"Longstreet Rule Review" Topic

I reviewed the Longstreet rules, by Sam Mustafa. I think it's a game everyone should check out. link

Good review, comprehensive yet to the point! I would suggest changing the first sentence slightly. By "brigade-level", you mean that the player is a brigade commander; however, many if not most gamers use "brigade-level" to mean that the maneuver units are brigades (and that therefore players are division- or corps commanders). My suggestion is to say something like "American Civil War rules for brigade-level actions, by Sam Mustafa."

This is not a review, only an opinion that you like them.

There is nothing about the game sequence, how movement works, how casualties are determined, nothing about melee or unit morale. Really, nothing about the game at all.

I'm happy you like the rules, but I sure as heck would not go out and spend money on a game without seeing how it plays.

Much more information is needed to properly call this a review.

Kim

Eumelus thank you very much!! Yes, thanks for the feedback, I definitely change it, I now realize that "brigade level" will conjure up games like fire & fury to most people.

KimRYoung isn't providing an opinion on a product a review??

thanks

Thanks for taking the time to give your feedback on the Longstreet rules they are a favourite of mine…