"The Guns of August " Topic

"The Guns of August is a documentary that follows the book by the same title by author, Barbara Tuchman (1912-1989), an eminent American historian. She received the first of her two Pulitzer prizes for this 1962 masterpiece on World War I. The documentary was made in 1965. Barbara Tuchman was highly respected for her ability to present complex subjects and present them with clarity. Until I read the previous review, I have never heard of anyone accusing her of hating Germany or its people or of her book being anti-German propaganda. But there are pictures of shot civilians and movies of smoldering ruins. Then again, there are people who claim the Holocaust never took place and is just anti-Nazi propaganda… Facts: On August 3 1914, Germany declared war on France. The German invasion plan for France called for an attack through Belgium, instead of through the heavily defended Franco-German border. Belgium was neutral and its neutrality was protected by treaty with Great Britain. The Germans attacked on August 3rd. The next day, August 4th, Great Britain declared war on Germany. Germany warned Belgium that they only wanted to reach France and if Belgium complied, there wouldn't be any trouble. Despite its small army, Belgium chose to protect its sovereignty and its honor and paid for it. Liège, Aarschot, Andenne, Tamines, Dinant, and Leuven, where the worst of the German depredations occurred."

YouTube link

Amicalement
Armand

Like nobody can read the BOOK already… Must we have EVERYTHING put into a visual format? I guess so, given the death of reading…

Tuchman's book has a wonderful dramatic style that will be hard to convey in a documentary. Her book has many historical inaccuracies. Far better is Sewell Tyng's earlier book – same dramatic style but way more sccurate

Robert

Howdy,

Wow, I agree with Robert. Tyng's book is excellent. Yet both have significant shortcomings. I had hoped Holger Herwig's book would be a comprehensive retelling. Boy, was I disappointed.

Ponder on,

JAS