Help support TMP


"Fake News, Dirty Tricks and Civil War Politics" Topic


4 Posts

All members in good standing are free to post here. Opinions expressed here are solely those of the posters, and have not been cleared with nor are they endorsed by The Miniatures Page.

Please do not post offers to buy and sell on the main forum.

For more information, see the TMP FAQ.


Back to the ACW Discussion Message Board


Areas of Interest

American Civil War

Featured Hobby News Article


Featured Link


Top-Rated Ruleset

Brother Against Brother


Rating: gold star gold star gold star gold star gold star gold star gold star 


Featured Showcase Article

1:600 USS Conestoga

Adding a timberclad to my Union fleet.


Featured Profile Article

Music Video: Eagles in the Clay

Music video about the 1st Battle of Puebla, from the perspective of a French Zouave.


Featured Book Review


266 hits since 6 Oct 2026
©1994-2026 Bill Armintrout
Comments or corrections?

Tango0107 Oct 2026 12:37 p.m. PST

"Today's political discourse includes frequent talk of "fake news" (a term which seems to only occasionally mean actual trickery rather than simply unfavorable reporting). Meanwhile, partisan political concerns sometimes seem thick with racial hostility, appealing to voters' irrational fears. None of this is new. During the Civil War a handful of efforts turned "fake news" into an art form and many partisan combatants proved shameless in appealing to white racism.

Near the close of 1863, as the two major parties were gearing up for the presidential election the following year, two journalists for the Democratic New York World concocted a bizarre and creative scheme. Shortly after the start of the new year, David Croly and George Wakeman anonymously published an ambitious 71-page pamphlet, entitled Miscegenation: The Theory of the Blending of the Races, Applied to the American White man and Negro. Pretending to be a complex scientific treatise, Miscegenation described an idealized future where Blacks and Whites would intermingle without limitations, including unrestrained sexual relations across racial lines.[1]

The clever journalists – who even coined the word "miscegenation" for posterity – played a complex game. They hoped to convince White readers that abolitionist Republicans supported the pamphlet's notions, even adding an Appendix with quotations from actual abolitionists, implying that those leaders had endorsed miscegenation. Binding their words directly to the upcoming election, Croly and Wakeman concluded that "whereas, the result of the last Presidential election [1860] has given the colored race on this continent its freedom, the next Presidential election should secure to every black man and woman the rest of their social and political rights." Thus, a vote for Abraham Lincoln would be a vote for pure racial equality and enfettered racial intermingling.[2] This rather brilliant piece of "fake news" attracted some attention in the national press and scored a huge victory for the forces of fraud when Ohio Democrat Sunset Cox – taken in by the fakery – delivered a speech before the House of Representatives denouncing the pamphlet…"


link


Armand

Red Jacket Supporting Member of TMP08 Oct 2026 7:02 a.m. PST

What surprises me is that people ever thought that the "news media" had ever been evenhanded in its approach to reporting "news." Newspapers and journalists have always been creatures of politics, from the founding of the country up and until today. Broadcast media is the same way. Even in the heyday of the great newscasters, who can forget Walter Cronkite telling the American people and the world that the war in Vietnam was unwinable. That was a political statement that was not supported by the "facts" on the ground. Subsequent investigation showed that the North Vietnamese had wrecked its military with the TET Offensive. Old Walter's statement supported the growing antiwar movement.

Absent personally witnessing an event, we have to rely upon the "professional journalists" to tell us what has happened. For a while, I thought that the internet was going to allow people to make up their own minds based upon realtime posting of factual reports. If that was ever achievable, with the advent of AI, it is impossible to discern what is or is not true. There are so many outright fakes and lies online that you need to view several sources before being able to get an idea as to what is correct. The only benifit of the internet today is that you have access to more sources from which to determine what news is true and what news is likely false. My former "go to" source, the BBC, has proven itself to be a tool of political masters. I actually like AFP because my limited French allows me to pick-out "facts" but does not allow me to understand any deep "analysis" by the reporters. I get to make up my own mind.

I imagine that the best time for journalistic integrity was WWII. The "free press" was more or less politically behind the war, with significant exception from the anti-Roosevelt American press barons. Plus, even with censorship, millions of people were getting firsthand observations from fighting men writing home. After the war, people still trusted the press while the press had resumed their positions as propaganda organs for political machines. Even in my mid-sized industrial city, we had 2 daily newspapers when I was growing up, which would editorially report on the news. The result was that the same event could take on two completely different meanings, depending upon which paper you read. Most people subscribed to both in order to gain a balanced view of the "facts." Everybody recognized that situation but nobody seriously objected to the politicizing of the news. Today we have one paper that has a couple of local reporters with the majority of the paper being composed of press association articles. The only reason to subscribe is for the sports coverage.

I do not know how society can get away from politics coloring the news. The government cannot take a too active role or we run into freedom of the press issues. Even if government were to take a hand, that would only result in more political control. Based upon my observations, governments cannot agree on what they are doing, with politics touching on everything that the government releases. With the advent of AI, we have images of actual individuals being manipulated to the extent that it looks and sounds as if a "trusted" individual is saying something that is demonstratively false or incendiary. Personally, I just try to gather whatever information I can and then make my own conclusions.

Looking at things honestly, we are in the same position as the public at the time of the American Civil War when it comes to journalism. Things are reported with a political bias that can be supported with "facts" created out of whole cloth, now by the computers that we embraced as a means to make our lives better. An enterprising computer geek or foreign government can create a completely believable news report that could materially impact a country or even the world. Everything about the event would seem believable while it was a total fiction. Many (most) people would automatically believe that fictional story, for example, that a space invader had landed in rural New Jersey where an invasion of the world would begin. Unlike the original event, today, that story would be supported by video "evidence" of the landing and subsequent "war." Just as many people would believe the story to be true, even when faced with their own observations that their particular city was not under attack.

Shagnasty Supporting Member of TMP08 Oct 2026 7:49 a.m. PST

RJ for the win. The weather and local festivals are about it. Even the sports news has become political.

Tango0108 Oct 2026 4:20 p.m. PST

Thanks


Armand

Sorry - only verified members can post on the forums.