Help support TMP


"Review of Miniature Wargames with Battlegames #373" Topic


13 Posts

All members in good standing are free to post here. Opinions expressed here are solely those of the posters, and have not been cleared with nor are they endorsed by The Miniatures Page.

Please don't make fun of others' membernames.

For more information, see the TMP FAQ.


Back to the Magazines and Periodicals Message Board


Areas of Interest

General

Featured Hobby News Article


Featured Recent Link


Featured Showcase Article

Lemax Christmas Trees

It's probably too late already this season to snatch these bargains up...


Featured Profile Article

Wild Creatures: Wild Animals

Third and last of the Wild Creatures series.


Current Poll


1,634 hits since 30 Apr 2014
©1994-2024 Bill Armintrout
Comments or corrections?

ubercommando30 Apr 2014 2:25 p.m. PST

This is my first review of this magazine after meeting Henry Hyde.

BRIEFING: How an imaginations tournament has re-kindled the enthusiasm flame and a mention of the Donald Featherstone Tribute weekend (more of this later).

FORWARD OBSERVER: Neil Shuck casts his eyes over new products from Agema, Gripping Beast and Battlegroup Barbarossa but of interest here is a range of 40mm Robin Hood figures from Trident. The Kickstarter list is absent from this month's column.

STEAMING AHEAD: Diane Sutherland's paddle steamer models are a bit tricky and time consuming to make, but they do look the part. If you liked her dirigibles from last month, then you'll like these.

FANTASY FACTS: 15mm Barbarians from Copplestone, Hydra miniatures War Rocket figures for dirtside battles plus the usual plethora of 15mm hard SF miniatures grace the column this month. The accompanying photos all do the products justice.

THREAT GENERATION: This one is for all you solo wargamers out there who want an enemy to genuinely surprise you on the table top. Martin England has devised a system which is both seemingly realistic but gives you the "where the heck did they come from?" ambush factor that you get in computer wargames such as Steel Panthers and Combat Mission. It doesn't look too tricky to use either.

SEND THREE AND FOURPENCE: How to put prisoner taking into your games. Some brief suggestions on how to do this, which is food for thought but…once again…I'd like to see more than one page devoted to some of Conrad Kinch's ideas.

OGRE: Blimey, this takes me back. Who'd have thought that after 35+ years Ogre would be the one SF board wargame of the 1970s to still be around? From a titchy black and white pocket game in a ziplock bag came a cast-iron concept for a game: One big f-off supertank versus a bunch of measly hovercraft tanks and infantry. This article is about the history of the game, and the setting, plus where the game stands now (apparently in a really heavy box with oodles of goodies). Some great photos of Ogre miniatures plus the 3D cardboard models you get with the current incarnation. I would have liked to have seen a scenario or gaming idea with this article but it's nice to see the old game still going strong.

FIGHTING FOR FEATHERSTONE: A report on the inaugural Featherstone trophy weekend in Basingstoke which seemed like a good time was had by old grognards and noobs alike. Nice photos of the players and the Gettysburg game that was run.

KEEP LUNCH WARM: A Great Northern War scenario where the Swedes under Charles XII (he of that gory mummified skull photo with the huge bullet hole in it) defeated a numerically superior Saxon-Polish force. Good balance of history, scenario and AAR but although things are written up with no particular rules system in mind, I would have liked to have known what rules were used for the actual game.

COMMAND CHALLENGE: I really like Andrew Rolph's articles as they're very thorough, and give you everything you need to run a scenario. This is an Operation Barbarossa game, recommended for Spearhead but Andrew gives suggestions as to how to adapt for other operational level WW2 games (without naming any). It's a long game; 32 turns over 6 hours, but full of tactical problems for the players to overcome. There's an AAR which is a tad too long for my liking and some of the Spearhead jargon (such as 4+1 DAv) could do with better explaining but it's a chunky scenario that should play well.

RECCE: Some new Osprey on review (one of which gets a scathing write up), a supplement for Impetvs but the stand out item here is the new edition of Hordes of the Things.

