"A Culture of Fear: Command Failure at Caporetto" Topic

"The Battle of Caporetto, fought in October of 1917 along the Isonzo Front, remains one of the most dramatic collapses of an Army in modern European history (Schindler, 2001). The Italian Army did not simply lose a battle. It suffered a systemic breakdown in leadership, communication, morale, and organizational cohesion. The defeat was so severe that it forced a complete restructuring of the Italian command system and reshaped the strategic balance of the First World War (Gooch, 2014). Caporetto is remembered not only for the rapid advance of German and Austro Hungarian forces but also for the profound failure of command that allowed the collapse to unfold. Scholars have long recognized that the Italian Army entered the battle with deep structural weaknesses, many of which stemmed from the leadership style of General Luigi Cadorna and the rigid command culture he imposed on the Army (Gooch, 2014). The events at Caporetto reveal how an inflexible doctrine, a punitive leadership environment, and a lack of trust between commanders and subordinates can undermine an entire military institution.

This article examines Caporetto as a case study in failed command. It explores the strategic context of the Italian Front (Schindler, 2001), the leadership culture that shaped Italian operations (Gooch, 2014), the infiltration tactics used by German and Austro Hungarian forces (Schindler, 2001), and the collapse of situational understanding that accelerated the Italian retreat. It also considers the broader implications of Caporetto for modern leadership and mission command philosophy. Drawing on a balanced mix of British, Italian, and Central Powers scholarship, as well as institutional sources such as the Imperial War Museums and the National World War One Museum (Imperial War Museums, n.d.; National World War One Museum and Memorial, n.d.), this article provides a comprehensive analysis of the battle and its enduring lessons…"

link

Armand