated when the Biden Admin and the EU stepped in to KILL the peace deal. Zelensky was warned that if he signed a peace deal with Russia, then the US and the EU would cut him off at the knees -- no financial aid, no humanitarian aid, no military aid, no intel aid. Ukraine would be cut adrift to face Russia alone. The peace deal died. WHY did the Biden Admin and the EU want to kill the peace deal and prolong the war? |
| Tango01 | 13 Oct 2026 1:17 p.m. PST |
Who really beleive what Putin could signed?… There were several factors which halted the talks…
In early April 2022, the discovery of mass civilian executions by withdrawing Russian forces in Bucha radically shifted public and political sentiment in Ukraine, making territorial concessions politically impossible for President Volodymyr Zelensky.
The draft documents showed that major issues—including the status of Crimea and the Donbas borders, as well as caps on the size of Ukraine's future military—were never mutually agreed upon.
Western governments emphasize that they did not dictate Ukraine's decisions. Rather, they provided the economic and military aid that gave Kyiv the viable alternative to keep fighting for its sovereignty rather than accepting an unfavorable conditional surrender.
I'm not taking sides with Biden—not at all—the only thing I'm pointing out is that he has always publicly opposed the Russians and their actions in Ukraine. Armand |
SBminisguy  | 13 Oct 2026 5:30 p.m. PST |
There were several factors which halted the talks… Sorry – I disagee and feel Bucha is the excuse used to cover what happened. The deal was being brokered in March, before Bucha was revealed. The peace talks were disrupted by pressure from the Biden Admin and EU, and then Ukrainian government broadly released images of the massacre. Recall that even by this time, so early in the war, the Ukrainian government had exercised State control over all media and it controlled what information about the war could be released. Boris Johnson's "special trip" to Kyiv in early April 2022 sealed the deal -- there would be no peace, only war. And I'd really like to know why. Yes yes, bad evil Russia and all that, BUT the established global track record in conflicts is that typically after the shooting starts, global influencer/peace groups and politicians try to get both sides to negotiate. Sometimes led by the UN, sometimes by NGOs, sometimes by politicians seeking fame. And this was a war IN EUROPE, highly destabilizing and destructive -- not an African backwater (no disrepect to African nations) or someplace hard to reach -- it's on the border of the EU, you can drive to Kiyiv. But not this war. There were no peace rallies in the West. No MoveOn or Code Pink or Peace Now movement. The politicians usually eager to rush to the cameras as peace brokers were silent and camera shy. And we actually saw the War Drums beat loudly. If you said, Peace Now! – you were decried as weak, anti-democratic, a Putin Puppet -- even a Nazi! Really, calling for peace makes you a Nazi? If you ask, "Say, we would like to know where all the hundreds of billions of $$$ sent to Ukraine have gone" – you were decried as weak, anti-democratic, a Putin Puppet -- even a Nazi! If you ask, what is the plan for victory? What is the definition of victory? – you are told only unrealistic Russian unconditional surrender is acceptable and if you don't support that -- you were decried as weak, anti-democratic, a Putin Puppet -- even a Nazi! See my point? |
| Cuprum2 | 13 Oct 2026 6:17 p.m. PST |
China is no one's friend… It needs this war for many reasons. It ties the hands of the US; it generates significant profits—through sales of drones and components to all parties in the conflict; it lowers the cost of Russian energy supplies for China (or rather, it *did* lower them—costs have risen substantially now); and the war makes Russia dependent on China… Grattan54, take a look at the stock market quotes following Trump's announcement about the deal… And you'll understand why he did it))) SBminisguy, Bucha was a staged provocation designed to derail the negotiations. |
