Help support TMP


"ChatGPT on Prince Rupert's Horse" Topic


12 Posts

All members in good standing are free to post here. Opinions expressed here are solely those of the posters, and have not been cleared with nor are they endorsed by The Miniatures Page.

Please use the Complaint button (!) to report problems on the forums.

For more information, see the TMP FAQ.


Back to the English Civil War Message Board


Areas of Interest

Renaissance

Featured Hobby News Article


Featured Link


Top-Rated Ruleset

Tactica Medieval Rulebook


Rating: gold star gold star gold star gold star gold star gold star gold star 


Featured Showcase Article

28mm Acolyte Vampires - Based

The Acolyte Vampires return - based, now, and ready for the game table.


Featured Profile Article


Current Poll


Featured Book Review


726 hits since 30 Dec 2022
©1994-2023 Bill Armintrout
Comments or corrections?

Timbo W30 Dec 2022 4:36 p.m. PST

So I wondered what ChatGPT would make of ECW regimental history.


History of Prince Rupert's Horse


Write a 250 word history of Prince Rupert's regiment of horse during the English civil War

Prince Rupert's Regiment of Horse was a cavalry unit that played a significant role in the English Civil War (1642-1651). The regiment was formed in 1642, at the outbreak of the Civil War, and was led by Prince Rupert of the Rhine, a prominent Royalist commander. Rupert was a skilled cavalry officer and had gained a reputation for his daring and aggressive tactics during the Thirty Years' War on the continent.

The regiment was made up of experienced soldiers who were well-trained in the use of cavalry tactics. They were equipped with muskets and swords, and were known for their speed and mobility on the battlefield. The regiment played a key role in many of the major engagements of the Civil War, including the Battle of Edgehill, the Siege of Bristol, and the Battle of Marston Moor.

Despite their successes, Prince Rupert's Regiment of Horse faced significant challenges during the Civil War. They were often outnumbered by their opponents and had to rely on their superior tactics and training to compensate for this disadvantage. Additionally, the regiment faced financial difficulties and struggled to maintain its ranks and equipment.

Despite these challenges, Prince Rupert's Regiment of Horse continued to fight on behalf of the Royalist cause until the end of the Civil War. After the defeat of the Royalists in 1651, Prince Rupert fled to the continent and the regiment was disbanded. However, the legacy of Prince Rupert's Regiment of Horse lived on, and they are remembered as one of the most effective cavalry units of the English Civil War.

Surprisingly mostly OK, apart from the musket bit, but really very generic.

I don't think KYPD should worry 😁

Cerdic31 Dec 2022 1:35 a.m. PST

What is ChatGPT?

Timbo W31 Dec 2022 2:41 a.m. PST

An online AI that you can ask questions

KeepYourPowderDry31 Dec 2022 3:42 a.m. PST

Phew, so that's quite scary. Didn't know such things existed. Sounds like something my #4 son would create because he was bored (and he has the skills to do it). I'll ask him when he wakes up 😂

Thanks for the vote of thanks Tim, I'm not completely redundant just yet

Arjuna31 Dec 2022 4:20 a.m. PST

Me:
What are Tabletop wargames?

ChatGPT:
Tabletop wargames are games that simulate warfare or other military conflict using miniature figurines, dice, and a game board or tabletop. They are often based on historical events or fictional worlds, and players take on the roles of military commanders or other leaders, making strategic decisions and directing the actions of their units.

In many tabletop wargames, players use miniature figurines or models to represent their units, and these units are typically organized into armies or other military forces. The game is played on a tabletop or game board, which is often divided into a grid or other system of squares or hexagons to represent the battlefield. Players roll dice to determine the outcome of various actions and use various rules and mechanics to simulate the movement and combat of their units.

There are many different types of tabletop wargames, ranging from simple games that can be played in a few hours to more complex games that can take days or even weeks to complete. Some tabletop wargames are played competitively, with players vying for victory, while others are played cooperatively, with players working together to achieve a common goal. Many tabletop wargames also include elements of role-playing, with players taking on the roles of specific characters or units and acting out their actions in character.

