Help support TMP


"Pre-Game Spotting and Maneuver Systems" Topic


7 Posts

All members in good standing are free to post here. Opinions expressed here are solely those of the posters, and have not been cleared with nor are they endorsed by The Miniatures Page.

For more information, see the TMP FAQ.


Back to the Spaceship Gaming Message Board

Back to the Modern Aviation Discussion (1946-2007) Message Board

Back to the WWII Aviation Discussion Message Board


Areas of Interest

World War Two in the Air
Modern
Science Fiction

Featured Hobby News Article


688 hits since 26 Aug 2019
©1994-2020 Bill Armintrout
Comments or corrections?

Levi the Ox27 Aug 2019 8:31 p.m. PST

Hello all,

What systems (if any) are you using or would you recommend to handle the spotting, identification, and positioning of aircraft before they come into range? I am most familiar with Blood Red Skies, which has a simple dice roll to determine which pilots are aware and in a good position, but I've been exploring these sorts of pre-battle modules for ground games (the Patrol Phase in Chain of Command and the Scharnhorst module for Blucher) and am curious what options exist for aerial games in both the prop and jet ages.

I have Squadron Forward (mostly mission generation) and the Achtung Indianer! spotting board from the 2018 Lard Magazine, the latter of which looks promising. What else is there?

Thresher01 Supporting Member of TMP28 Aug 2019 12:06 a.m. PST

Usually the ones included with the rules.

Sometimes we ignore that altogether though, and assume everyone has spotted one another.

That way, things don't go badly for people unskilled at rolling the numbers they desire on their dice for this.

If "bounced" and clueless, things quickly go south for the situationally unaware.

Wilf1235828 Aug 2019 3:53 a.m. PST

TFL Bag The Hun uses 'Bogies' as unspotted blinds, including dummies to wrong foot the opposition.

Yellow Admiral29 Aug 2019 3:40 p.m. PST

There are really two different approaches to aerial gaming: the "dogfight" game and the "air battle" game.

Many popular classic air games are very much "dogfight" games because of their focus on individual plane and pilot characteristics: Mustangs & Messerschmitts, Check Your 6, Blue Max/Canvas Eagles, Mustangs, etc. A dogfight game is typically for a small number of planes per player (maybe only 1!) because it's all about maneuvering and shooting and outwitting the enemy, and it takes a lot of time and energy to manage each plane. For a game in this context, I find spotting rules completely inappropriate. It's a very poor gaming experience to be stuck as the "sitting duck", watching the enemy line up a perfect shot and depending on Lady Luck to spoil the shot. Miniatures gamers want to roll dice *and* move miniatures, not just remove them from the table, so in my opinion, the scenario should begin with all players aware of each other and able to being maneuvers on the first turn. Where they would be a fun equalizer or tactical puzzle, ambush situations can be represented in the setup conditions (e.g., the bouncing planes start with positional advantage).

An "air battle" game is a more expansive concept, aimed at playing fast and (usually) getting more planes on the table, by abstracting the individual maneuvers and shots, and focusing more on the overall mission. Some newer air games (Bag the Hun, Blood Red Skies) and many of the aerial rules included in naval games have a more "air battle" focus, typically abstracting individual plane maneuvers or just ignoring them altogether, to better focus the players' attention on the objective(s) of the mission and/or the importance of coordination and mutual support. In such a game, esp. with each player controlling multiple flights or even multiple squadrons, it makes perfect sense to try to model aerial ambushes in the course of the game. Bounced victims were a perfectly normal part of aerial combat, and might even be a critical force equalizer in an imbalanced theater (e.g. the 1941-42 Western Desert campaign).

There's no bright line between these two concepts, it's more a matter of focus and personal taste, and many rules try to cover both foci to some extent. However, I think it's a good idea to evaluate the main focus of the game before determining the appropriate use of spotting rules.

My only "recommendation" is a negative one: don't use the spotting rules in CY6. grin

I play a lot of CY6, and I find the spotting rules to be a waste of time, and poorly written too. I already mentioned that I consider CY6 very much a "dogfight" game, with a single flight of 2-4 planes about the maximum burden for any one player. The spotting rules pretty much require planes to fly straight and level until they "spot" an enemy, which can result in planes being left completely out of the fight. CY6 is a Hollywood-style dogfight game, not a hyper-accurate simulation for recreating the minutiae of pilot attrition in combat situations, so I really don't care if this kind of encounter is "realistic"; it's no fun in play.

I am still on the lookout for an "air battle" style game I like to play, so I don't have any personal recommendations. Lots of people enjoy BTH and BRS, so they're worth a look.

- Ix

Wolfhag02 Sep 2019 7:48 p.m. PST

The Fighting Wings system has an excellent "Tactical Maneuvering Grid" to handle positioning before the close-range dog fight begins. It can simulate a "bounce" very effectively and does allow maneuvering into position to gain an advantage before the fight starts

Wolfhag

Lion in the Stars03 Sep 2019 6:11 p.m. PST

I very much agree with Yellow Admiral's comments about the design differences between a Dogfight game and an Air Battle game.

If you're only playing one bird per player (or up to 4 birds per really good player, really), you have already spotted the opponent and you're in a Dogfight.

If you're playing a squadron or more per player, you can have spotting rules matter and you're in an Air Battle.

Marcin from Assault Publishing05 Oct 2019 11:51 a.m. PST

You can download my Shadows in the Void rulebook (free as pdf at assaultpublishing.com) and look at the system. The detecting/locking starfighters and misleading opponent before the combat are one of the most important aspects of the game.

Sorry - only verified members can post on the forums.