Help support TMP


"1644 rules review" Topic


14 Posts

All members in good standing are free to post here. Opinions expressed here are solely those of the posters, and have not been cleared with nor are they endorsed by The Miniatures Page.

For more information, see the TMP FAQ.


Back to the English Civil War Message Board


Areas of Interest

Renaissance

Featured Hobby News Article


Featured Showcase Article

28mm Acolyte Vampires - Based

The Acolyte Vampires return - based, now, and ready for the game table.


Featured Workbench Article

Painting a 15mm Tibetan DBA Army: The Infantry

wodger Fezian begins his series on how to paint a 15mm DBA army well, in a reasonable time frame.


Featured Profile Article

First Look: Barrage's 28mm Streets & Sidewalks

Personal logo Editor in Chief Bill The Editor of TMP Fezian looks at some new terrain products, which use space age technology!


864 hits since 8 Oct 2022
©1994-2023 Bill Armintrout
Comments or corrections?


TMP logo

Membership

Please sign in to your membership account, or, if you are not yet a member, please sign up for your free membership account.
KeepYourPowderDry09 Oct 2022 9:37 p.m. PST

The latest in my series of Civil War rules reviews looks at the stalwart 1644 set. link

takeda33309 Oct 2022 10:46 p.m. PST

Nice review, I had a copy long ago and now lost. It was very helpful starting out in ECW but never really cared for the rules themselves. Imho that is.

Charge The Guns10 Oct 2022 12:03 a.m. PST

Good review 👍.

We tried them, for nostalgias sake, recently. I was quite concerned about the simultaneous movement, as we haven't played a game with that for decades. However the order system, with little chits, worked really well and was our favourite part of the game. Old fans of figure casualties also liked the opportunity to take single figures off again. 😀. Melees did take a long time to resolve.

pikeman66610 Oct 2022 5:45 a.m. PST

I had some enjoyable games with these rules. They're still on my bookshelf if anyone wants to play.

Son of MOOG10 Oct 2022 5:48 a.m. PST

One of my favorite rule systems. Always have a fun game with them…..now if I could only roll better!

Timbo W10 Oct 2022 7:37 a.m. PST

I used to use these for larger battles as they were reasonably fast play compared with Forlorn Hope.

Main issues I found were that the musketry was very devastating. Casualties were high and /or morale too insensitive to losses so units often survived to 50%. I heard that the ECW rules were adapted from a set of Marlburian or SYW rules, so maybe a bit of a hangover from these?

Not fatal issues, as one could handwave 'casualties' as disorganisation, stragglers etc but units standing after taking high casualties does not seem typical of the ECW, a few cases excepted.

Personal logo Dye4minis Supporting Member of TMP10 Oct 2022 9:56 a.m. PST

Funny to see this post! I just ran across my copy in a stack of old rules and pulled them out to see their suitability for 2 10mm Pendraken ECW army packs I recently acquired. Am taking a closer look at the campaign system in the back for possible applications in other periods. Rick seems to have hit the right buttons there with me.

KeepYourPowderDry10 Oct 2022 10:14 a.m. PST

Clearly much love still exists for these rules. And so there should be. The layout is a bit of a benchmark and pattern for those which followed. I just think that there are better rules in existence.

Dye4minis – Regiment of Foot v1 has an excellent campaign system. Worth a look if you can find a copy (they ditched the system in V2)

Olivero10 Oct 2022 10:51 a.m. PST

Regiment of Foote v1 has just been re-released in pdf format on the Peter Pig website. You only need to scroll down a bit. And for a very reasonable price I think.

KeepYourPowderDry10 Oct 2022 8:41 p.m. PST

Thanks Olivero, I knew that it was in the pipeline to become available as a PDF but was unaware that it had finally made it.

Dexter Ward11 Oct 2022 12:06 a.m. PST

1644 has some great ideas. The morale ladder, the way cavalry melees work with extra ranks being fed in. But it has some not so good ideas as well; the casualty system is very deterministic; you know you will cause 1 casualty with a 50% chance of a second, that wort of thing. No outliers possible. The infantry melee system is a bit clunky, and the game plays quite slowly.
The Scruttockshire campaign included is excellent.

Shagnasty Supporting Member of TMP11 Oct 2022 11:28 a.m. PST

Another vote for Scruttockshire! I agree with the comments on the devastating musketry.

Prince Alberts Revenge11 Oct 2022 5:54 p.m. PST

Purchased it years ago when I was transitioning from Warhammer to historicals. That, along with DBR, some of the first historical rulesets I owned. Never played it but was the first of many pike and shot rules purchased in my quest to find something I liked.

Griefbringer12 Oct 2022 9:13 a.m. PST

I heard that the ECW rules were adapted from a set of Marlburian or SYW rules, so maybe a bit of a hangover from these?

At least my copy of the rules (Foundry Publications, 2007) clearly states in the foreword on page 2 that the rules were

"… originally designed for the War of the Spanish Succession, and subsequently adapted for a wide variety of periods."

There are also army lists included for the Marlburian French and British force (pages 106-109), and on these lists musketeers tend to have higher fire factor than in the ECW and TYW lists (3 vs. 4), so some effort was taken to set apart the effectiveness of musketry between the different sub-periods.

Sorry - only verified members can post on the forums.