CAVALIER & HAMMERHEAD: John Treadaway reviews these two shows…+1 bonus point for featuring a lovely photo and mention of my club's Schweinfurt 1943 game and some cool looking 3D printed 1/144th scale APCs. It sounds like Hammerhead was the more interesting tournament and with each passing month I'm having my opinion changed about the usefulness or desirability of demonstration games. I'm now against them.

SALUTE 2014 SNAPSHOT: Hellooooooooo nurse!

OVERALL: A good issue that covers quite a few eras and which has a lot of practical stuff in it to take away and try at your club or next game at home. Not as controversial or opinionated as some other issues have been but definitely one to check out.

DiceatDawn01 May 2014 2:52 a.m. PST

GNW scenario was fought with Polemos Great Northern War I believe.

steamingdave4701 May 2014 6:55 a.m. PST

Diecatdawn is correct, Polemos GNW used and gave the right result (guess who was playing Swedish?)

ubercommando01 May 2014 8:46 a.m. PST

Thanks for the extra info on the GNW game. I've always had a sneaking admiration for Charles XII.

Cambria562201 May 2014 3:25 p.m. PST

I thought the Ogre article was significantly too long at 7 full pages – perhaps some material could have been moved online instead. The same could be said of the Command Challenge at 9 pages.

And for me the Salute 2014 Snapshot wasted more than half of the single page by giving it over to a large photo of the MWBG girls posing with some unconvincing reenactors. I'd far rather have seen a large photo, or a couple of smaller ones, of more games. I think that's what MWBG should stick with and leave the 'girlie pics' to other glossy magazines!

arthur181502 May 2014 2:53 a.m. PST

I tend to agree with Cambria5622 about the longer articles: this issue was rather dominated by them – great for those interested in those particular topics, not so good for those of us who aren't!

The report on the Featherstone tribute weekend did not really need such large photographs of the troops in the Gettysburg game – Don himself wrote that wargame soldiers do not need to be works of art, something we might do well to remember – and the Salute 'girlie' picture just did not seem right…

Littlearmies05 May 2014 10:32 a.m. PST

While I agree on the length of the articles and pictures of the Featherstone weekend. my comment on the Salute pic with the girls wasn't so much a complaint about them (after all it wasn't as if they had their boobs out or anything) but the re-enactors.

I've always thought re-enactors a bit strange (I went out with a woman who was a member of the Sealed Knot years ago and she did nothing to disabuse me of this notion), and these ones were a particularly egregious example being both overweight and wearing modern spectacles…

Paint it Pink07 May 2014 10:22 a.m. PST

@ubercommando

OGRE: Blimey, this takes me back. Who'd have thought that after 35+ years Ogre would be the one SF board wargame of the 1970s to still be around? From a titchy black and white pocket game in a ziplock bag came a cast-iron concept for a game: One big f-off supertank versus a bunch of measly hovercraft tanks and infantry. This article is about the history of the game, and the setting, plus where the game stands now (apparently in a really heavy box with oodles of goodies). Some great photos of Ogre miniatures plus the 3D cardboard models you get with the current incarnation. I would have liked to have seen a scenario or gaming idea with this article but it's nice to see the old game still going strong.

20thmaine

…oh, and I thought I was an OGRE fanatic – no more, I doff my cap to Ashley Pollard who makes my obsession look like the slightest of infatuations… grin

Thanks for the shout out and appreciation of the Ogre article.

John Treadaway08 May 2014 3:27 a.m. PST

Hear hear: Twas' a good thing!

John T

andycole08 May 2014 5:27 a.m. PST

This hasn't shown up in my latest WHSmith yet, anyone else having this trouble?

ubercommando08 May 2014 6:47 a.m. PST

Speaking of 70s sci-fi board wargaming, someone help me out here: What were the names of the SPI produced tactical wargames that were published late 70s/early 80s, some in the plastic counter tray box with the clear lid and were about futuristic Earth humans who could zip around the battlefield in jet packs? One game was a skirmish one, one was a bit more operational and one was the starship combat variant.

Paint it Pink09 May 2014 4:55 a.m. PST

StarForce and StarSoldier. Google is your friend.

ubercommando12 May 2014 7:30 a.m. PST

Thanks for that. Google is my friend but it's quicker to ask you guys.

Sorry - only verified members can post on the forums.