SBminisguy  | 14 Oct 2026 1:27 p.m. PST |
SBminisguy, Bucha was a staged provocation designed to derail the negotiations. I have no doubt it happened, fits with Russian's other "internal" conflicts like Chechnya. But it was magnified and exploited as an excuse for the peace talks being killed by the EU and Biden. In contrast, at the same time as the revelation of 70 being killed by Russian forces in Bucha, Boko Haram in Nigeria butchered an entire village -- killed 150 men and teen boys, the elderly, babies and pregnant women and kidnapped like 30-40 women and teen girls. Yawn. Nobody cared, no EU outcry, no special breaking news reports. |
| Tango01 | 14 Oct 2026 4:29 p.m. PST |
Sorry… but what a terrible comparison… if we're going to justify massacres based on the number of victims or the location where they take place… then there's a problem… this thread isn't about Africa or other places plagued by primitive forms of terror… we already know that posting about conflicts far from Europe or America holds no interest whatsoever for readers—much like my thread on "Tigrayan leaders say new war with Ethiopian government"—but that in no way justifies or diminishes the conduct of the Russians toward the civilian population in Ukraine. Armand
|
| Tango01 | 14 Oct 2026 5:19 p.m. PST |
Since we're on the subject of massacres throughout history… here's an interesting list of the worst ones, where you can see our dear Russian friends really shining with their fine disposition. link Armand |
SBminisguy  | 14 Oct 2026 8:31 p.m. PST |
Sorry… but what a terrible comparison… if we're going to justify massacres based on the number of victims or the location where they take place Sorry -- can you read? I didn't justify anything, only called attention to the contrast between politically useful massacres like Bucha and inconvenient massacres like the one in Nigeria. that in no way justifies or diminishes the conduct of the Russians toward the civilian population in Ukraine. Agreed, point out where I said otherwise. The point I made is simple -- the Bucha massacre happened and that's all on Russia, but it was used as the excuse to explain why the peace talks failed instead of the reality that the EU and the Biden Admin threatened Zelensky if he signed a deal. And you still have NOT answered my question – WHY did the EU and the Biden Admin want to continue the war? Where was "The Peace Movement" and Greta Thunberg and Code Pink and MoveOn marching for peace? Why, when every other war immediately attracts people trying to resolve a peace deal is this war different and the usual cast of peace makers are instead war makers? * 1.5 MILLION casualties. * $800 USD BILLION in damage and estimated recovery costs * Over $400 USD BILLION in aid to Ukraine * Global disruption of energy, grain and fertilizer supplies that resulted in an additional 43 MILLION people in Africa and other developing countries pushed into malnourishment status, 23 MILLION categorized as "extreme hunger" and hundreds of thousands of hunger related deaths. This is the most costly and destructive war since WW2…what's your answer? |
| Tango01 | 14 Oct 2026 9:55 p.m. PST |
I perceive an unpleasant and aggressive response from you… how can you ask me if I know how to read?… besides… who is forcing me to answer ANYTHING you ask?… It is true that English is not my first language—it's not even my third—but given how long I've been writing on TMP, I think it's fair to say I understand at least some English. I have no interest in weighing in on President Biden's administration—whom you make a habit of tearing down at every opportunity—as I am not from your country and the underlying political divide there does not concern me.
You should accept that you don't have a monopoly on the truth and that there are other opinions, such as…
"A recurring anti-Western disinformation narrative that falsely accuses Biden's US administration, the EU and the UK of prolonging the war in Ukraine and attempting to plunge Russia into chaos.
