Help support TMP


"North Sea 1915 - Naval Thunder Report" Topic


11 Posts

All members in good standing are free to post here. Opinions expressed here are solely those of the posters, and have not been cleared with nor are they endorsed by The Miniatures Page.

For more information, see the TMP FAQ.


Back to the Naval Gaming 1898-1929 Message Board

Back to the Early 20th Century Battle Reports Message Board

Back to the Blogs of War Message Board


773 hits since 12 Oct 2012
©1994-2014 Bill Armintrout
Comments or corrections?

Personal logo scrivs Supporting Member of TMP12 Oct 2012 10:26 a.m. PST

Yesterday evening at Maelstrom Games we had our first WWI naval game using Naval Thunder.

picture

I have done a write up of the battle and included a load more images on the Scrivsland blog: link

SteelonSand12 Oct 2012 10:58 a.m. PST

Great after action report, nicely illustrated with photographs – very inspiring, if not for the luckless Royal Navy!

Some nice painting on the ships too, thanks for sharing.

Personal logo Texas Jack Supporting Member of TMP12 Oct 2012 11:43 a.m. PST

Itīs always a pleasure to visit your blog, scrivs, and this is no exception!

I do think it is a bit harsh giving the RN a penalty on gunnery. At Jutland they had the sun in their eyes for the first part, but afterwards they did well, regardless of what range finding technology they were using. Still, no cure for bad die rolls!

Personal logo scrivs Supporting Member of TMP13 Oct 2012 9:16 a.m. PST

Thanks chaps. We should be having a rematch on Thursday, hopefully that will go better for the Royal Navy.

Pontius15 Oct 2012 4:30 a.m. PST

At Jutland they had the sun in their eyes for the first part,

Surely not. During the late afternoon Battlecruiser Action Beatty's forces were west of Hipper's.
Later when Jellicoe's Battlefleet fired on Sheer the Germans were to the west and sillouetted against the setting sun, while the British were partially hidden against the darkening eastern horizon. A reversal of the situation at Coronel where Craddock was so comprehensively beaten.
The effect of light and differential visibility is a factor often overlooked by gamers so well done to Skrivs for introducing it.

Dexter Ward15 Oct 2012 6:29 a.m. PST

At Dogger Bank, British gunnery was pretty poor; Tiger had a new crew, and the explosive in the shells didn't go off properly. The rule for bad British shells in NT simulates this very nicely; it was after Dogger Bank that they sorted out the problem. So the penalty is nothing to do with the sun or with poor aiming.

TheDreadnought Sponsoring Member of TMP Inactive Member15 Oct 2012 8:16 a.m. PST

Looks like a great game! Hope you guys enjoyed it!

Thank you very much for sharing. A large part of the fun for me in writing Naval Thunder derives from seeing people have fun with it.

Here's a link to the rules for others who are curious:

link

Personal logo Texas Jack Supporting Member of TMP15 Oct 2012 12:19 p.m. PST

@Pontius- Right you are! My old brain just ainīt what it used to begrin

SteveM16 Oct 2012 10:54 a.m. PST

The problem was nothing to do with gunnery, as Dexter says it was a problem with the armour piercing shells, which was not sorted out until after Jutland.
The problem was only discovered by Beatty at a lunch party with a Swedish Naval officer in August 1916 (see 'Castles of Steel' page 668).

warren bruhn Inactive Member19 Oct 2012 7:28 p.m. PST

The British 1st & 2nd BC squadrons were quite bad in gunnery at Jutland compared to the Germans and compared to their own battleships, including the 5th battle squadron. The reason for the difference was that Jellicoe was having all the battleships train at gunnery inside Scapa Flow. The BCs stationed at Rosyth didn't get enough gunnery training. But the 3rd BC squadron (Hood) had been stationed at Scapa Flow for some gunnery training just before Jutland (replaced on a temporary basis by 5th BS), and the shooting of 3rd BC squadron was noticeably better at Jutland.

Also, in the British navy the BC were not regarded as an elite force, unlike the German scouting group. HMS Tiger in particular was manned by a lot of low grade crew, and the gunnery officer proved to be totally incompetent at Dogger Bank. I don't know how the Naval Thunder system works, but a gunnery penalty to the British 1st & 2nd BCS at Jutland is quite valid, and to all the British BCs before Jutland, and an extra penalty to Tiger at Dogger Bank. And note that at Dogger Bank none of the director fire control systems were yet operational on any of the British BCs (I think Tiger's was mostly installed but not yet working, and operators not yet trained).

StokieSteve Inactive Member23 Dec 2012 3:06 p.m. PST

Very nicely painted ships. What are the bases made from?

Sorry - only trusted members can post on the forums.