"a review of Hail Caesar supplement Sheild Wall" Topic

Hey everyone!

I purchased the HC supplement Shield Wall and wrote a review about it over on the blog. Mainly because when I was looking at it there was hardly any info online.

check it out why not?

link

Sadly, overall impression is quite 'meh.'

Agree with everything you say. Thanks for sharing! Plenty of better ways to get my dark ages fix…….

Thanks Ney Ney. Glad you read it.
(Now watch me. 😀).

The Warhammer Ancients "Shieldwall" was a great supplement!

I am half way through reading it now. I felt the same way about the skirmish rules: I would just use a different system for a skirmish game. However, I was still interested to read them as I have become a bit of a rules junky.

I read the skirmish rules because I was a little curious and for the purpose of the review. However I quickly thought of better systems for skirmish combat…
one of the was Lord of the rings SBG which is a great skirmish system (with the magic removed) which the rules borrow from (that zone of control mechanic is straight out of LOTR).

Thanks Stewart – great to read unbiased and thoughtful reviews of gaming products.

Matches my impression of most Hail Caesar products.

TomT