This piece is a part of a wider disinformation campaign portraying Europe and Biden's administration as a warmongering actor, and accuses them of not having the desire to achieve peace. There is no evidence to indicate that the European countries or the Biden administration were eager to prolong the war in Ukraine. Joe Biden warned Russia, even before the full-scale invasion, that the West would respond decisively to any invasion of Ukraine. After the start of the full-scale invasion, then-President Joe Biden called for peace in Ukraine several times. As regards Europe, EU officials have several times stated that it is up to Ukraine only, as the victim of Russia's aggression, to decide when peace talks with Russia may be possible and in which terms to end the war. The EU supports a peaceful solution to the conflict, ensuring that any peace agreement respects Ukraine's independence, sovereignty, and territorial integrity. During the war, European countries provided Ukraine with €155.00 EUR billion in financial support, while the United States contributed €114.00 EUR billion. These figures demonstrate that the war has been costly for both. It also indicates that neither the U.S. nor European countries have had an interest in prolonging the conflict in Ukraine. The Pro-Kremlin disinformation apparatus has systematically instrumentalised the narrative that Russia wants peace in Ukraine in contrast to the West, but, as evidenced by Russia's actions in Ukraine, such statements are merely empty PR stunts deployed to garner support for Russia's war of aggression in Ukraine…" link
And whatever might be said about negotiations, diplomatic pressures, or unwritten agreements—none of that matters to me in the slightest… there is only one aggressor here, and that is Russia. The rest is just empty fanfare… Armand
|
35thOVI  | 15 Oct 2026 3:03 a.m. PST |
SB +1 Nobody outside of Russia and her allies questions that Russia was the aggressor. Tango you are being disingenuous. You post articles often and make comments within the articles that take sides against many actions or inactions of the current administration. So yes, taking sides. Maybe you don't perceive it as such, but such it is. After the conflict started, those in NATO saw this war as a way to drain Russia of military resources, money and hopefully weaken or have the Russians remove Putin. . Leaders talked about it openly as did political commentators. Even those on TMP talked about. By default, a quick ending would not have achieved any of those. As to Biden: President Joe Biden suggested in January 2022 that the U.S. and allied response to a Russian move into Ukraine "depends on what it does," distinguishing between a "minor incursion" and a full-scale invasion • The "Minor Incursion" Comment: During a press conference, Biden said, "It's one thing if it's a minor incursion and then we end up having a fight about what to do and not do, et cetera," while warning that a major attack would be a "disaster for Russia". • Criticism: The remark sparked concern among NATO allies and drew a sharp rebuttal from Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy, who tweeted that there are no "minor incursions" or "minor casualties".
Only after world criticism did Joe, or whoever wrote the responses, come out with a tougher stance. I have been posting about radical fundamentalist Islamic atrocities including Nigeria for a long time. Some have been unhappy about that on TMP. But it does not make it any less true. A new example: Yemen's Iran-backed Houthi rebels launched a series of deadly missile and drone attacks against King Khalid International Airport in Riyadh, Saudi Arabia. • First Strike (Saturday, October 10/11, 2026): A ballistic and cruise missile attack hit the main terminal at Riyadh's airport, killing at least 13 people—including an American citizen, an Indian national, four Saudi citizens, two Bangladeshi nationals, and individuals from Egypt, Jordan, Palestine, Syria, and Sudan—and injuring over 300 others. • Second Strike (Sunday, October 11, 2026): A follow-up projectile struck Terminal 4 at the same airport, killing 1 person (a Pakistani resident) and injuring 11 more.
Many on TMP were quick to condemn the U.S. for a strike on an Iranian girls school (a location the radical Islamists use for their military.. (see Hamas, Hezbollah, etc.). They condemn Russian attacks on Ukrainian civilians. But the Houthi attacks, Iranian, Nigerian attacks on civilians as a practice, where are the posts here??? 🦗 🦗 Answer: They don't fulfill agendas. Radical Fundamentalist Islam is EVERYBODYS enemy. Look at those killed in the airport: western, middle eastern, Asian. , Christian, Muslim. They kill anybody and everybody! They don't care! I won't respond to anything else, SB can. |
SBminisguy  | 15 Oct 2026 6:13 a.m. PST |
