Help support TMP


"reading the dust cloud" Topic


9 Posts

All members in good standing are free to post here. Opinions expressed here are solely those of the posters, and have not been cleared with nor are they endorsed by The Miniatures Page.

Please do not post offers to buy and sell on the main forum.

For more information, see the TMP FAQ.


Back to the Artificial Intelligence (AI) Message Board

Back to the American Indian Wars Message Board


Areas of Interest

General
Renaissance
18th Century
19th Century

Featured Hobby News Article


Featured Link


Top-Rated Ruleset

Impetus


Rating: gold star gold star gold star gold star gold star gold star gold star 


Featured Showcase Article

28mm Acolyte Vampires - Based

The Acolyte Vampires return - based, now, and ready for the game table.


Featured Profile Article

Music Video: Secrets of the Ocean Keep

Taking our pirate artwork, and making a new tune crafted specifically for it.


Current Poll


372 hits since 7 Oct 2026
©1994-2026 Bill Armintrout
Comments or corrections?

Personal logo doc mcb Supporting Member of TMP08 Oct 2026 7:58 a.m. PST

Whoosh! I'll try to post the six images on my FB with a link so you can see them. What I did was ask Grok about dust clouds as scouts might see them and try to "read" them. The cloud as seen by a scout is an objective fact, and I can hand a player an image and say THIS is what you see. Interpreting it is another matter. A warband of thirty braves, and four boys driving a remuda of thirty horses, look pretty much the same.

Here is what the robot told em:

Six cards cover it. More than that starts illustrating stories instead of shapes, and the shape is the only objective fact.

A scout did not get a different picture for "warriors" and "boys with horses." He got a plume, and the plume only varies in a few ways the eye can actually sort at horizon range: how tall it stands, how wide it lies, whether it is one body or broken into clumps, whether something dark shows under it, and whether it trails or spins in place.

Direction is not a seventh cloud. You turn the card, or mark the trail edge. Speed is mostly already in the shape — a boil versus a hang — so it does not need its own pictures.

Alkali and damp ground are modifiers you say aloud ("the ground is white; this would look bigger than it is"), not extra plates.

These six are the set. Same light, same rise, same distance, so the only thing that changes is the cloud.

1. Thread. Short, low, thin trail. A file.
2. Tall boil. Narrow column, high and leaning. Mounted and moving.
3. Broad hang. Wide, low, broken along the bottom. A spread herd at a walk.
4. Dark-fronted pall. Long, dense, yellow-brown, with a darker line at the base and no animals resolved. Heavy animals, or a large body running.
5. Broken clumps. Several separate puffs in a line, not one cloud. Wagons, travois, a village string.
6. Spinner. One column, no trail behind it. Wind, or something wallowing and not going anywhere.

That is the reasonable range. Cards 2 and 3 are the pair your misread lives in: a driven remuda and a war party swap places here, and a buffalo band can be called for the pall. The umpire keeps the key. The player only sees the plate.

link

Personal logo doc mcb Supporting Member of TMP08 Oct 2026 8:15 a.m. PST

Btw, I spent about an hour last night discussing dust clouds with the AI, and then this morning it took another hour to produce six images with explanations.

I will take the images to FedEx and get nice laminated half sheets to use as player handouts.

Personal logo doc mcb Supporting Member of TMP08 Oct 2026 8:42 a.m. PST

On the table top, there will be a distance within which miniatures can be identified and would be put on the table when spotted. Beyond that distance what is spotted is a dust cloud.

This will be with dummy markers which may represent real people or nothing. When opposing dummies can see each other, players reveal if real or not. When both are nothing, remove both. When one is real, remove the dummy, but the other player now knows something there is real, but not what. If both are real and close enough, put the minis on tne table. If real but far away, show the dust cloud.

The H Man Supporting Member of TMP08 Oct 2026 2:57 p.m. PST

"Whoosh! I'll try to post the six images on my FB with a link so you can see them. What I did was ask Grok about dust clouds as scouts might see them and try to "read" them."

Cheers.

That actually reminds me, I'm supposed to be looking for more pictures in that tank smoke.

Did you find that hook yet?

I'm guessing AI can't actually replicate smoke, so it just crams a bunch of images together.

Personal logo doc mcb Supporting Member of TMP08 Oct 2026 4:42 p.m. PST

I just asked ChatGPT to do the same task and it out-performed GROK.

Personal logo Grelber Supporting Member of TMP08 Oct 2026 8:38 p.m. PST

I read a book about the battle of Chickamauga, where one of the Union officers who had served on the Western frontier prior to the War, was explained to his people how to tell infantry from cavalry by their dust cloud.

Grelber

Andrew Walters09 Oct 2026 11:28 a.m. PST


I'm guessing AI can't actually replicate smoke, so it just crams a bunch of images together.

That is true of smoke, walruses, and everything that is not smoke or walruses. But it works!

To un-hijack, I love this idea! Unfortunately you're asking the players to distinguish something they have no experience discerning but which the characters in the game would have a lifetime of experience evaluating, but it's still fun!

There was a US Army red team, a regiment, that famously used to drag big metal frames behind a few trucks to create a dust cloud that looked like a tank column, to human observers as well as the gear on the JSTARS aircraft. I'm sure this kind of thing goes all the way back, as what's his name said "all warfare is based on deception". So players should be skeptical of dust clouds!

Personal logo doc mcb Supporting Member of TMP09 Oct 2026 3:11 p.m. PST

Andrew, indeed. Creating dust on purpose should be an available tactic.

As to this:

Unfortunately you're asking the players to distinguish something they have no experience discerning but which the characters in the game would have a lifetime of experience evaluating, but it's still fun!

That problem applies widely. I am now old and fat and slow, but can still play a Comanche hunter sneaking up on a ranch house. 65 years ago I COULD carry away a watermelon from a farmer's field, but even then was no expert. We play games rather than doing these things for real, and thank God for that!

The H Man Supporting Member of TMP09 Oct 2026 4:17 p.m. PST

Kicking in the cabin door again, just to say it's interesting it doesn't look to use images of smoke for.., smoke. At least not in the case yonder.

Likely the same for dust.

Perhaps the lion king put it off?

Sorry - only verified members can post on the forums.