"Pommel Holster Question" Topic

There appears to be two modes for a pommel/saddle holster:

Closed – large flap visible at side, no visible pistol handle.

Open – Large flap now next to saddle pommel. Pistol handle visible, spare cartridges revealed (inside edge).

Question: Were there two positions for the pistol? One sat well in the holster (for closed) perhaps handle forwards; and the other standing proud out of the holster with handle backwards for access?

I imagine that the pistol remained firmly seated regardless.

I read that pistol butts were backwards to facilitate an off hand draw or a cross draw since one of the hands was the primary reign hand. Personal taste may have also been a factor since art shows the pistol butt both forwards and backwards.

i always thought the flaps (however elaborately decorated) were on every holster to protect the weapon and the powder from wet weather. they would then be folded back when the troops went into action for ease of access – butt forward or backwards being a matter of personal choice. the cartridges could have been on the flap but why? in battle at close range would there be time to reload? of course they could withdraw and reload but prepared cartridges would be better in a sealed pouch than on the flap. reloading is a delicate process on foot but on a nervous horse it would be a good trick. the rider needs both hands.

Pretty sure most holsters would have had some sort of flap that would be tucked back at need.
Butt forward makes sense… crossdraw much easier in a saddle.
NO reloading in combat unless withdrawn while a couple of other ranks go in to fire… and problematic, even then.

I am surprised that most pistols / carbines do not appear to have rings for lanyards? In 'Battle'… (probably rather more staid than assumed)… weapon re-holstered… but in melee… NO time for that! But, very expensive kit to drop.

I have only played 'silly games' with a bunch of other horsepersons…. but they were very 'confused'! Controlling, moving, identifying… WITHOUT swords or being shot at… well !
Melees… probably to be avoided! Maneuver instead! Only 50/50 chances in melee… and no time to muck about!