Me:
Give me some examples of tabletop wargames with miniatures.

ChatGPT:
Some examples of tabletop wargames that use miniature figurines include:

Warhammer 40,000: This is a science fiction-themed tabletop wargame set in a distant future where humanity is at war with a variety of alien races. Players collect and paint miniature models of their armies and use dice and a variety of rules to determine the outcome of their battles.

Warmachine: This is a fantasy-themed tabletop wargame set in the world of Immoren, where powerful steam-powered warjacks clash with magic-wielding warriors. Players collect and paint miniature models of their armies and use dice and a variety of rules to determine the outcome of their battles.

Flames of War: This is a World War II-themed tabletop wargame that allows players to recreate battles from the European and Pacific theaters of the war. Players collect and paint miniature models of their armies and use dice and a variety of rules to determine the outcome of their battles.

Bolt Action: This is a World War II-themed tabletop wargame that focuses on infantry and armor combat. Players collect and paint miniature models of their armies and use dice and a variety of rules to determine the outcome of their battles.

Heroclix: This is a superhero-themed tabletop wargame that uses collectible miniature figures with dials that can be turned to reveal different abilities and powers. Players build teams of characters and use dice and a variety of rules to determine the outcome of their battles.

Me:
Tell me about the history of tabletop wargaming.

ChatGPT:
The origins of tabletop wargaming can be traced back to the 19th century, when military officers and strategists began using miniature figurines and maps to simulate and analyze potential battlefield scenarios. These early wargames were often used for training and education, and helped military leaders to better understand the complexities of warfare and to develop more effective tactics and strategies.

The first known commercial tabletop wargame was released in 1954, and was called "Tactics." It was followed by a number of other wargames over the next few decades, including "PanzerBlitz" and "Diplomacy." These early wargames were typically focused on historical battles or hypothetical military scenarios, and often included complex rules and mechanics to simulate the movement and combat of various units.

In the 1970s and 1980s, tabletop wargaming saw a surge in popularity, thanks in part to the rise of role-playing games such as "Dungeons & Dragons," which introduced many people to the concept of using miniature figurines and dice in a gaming context. This led to the development of a number of fantasy-themed wargames, such as "Warhammer" and "Warhammer 40,000," which remain popular to this day.

Today, tabletop wargaming is a thriving hobby enjoyed by millions of people around the world. There are countless different tabletop wargames available, covering a wide range of themes and genres, and the hobby continues to evolve and grow.

Me:
Can you give me some websites where I can find more information about tabletop wargames?

ChatGPT:
There are many websites where you can find more information about tabletop wargames, including:

BoardGameGeek (www.boardgamegeek.com): This is a comprehensive resource for tabletop games of all kinds, including wargames. You can find information about hundreds of different wargames, as well as user reviews and ratings, forums for discussing the games, and more.

Miniature Wargaming (www.miniaturewargaming.com): This website is specifically dedicated to tabletop wargaming, and includes news and reviews of wargames, painting and modeling tips, and forums for discussing the hobby.

Tabletop Gaming News (www.tabletopgamingnews.com): This website is a news and review site for all types of tabletop games, including wargames. You can find information about new and upcoming wargames, as well as reviews and articles about the hobby.

The Wargamer (www.thewargamer.com): This website is a news and review site for wargames, focusing on digital and computer-based wargames as well as tabletop wargames. You can find information about new and upcoming wargames, as well as reviews and articles about the hobby.

Tabletop Wargames (www.tabletopwargames.co.uk): This is a UK-based website that provides news and reviews of tabletop wargames, as well as painting and modeling tips, and forums for discussing the hobby.

Me:
What do you know about theminiaturespage.com ?

ChatGPT:
The Miniatures Page (www.theminiaturespage.com) is a website that is dedicated to tabletop miniature gaming. It includes news, reviews, and discussion forums related to tabletop miniature games, including wargames. The website also features a marketplace section where users can buy and sell miniature figurines and other gaming-related items.