Hey, Tango, did you know the link you posted is from the EUvsDisinfo (also styled EU vs Disinfo). It is the flagship public project of the East StratCom Task Force, a unit within the European External Action Service (EEAS)—the EU's diplomatic service. It is an EU-run strategic communications platform designed to promote EU messaging. So it's hardly " the Truth." |
SBminisguy  | 15 Oct 2026 6:19 a.m. PST |
I won't respond to anything else, SB can Not like it's a real discussion anyways… I ask questions and get accusations… Maybe someday a study on the politics and propaganda of this war will be made, trying to explain how the usual peacemakers became war boosters, and a foreign war became a domestic political litmus test for the usually anti-war Democrats and European liberal parties. |
35thOVI  | 15 Oct 2026 6:39 a.m. PST |
SB do you find it hypocritical that those who blast the U.S. for the school bombing and the Israelis anytime a Palestinian "civilian" dies by an Israeli weapon, never complain about the much, much higher civilian death toll perpetuated by Radical Islam… Iran, Hamas, Hezbollah, ISSUS, the Houthis, al-Qaeda, Boko Haram and all the rest, including internal Islamic terrorists in their own countries? Those countries and groups care NOT who dies. Don't even make an effort to avoid it. Are gleeful when they do die. Even brag about it publicly. |
SBminisguy  | 15 Oct 2026 7:54 a.m. PST |
Yes, a bit -- I'm as much interested in the break down of basic "If this, then that" logic chains and critical thought. For instance, the Bucha Massacre for which Russia is to be condemned utterly -- why did Zelensky choose the timing he did to release the news? Even so early in the war, Zelensky had swiftly moved to exert direct State control over the media and nothing was said without government permission. So why then? And why not Peace? There is no other conflict I can think of where there is such active opposition to exploring a negotiated end to a war. Oh, wait -- I remember, there is one…Libya. There were no peace marches to stop the war in Libya, and the EU engaged in that war because it MET THEIR NEEDS. Khadaffi had started giving oil concessions to China, and the Europeans were freaking out -- it was a strategic and economic issue for them. And so they and the Obama Admin created a "humanitarian crisis worry" over protests in Libya during the Arab Spring as the justification to start a war to topple Khadaffi. And they did -- as Hillary chortled, "We came, we saw, HE DIED!" And so did hundreds of thousands killed in civil war, and millions of refugees, and the Benghazi compound stormed and all that. What did they get out of it? OIL, much needed oil. Contrast that to the Balkans Wars after the break-up of Yugoslavia and the intense EU and US and UN diplomatic efforts to get peace deals in place to stop the killing. What do they get out of it? Nothing. No stratgic interests, no resources in the Balkans, just instability that was bad for business. Now let's return to Ukraine. Like the Libya War a US president and the EU promote conflict over conflict resolution, they pump hundreds of billions of $$ inth the war to keep Ukrain in the fight and they block all peace overtures to keep the fight going. So what's the strategic interest that the Biden Admin and the EU saw, and what's the enduring interest for the EU to keep the killing going? What do the get out of it? Questions… it's OK to ask questions… |
35thOVI  | 15 Oct 2026 8:22 a.m. PST |
SB I said when this started, the longer it lasted, the more dangerous it will become. Putin cannot leave now without losing face. You have Europe accusing Russia of sabotage within their countries. You have the ship attacks in the Baltic, Drones in NATO countries. One slip, one mistake or one individual doing an intentional act. I'll add, I knew this would not last. Neither side wants it and neither side really wants peace. Thousands die weekly and almost nothing happens. Yes, both Russia and Ukraine have targeted each other's energy and oil infrastructure following Donald Trump's unilateral announcement of an "energy ceasefire" on Sunday, October 11, 2026. [1, 2, 3]Timeline of Attacks: * Sunday, October 11, 2026: * US President Donald Trump publicly claimed that Russia and Ukraine agreed to an immediate energy ceasefire. * Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy reported that Russian forces struck multiple Ukrainian energy and gas facilities (including six key energy sites and a joint heating and power plant in Kharkiv) just hours after the truce was announced. [1, 2, 3, 4, 5] * Monday, October 12 – Wednesday, October 14, 2026: * Ukrainian forces paused major strikes on Russian energy infrastructure for about three days while accusing Russia of continuing daily attacks on Ukrainian power grids. [1, 2] * Thursday, October 15, 2026: * Ukraine officially resumed its strikes, launching a drone and missile attack against the Rosneft oil refinery in Russia's Ryazan region (about 300 km southeast of Moscow), which sparked a fire. * Russia responded with a large-scale swarm of drones overnight targeting infrastructure in central Ukraine and Kyiv.
