"Embattled Banner: The True History of the Confederate" Topic

… FLAG

""If you are a regular reader of Civil War Times, the Confederate battle flag is a familiar part of your world. The symbolism of the flag is simple and straightforward: It represents the Confederate side in the war that you enjoy studying. More than likely, your knowledge of the flag has expanded and become more sophisticated over the years. At some point, you learned that the Confederate battle flag was not, in fact, "the Confederate flag" and was not known as the "Stars and Bars." That name properly belongs to the first national flag of the Confederacy.

If you studied the war in the Western and Trans-Mississippi theaters, you learned that "Confederate battle flag" is a misnomer. Many Confederate units served under battle flags that looked nothing like the red flag with the star-studded blue cross. You may have grown up with more than just an idle knowledge of the flag's association with the Confederacy and its armies, but also with a reverence for the flag because of its association with Confederate ancestors. If you didn't, your interest in the war likely brought you into contact with people who have a strong emotional connection with the flag. And, at some point in your life, you became aware that not everyone shared your perception of the Confederate flag. If you weren't aware of this before, the unprecedented flurry of events and of public reaction to them that occurred in June 2015 have raised obvious questions that all students of Civil War history must confront: Why do people have such different and often conflicting perceptions of what the Confederate flag means, and how did those different meanings evolve?…"

Main page

link

Armand

One of the takeaways from this article is how easily systems that oppress can reinvent themselves as self pitying victims.

A good article in many ways. The idea of displaying the flag in context, having that kind of awareness, is something we have been discussing. Does not seem to mention the idea of the flag as a symbol of acts of war against the United States, however.

Foote and Faulkner paint some great imagery, but the flag lived far beyond nostalgia.

I have said many times, one of the toughest moments of Jan 6 for me was seeing that flag in the Capitol after so many died to keep it out long ago. A very different context.

For some, that flag means danger. But as a soldiers flag, I think it finds a better place in the story.

One of the takeaways from this article is how easily systems that oppress can reinvent themselves as self pitying victims.

As a Native American I can definitely tell you about oppressive systems and it has nothing to do with the Confederacy.

Those who served under Confederette Banners tried to kill members of my family. I'm not going to celebrate them or thank them.

Thanks

Armand

+10 Au pas de Charge