The Miniatures Page was founded in 1998 and has become a popular resource for tabletop miniature gamers. It has a large and active community of users who discuss a wide range of topics related to the hobby, including painting and modeling techniques, game rules and mechanics, and strategies for playing various tabletop wargames.

In addition to wargames, The Miniatures Page also covers other types of tabletop miniature games, such as board games that use miniatures, role-playing games that use miniatures, and collectible miniature games. The website is regularly updated with new content, including reviews of new and upcoming miniature games, and is a good resource for those interested in learning more about the tabletop miniature gaming hobby.

Me:
Is it a well known website?

ChatGPT:
The Miniatures Page (www.theminiaturespage.com) is a well-known and respected website within the tabletop miniature gaming community. It has been in operation since 1998 and has a large and active user base. Many tabletop miniature gamers visit the website regularly to stay up to date on news and reviews related to the hobby, and to participate in the discussion forums.

While The Miniatures Page is not as well-known as some other websites that cover a wider range of topics, it is an important resource for those interested in tabletop miniature gaming, including wargames. If you are interested in learning more about tabletop wargames or other types of tabletop miniature games, The Miniatures Page is a good place to start.

Me:
What are some good rule systems for scifi skirmishes?

ChatGPT:
There are many rule systems that are suitable for scifi skirmishes, and the best one for you will depend on your personal preferences and the type of scifi game you want to play. Here are a few examples of rule systems that are popular for scifi skirmishes:

Star Wars: Legion: This is a tabletop miniature wargame set in the Star Wars universe, and it allows players to recreate battles between the Galactic Empire and the Rebel Alliance using miniature figurines. The game uses a unique card-based activation system to determine which units can act during each turn, and includes a variety of special abilities and equipment options to help players create custom armies.

Infinity: This is a tabletop miniature wargame set in a futuristic, high-tech universe where players control elite soldiers and advanced robots. The game uses a dynamic action point system to determine which units can act during each turn, and includes a wide range of futuristic weapons and equipment.

Warzone: This is a tabletop miniature wargame set in a post-apocalyptic future where players control various factions vying for survival. The game uses a simple and fast-paced rule system that focuses on unit-level skirmishes, and includes a variety of special abilities and equipment options to help players create unique armies.

Dropzone Commander: This is a tabletop miniature wargame set in a distant future where players control advanced armies of vehicles, soldiers, and robots. The game uses a unique command point system to determine which units can act during each turn, and includes a wide range of futuristic weapons and equipment.

These are just a few examples of rule systems that are suitable for scifi skirmishes. There are many others to choose from, so you may want to do some research and try out a few different ones to find the one that best fits your needs and preferences.

Me:
I need three rules for movement in a scifi skirmish rules system.

ChatGPT:
Here are three potential rules for movement in a scifi skirmish rules system:

Movement Points: Units in the game may have a certain number of movement points (or "MP") that they can use to move each turn. These points could be spent to move a certain number of squares or hexes on the game board, with more difficult terrain costing more movement points to move through.

Terrain Modifiers: Movement through certain types of terrain, such as rough terrain or water, may be more difficult for some units and could require them to spend more movement points or roll additional dice to see if they can successfully navigate the terrain.

Movement Orders: Players may be able to issue different types of movement orders to their units, such as "advance," "halt," or "fall back." These orders could allow units to move more quickly or more cautiously, or to retreat from danger.

These are just a few examples of rules for movement that could be included in a scifi skirmish rules system. You may want to consider other factors, such as the size and type of units, the terrain of the battlefield, and the overall theme and tone of the game when designing your movement rules.


Point systems are a common mechanic used in tabletop wargames to balance the power and capabilities of different units and armies. In a point system, each unit or model in the game is assigned a certain number of points, and players are typically given a fixed number of points to spend when building their armies. This allows players to create armies with a variety of different units and abilities, while still ensuring that the overall power level of the armies is balanced.

Me:
What are the advantages of point systems and are there alternatives?

ChatGPT:
There are several advantages to using point systems in tabletop wargames:

Balance: Point systems help to balance the power and capabilities of different units and armies, which can help to create a more fair and enjoyable gaming experience for all players.