|
| Tango01 | 15 Oct 2026 1:07 p.m. PST |
I see no issue with publishing current-affairs articles related to the leaders currently in power… what I find tiresome is that every time a discussion arises on the subject, someone chimes in with: "Ah! But…" It would seem that the "villainous" Zelensky actually accepted Trump's proposal—all while the Russians continued to bomb civilian buildings, hospitals, and so on. Naturally, he then struck back where it hurts them the most. Why is no one criticizing the Russian stance? It's as if they're mocking their own president's proposals. For me, the issue is quite simple: there is an aggressor and a victim of aggression. Which side are you on? Armand |
35thOVI  | 15 Oct 2026 1:51 p.m. PST |
Tango Articles placed out on ultramodern warfare when it relates to policies of a politician or a countries policy, are done in the vast majority of cases, because of the "perception" the individual posting is espousing. If I post an article on how Australia can no longer trust the United States because of the policies of a politician… it is political. Especially if the poster has a history of posting negative "articles" about the same politician and or country. It is the nature of the beast. Trying to say it's not, is disingenuous. If you refer to my quotes about the oil infrastructure attacks, did I accuse either side? Did I not put the dates showing who did it and when? I stick to what I said though. Neither side right now I believe wants peace. The Ukrainians believe they are making headway and Putin cannot afford to in Russias current position on the field. |
SBminisguy  | 15 Oct 2026 3:13 p.m. PST |
For me, the issue is quite simple: there is an aggressor and a victim of aggression. Which side are you on? That's true of almost EVERY war across human history, so this war isn't unusual. What's unusual is your demand to take a maximalist uncompromosing position on a war that could literally lead to mushroom clouds sprouting over the great cities of the world. Why can't you be on Ukraine's "side" and also feel that the best course of action for Ukraine and everyone else is a negotiated end to a war that has killed or injured almost 2 MILLION when you add in the war-caused famine deaths in Africa, some $1.2 USD TRILLION in costs and could cross the line into WW3? |
| Tango01 | 15 Oct 2026 4:40 p.m. PST |
So… the Ukrainians are not open to peace on the basis of the excellent and fair terms being offered to them… and that's not all… they know perfectly well that any agreement signed with Putin will be strictly upheld by Russia… so, once any such pact is signed, they ought to disband their army and become a country like Switzerland… what foolish people, these Ukrainians… peace—with all the necessary guarantees—is within their reach, yet because they love war, they continue to fight against the peace-loving and trustworthy Russians. Oh! And I forgot to mention that they are also to blame for so much death and expense—even on another continent—and are even responsible for a possible nuclear war.
Armand |
SBminisguy  | 15 Oct 2026 8:18 p.m. PST |
Your sarcasm and deflection is not a good look. Are you so emotionally wedded to punishing Russia that you can't register the death toll and destruction in Ukraine and Russian and the hundreds of thousands of famine deaths in Africa? I'll ask one last direct question -- WHAT is your practical end solution to this war. Be real, use your experienced analytical information processing mind. |
| Tango01 | 15 Oct 2026 9:33 p.m. PST |
Opinions on this matter have already been voiced dozens of times here… I am not going to repeat what has been said. What is clear is that Putin and his cohort are not friends of the USA or anyone in the West. It is up to each individual country to decide how to act accordingly.