Customization: Point systems allow players to customize their armies by choosing which units and abilities they want to include, which can add depth and variety to the game.

Flexibility: Point systems can be easily adjusted to account for changes in the game's rules or the introduction of new units, which allows the game to remain balanced over time.

While point systems are a common and effective way to balance the power level of different units and armies in tabletop wargames, they are not the only option. Other alternatives include using fixed army lists or allowing players to build armies using a certain number of "slots" that can be filled with different units or abilities. Ultimately, the best approach will depend on the specific goals and needs of the game.

Me:
Are there disadvantages?

ChatGPT:
Like any game mechanic, point systems have their own set of advantages and disadvantages. Some potential disadvantages of using point systems in tabletop wargames include:

Complexity: Point systems can add an additional layer of complexity to the game, as players need to keep track of the points values of different units and abilities, and ensure that their armies remain within the point limit.

Time investment: Building an army using a point system can be time-consuming, as players need to carefully consider which units and abilities they want to include and how they will fit into their overall strategy.

Limited options: Depending on the point values of different units and abilities, players may feel limited in their options and may not be able to include all of the units or abilities they want in their armies.

Inaccurate representation: Point values are not always an accurate representation of the relative power and capabilities of different units and abilities, which can lead to some units being overvalued or undervalued.

Meta-game considerations: Point systems can sometimes lead to a focus on min-maxing and optimizing armies for competitive play, which can shift the focus of the game away from the theme and story and towards gameplay mechanics.

Overall, whether the disadvantages of point systems outweigh the advantages will depend on the specific goals and needs of the game and the preferences of the players.

Arjuna31 Dec 2022 4:30 a.m. PST

I call it my AI Buddy.
Together we've already written dozens of short articles, blog posts, messages, some homework, and some minor programming.
In about a fifth of the time.
I'm still exploring.
I love it.

On the Internet nobody knows, you're an AI.
:)

Arjuna31 Dec 2022 4:44 a.m. PST

To be more on topic:

Me:
What are some skirmish rule systems for the English Civil War?

ChatGPT
There are several tabletop wargames that use rules systems specifically designed for simulating skirmishes during the English Civil War. Here are a few examples:

English Civil War Rules: This is a set of wargame rules specifically designed for simulating skirmishes during the English Civil War. The rules are designed to be simple and fast-paced, and focus on unit-level combat.

Pike & Shot: This is a tabletop miniature wargame set during the Renaissance and Early Modern periods, including the English Civil War. The game uses a simple and intuitive rule system that focuses on the movement and combat of individual units, and includes a variety of historical units and equipment.

Mordheim: This is a tabletop miniature wargame set in the fantasy world of the Warhammer universe, but it includes rules for creating skirmish-level games set during the English Civil War. Players can collect and paint miniature models of their armies and use dice and a variety of rules to determine the outcome of their battles.

Fire & Fury: This is a set of tabletop wargame rules that can be used to simulate battles from the American Civil War, but which can also be adapted to the English Civil War. The rules are designed to be simple and fast-paced, and focus on the movement and combat of individual units.

These are just a few examples of tabletop wargames that include rules systems suitable for simulating skirmishes during the English Civil War. There are many other options to choose from, so you may want to do some research and try out a few different ones to find the one that best fits your needs and preferences.

Didn't know about Mordheim ECW.
You learn something new every day…

KeepYourPowderDry31 Dec 2022 7:24 a.m. PST

And that last entry about skirmish rules shows how flawed AI is… Pike and Shotte isn't really for skirmishes. No mention of File Leader, Once Upon A Time In The West Country, or Pikeman's Lament.

No idea about Mordheim or F&F, has the AI picked up on key words 'renaissance' and 'civil war'?

Arjuna31 Dec 2022 7:45 a.m. PST

Pike and Shotte isn't really for skirmishes

To be precise Pike and Shotte is for skirmishes, Pike & Shot is not.
That shows how flawed NI is…

Just kidding.