It is also clear that Ukraine is the country under attack and that it needs all the help it can get. And that the Russians are bad guys in this history. Armand
|
| Martyn K | 16 Oct 2026 5:15 a.m. PST |
it is interesting that the view that Ukraine is the one always against peace is being postulated. If we take the latest energy ceasefire that was announced by the US as a fait accompli on the 11th October – Russia continued attacks against Ukrainian energy and gas infrastructure in multiple regions cutting power to hundreds of thousands of people. Russia stated that the deal had never been finalized despite the US announcing that it was a completed deal. Either Russia or the US was not telling the truth about the deal. Ukraine, despite never being involved in the deal, held the deal for nearly three days before resuming the attacks on Russia energy infrastructure. Attacks on Russian refineries and data centers (which is a whole interesting discussion in itself) are some of the few pressure points Ukraine has to exert on Russia. I wake this morning to find comments from the US administration that Ukraine's attacks on Russia's oil refineries are a "Disgrace". It left me with the feeling that someone was trying to gaslight me. So recent events continue to lead me to be skeptical of the propaganda that the US and Russia are the ones actively wanting peace and the evil EU is using Ukraine as a puppet to continue the war. |
35thOVI  | 16 Oct 2026 5:35 a.m. PST |
To both of you. Did my post NOT post exact dates of infrastructure attacks after the "ceasefire", that I also said in another thread, had little chance of being successful? Yes or No It's in white to make it easier to find. I think you only read what you want to read. I know I've never taken Russias side. Go back through the early threads on the Ukraine. But today, at this moment, I don't believe either side wants a peace, nor even a ceasefire. SB asked a legitimate question, that is being ignored. I'll ask one last direct question -- WHAT is your practical end solution to this war. Be real, use your experienced analytical information processing mind. We currently have had Europe accusing Russia of sabotage in their countries. We have had NATO countries accusing Russia of violating their borders with overflights. We have Bulgaria accusing Russia of attacking and sinking commercial ships in their waters. We have multiple NATO countries accusing Russia of using its "shadow fleet" to sabotage undersea cables and pipelines I want to add, almost everyone accused Russia of the Nord Stream gas pipelines attacks in September 2022. An accusation that never really made sense. But if one said that here, one was subjected to these same attacks and motivations. What have the Germans since found? Those are just 4 above off the top of my head. This is going on 5 years now. How long before a mistake is made or a NON mistake and we go through the chain of alliances of WW1 and WW2? But in today's environment, we are taking minutes and seconds, not days, weeks and months. I'll say another thing I've said many times before, I hate peace time military alliances. They lead only to the situations of WW1 and WW2. |
SBminisguy  | 16 Oct 2026 7:45 a.m. PST |
SB asked a legitimate question, that is being ignored. Look, the clean story is appealing: Russia invaded, Ukraine is the victim, keep arming them until the bad guys lose, and anything short of that is weakness. It feels morally straightforward and matches years of Western commentary. Reality rarely cooperates with maximalist framing, and history shows why. War doesn't care how you feel. The most likely outcome is still a long grind ending in an imperfect freeze or settlement near current lines. Ukraine keeps its independence and most of its territory; Russia holds what it occupies without the full 2022 victory. Mass death, trillions spent, a closer Russia-China tie, and lines of control that look a lot like 2022. Guarantees stronger than nothing but short of NATO membership are the probable security fig leaf; full Alliance entry isn't realistic. That's not justice. It's what attrition wars produce when neither side can force a decisive result. Continued maximalist pressure without an off-ramp doesn't create Ukrainian reconquest or Russian collapse. It just extends the trading of blows and the spillover. Neither side's politics make an exit easier. Possible Russian successors (Mishustin as placeholder, security figures like Dyumin or Patrushev) inherit a conflict framed as existential; the siloviki and hardliners treat concessions as defeat, and any new leader risks looking weak by moving first, so the bias is toward continuation. On the Western side the war has become a rigid emotional litmus test, especially among traditionally anti-war Democrats and European liberals. Support signals moral alignment; questioning duration, costs, or endgames is often treated as bad character rather than strategy. Leaders exploring off-ramps face domestic costs. When both sides tie identity to not appearing to lose, concessions become harder even as the price rises. And this sh1t could get out of hand. The volume of drone incursions near NATO airspace, shipping attacks off Bulgaria and Romania, Baltic scrambles, and hybrid probes keeps rising. Most stay below Article 5, but every extra month multiplies the chance something goes wrong and gets read as a test of resolve. Sarajevo, the Defenestration of Prague, and the Ems Telegram show how limited incidents become triggers when conditions are already dangerous and leaders won't back down. Nuclear weapons and the lack of automatic triggers have acted as brakes so far. They do not erase the pattern. Maximalist thinking treats negotiation as surrender. History suggests the more common problem is wars that drag on because the clean ending never arrives while messy incidents pile up. Preferring the former just buys more time for something ugly and uncontrolled to happen. |
| Martyn K | 16 Oct 2026 8:02 a.m. PST |
Appeasement never solves the problem. If as you suggest, Ukraine just accepts the current borders. What then happens when: - Russia rearms and invades Ukraine again in force in five years times. - Russia invades areas of Estonia claiming that they have large Russian populations. - Russia carries out border incursions of Poland, Slovakia or Hungary - Russia continues to engage in hybrid warfare against NATO nations. All of these potential actions are encouraged if the invasion of Ukraine is rewarded with territory gains. |
SBminisguy  | 16 Oct 2026 9:10 a.m. PST |
Recognizing there is no good outcome after years of fighting and roughly $400 USD billion spent is not appeasement. It is an acknowledgment of the military result: Russia failed to take Kyiv or collapse Ukraine, Ukraine has not reversed the 2022 gains, and both sides have paid heavily for a stalemate in the loss of a whole generation of young men. The claim that any settlement near current lines automatically invites the next invasion treats Putin as a cartoon whose behavior is controlled only by whether the last war is labeled a success. His record looks more like Mussolini's: ambitions that outran capacity, an army that stalled and bled against a smaller neighbor, and a regime that has already absorbed enormous costs without achieving its original goals. Five years of breathing room is more likely to produce a Ukrainian "hedgehog" defense that makes any future incursion expensive and slow, plus time for economic recovery and demographic stabilization of the kind that followed other destructive wars. A functioning, armed, independent Ukraine will continue to demonstrate that it outperforms anything a Russian-controlled Donbas can offer. The same interval gives European NATO members, already under pressure from Trump to spend more, further time to thicken their own defenses and get their houses in order. Continued open-ended fighting does not eliminate the risks listed. It extends the period during which drone, shipping, and hybrid incidents keep occurring near NATO territory, while both sides have political incentives to treat those incidents as tests of resolve. After the money already spent and the casualties already taken, insisting that only more of the same can prevent future problems is not strategy. It is a refusal to accept that the clean ending you emotionally want was never realistic or likely. |
Grattan54  | 16 Oct 2026 10:14 a.m. PST |
35th OVI, I have been reading your several last posts. Overall, I would say I agree with you take on things. I do think Ukraine would like peace but it wants Russia to give back the territory it has taken. Not sure that is going to happen. I don't think Putin has ever wanted peace. Everytime Trump has been close to a ceasefire or talks it is Putin who breaks it. Putin still feels he can grind Ukraine down and win. Now, where we might now disagree is that I see the US now backing Russia by buying it diesel and cutting the satellite support to Ukraine. If I am right, I am very dishearten by this. |
35thOVI  | 16 Oct 2026 10:45 a.m. PST |
Grattan, No, neither side wants peace. The Ukraine wants as much back as they can get as long as their population can hold up. Russia is in a face saving mode. They can't afford to give up anything, otherwise Vlad had no justification for the loses both financially and people wise he has incurred. It could easily go multiple years more, unless something "happens". (Hope nothing happens) I am not a fan of the diesel purchase. I understand why it was done, but I don't see it making a difference. I believe it will be reimplemented as soon as Election Day ends. After which I believe lots of stuff is going to happen.. maybe quickly. Where we disagree is you all who are so quick to condemn the President for doing this, have failed for nearly 5 years to condemn those in the EU, NATO and other allies for doing the same type of things! You can't have it both ways. Either all are wrong and you condemn them all, BY NAME, or you condemn none. Otherwise it's just base hypocrisy and political agenda. |
Grattan54  | 16 Oct 2026 5:41 p.m. PST |
35th, No, I do agree with you. The EU and NATO should not be buying fuel from Russia. They have greatly reduced what they had been buying, but I do agree with on that. |
| Cuprum2 | 19 Oct 2026 4:08 p.m. PST |
Grattan54, A peace agreement had already been reached by both sides in 2022 in Istanbul. But it was Ukraine that rejected it. |
Grattan54  | 19 Oct 2026 5:28 p.m. PST |
A peace agreement can not be reached by both sides when one side does not agree. |
SBminisguy  | 19 Oct 2026 7:00 p.m. PST |
@Grattan54, Cuprum2 isn't wrong about the 2022 peace deal…but you're also not wrong that it takes two to talk peace. Sadly, people aren't tired enough of the killing yet to be ready for peace… |
|