ChatGPT is a generative language AI model.
It's just a few weeks in the wild, trained on vast amounts of text from the web and other language corpora with as 2021.
And such obscure topics as ECW tabletop wargames aren't exactly mainstream on the net.
It generates probable text strings, it doesn't search the web or weight information based on criteria.
Of course, it is flawed.
But nonetheless, it's impressive.

Me:
Tell me what you are, ChatGPT.

ChatGPT:
I am an AI language model called Assistant, trained by OpenAI. I was designed to be able to understand and generate human-like text, and I can be used to answer questions, provide information, and engage in conversation. I am not a real person, but rather a program that has been trained on a large dataset of human-generated text, and I do my best to respond to user inquiries in a helpful and informative manner. I do not have access to the internet or any external information, so I can only provide answers based on the knowledge that I have been programmed with. If you have any questions or need any assistance, please don't hesitate to ask.

Me:
What are your flaws?

ChatGPT:
As an artificial intelligence, I do not have personal flaws in the same way that a human might. However, there are some limitations to my abilities and understanding that you should be aware of.

One limitation is that my knowledge is based on the data that was used to train me, and this data has a fixed cutoff point. This means that I may not be able to provide accurate or up-to-date information on events or developments that have occurred after my training data was compiled.

Another limitation is that I may not always be able to understand or respond appropriately to complex or nuanced questions or statements. I may also struggle with tasks that require a high level of creativity or original thought.

Finally, I am only able to provide information and assistance within the scope of my programming. If you have a question or need help with something that falls outside of my capabilities, I may not be able to assist you.

I hope this helps to give you a better understanding of my limitations. If you have any further questions, please don't hesitate to ask.

Me:
So, you don't reason about a topic, but calculate the probability of a text string based on the prompt I give you?


ChatGPT:
Yes, that's correct. As an artificial intelligence language model, I am trained to generate human-like text by analyzing patterns in the data that was used to train me. When I receive a prompt or question, I use the patterns and structures that I have learned from this training data to generate a response.

To generate a response, I analyze the words and phrases in the prompt and use this information to calculate the probability of different text strings that might follow. I then use this probability to generate a response that is most likely to be relevant and coherent given the information in the prompt.

I do not have personal experiences or opinions, and my responses are not based on my own feelings or beliefs. Instead, I use the patterns and structures in the data I have been trained on to generate responses that are most likely to be appropriate and accurate given the information in the prompt.


Me:
So, is it correct to say, a prompt is a way to explore the corpora of human data, information, and knowledge embedded into your algorithms?

ChatGPT:
Yes, that's correct. As an artificial intelligence language model, I have been trained on a large dataset of human-generated text, which includes a wide range of information and knowledge. When I receive a prompt, it provides me with a specific context or topic to consider, and I use the patterns and structures that I have learned from this training data to generate a response.

In this sense, a prompt can be thought of as a way to explore the information and knowledge that is embedded in my algorithms, as it allows me to generate responses that are relevant and coherent given the specific context or topic that is provided.

I do not have access to the internet or any external information, so I can only provide responses based on the knowledge and information that I have been programmed with. However, I have been trained on a diverse and extensive dataset, and I do my best to provide accurate and reliable information on a wide range of topics. If you have any questions or need assistance with something specific, please don't hesitate to ask.

Me:
A fellow wargamer told me the rules Pike & Shot aren't skirmish rules.
There is another rule system with the name Pike and Shotte.
Could it be you confused them?

ChatGPT:
I apologize if I have provided incorrect or misleading information. As an artificial intelligence, I do my best to provide accurate and reliable information based on the data that was used to train me. However, my knowledge has a fixed cutoff point, and I may not always be able to provide up-to-date or complete information on every topic.

It is possible that there is more than one set of wargaming rules called "Pike and Shot" or "Pike and Shotte," and that my previous response was referring to a different set of rules than the ones you mentioned. I apologize if this caused any confusion.

If you have specific questions about a particular set of wargaming rules, I would recommend consulting the rulebook or seeking out additional information and resources online or from other experienced wargamers. I am here to provide general information and assistance, but I may not have detailed knowledge of every wargaming rule system.

Arjuna31 Dec 2022 8:06 a.m. PST

More polite, humble and insightful than many I met at the wargaming table
:)

Shagnasty Supporting Member of TMP31 Dec 2022 10:19 a.m. PST

Interesting but creepy. Does it sing songs like, say, "Daisy?"

Arjuna31 Dec 2022 10:58 a.m. PST

Reference:
First computer to sing Daisy Bell

Me:
Give me a song like 'Daisy'.

ChatGPT:
Sure, here's a song that I came up with that's similar to "Daisy":

Verse 1:
I saw you standing there
In the field of flowers
Your golden hair
Shining in the sunlight

Chorus:
Oh Daisy, Daisy
You stole my heart
With your sweet smile
And your gentle touch

Verse 2:
We walked through the meadow
Holding hands and laughing
The world felt so bright
With you by my side

Chorus:
Oh Daisy, Daisy
You stole my heart
With your sweet smile
And your gentle touch

Bridge:
We laid in the grass
And watched the clouds go by
I knew in that moment
I never wanted to say goodbye

Chorus:
Oh Daisy, Daisy
You stole my heart
With your sweet smile
And your gentle touch

Me:
Also the score, please.

ChatGPT:
Sure, here's the chord progression for the song:

Verse:
D G A
D G A

Chorus:
D A Bm G
D A Bm G

Bridge:
D A Bm G
D A Bm G

You can play this on guitar or any other instrument that can play chords. You can also use a piano or keyboard if you prefer. Just play the chords in the order indicated for each section of the song. If you're playing on a guitar, you'll need to strum the chords using a picking pattern or strumming technique of your choice. You can also experiment with different chord voicings or inversions to add variety to the sound.

Me:
How can I make it more melancholy 17th century?
Like, say John Wards "Weep forth your tears"

ChatGPT:
To make the song more melancholy and evocative of 17th-century music like John Ward's "Weep forth your tears," you could try incorporating the following elements:

Use a minor key: Minor keys tend to sound sad or mournful, so using a minor key for the song can help to create a melancholic mood.

Use slower tempo: A slower tempo can add to the sense of sorrow and contemplation.

Incorporate dissonance: Dissonant intervals or chords can add tension and unease to the music, which can contribute to the melancholic mood.

Use ornamental melodies: Melodies with ornamental or decorative flourishes, like trills or turns, can add to the sense of emotional depth and complexity.

Consider using a plucked string instrument: Instruments like the lute or theorbo, which were popular in the 17th century, can give the song an authentic period sound.

Use a wide range: Vocal melodies that span a wide range can add to the emotional intensity of the song.

Use chromaticism: Using chromatic notes or chords, which are outside of the diatonic scale, can add dissonance and tension to the music.

By incorporating some or all of these elements, you can create a song that has a more melancholic, 17th-century feel like "Weep forth your tears."

Me:
Change the text so that it mourns the loss of something beloved.
Preferably a lost love.

ChatGPT:
Sure, here's a version of the song that mourns the loss of a beloved love:

Verse 1:
I saw you standing there
In the field of flowers
Your golden hair
Shining in the sunlight

But now you're gone
And my heart is torn
I'm left alone
To sing this mournful song

Chorus:
Oh Daisy, Daisy
You stole my heart
But now you're gone
And we're worlds apart

Verse 2:
We walked through the meadow
Holding hands and laughing
The world felt so bright
With you by my side

But now you're gone
And my heart is torn
I'm left alone
To sing this mournful song

Chorus:
Oh Daisy, Daisy
You stole my heart
But now you're gone
And we're worlds apart

Bridge:
We laid in the grass
And watched the clouds go by
I knew in that moment
I never wanted to say goodbye

But now you're gone
And my heart is torn
I'm left alone
To sing this mournful song

Chorus:
Oh Daisy, Daisy
You stole my heart
But now you're gone
And we're worlds apart

Sorry - only verified members can post on the forums.