Help support TMP


"Strike on el-Alrish Yom Kippur War Oct. 18th 1973 CY6:JA" Topic


24 Posts

All members in good standing are free to post here. Opinions expressed here are solely those of the posters, and have not been cleared with nor are they endorsed by The Miniatures Page.

Please remember not to make new product announcements on the forum. Our advertisers pay for the privilege of making such announcements.

For more information, see the TMP FAQ.


Back to the Modern Aviation Painting Guides Message Board

Back to the Modern Gallery Message Board

Back to the Modern Battle Reports Message Board


Areas of Interest

Modern

Featured Hobby News Article


Featured Link


Top-Rated Ruleset

FUBAR


Rating: gold star gold star gold star gold star gold star gold star gold star gold star 


Featured Showcase Article


Featured Workbench Article

Maddogs and Englishmen...

Lonewolf dcc Fezian paints his favorite from Hasslefree's Zombie Hunter range.


Featured Profile Article

Council of Five Nations 2010

Personal logo Editor in Chief Bill The Editor of TMP Fezian is back from Council of Five Nations.


Featured Book Review


Featured Movie Review


4,397 hits since 13 Nov 2011
©1994-2022 Bill Armintrout
Comments or corrections?

Windward13 Nov 2011 4:01 p.m. PST

I've written a new scenario for Check Your 6: Jet Age for the Yom Kippur War, called "Strike on el-Arish" here is an AAR of one of our play test games.

History: By the summer of 1973 a total of 38 (Libyan) Mirage 5D and 5DEs were in full service with EAF. At the start of the war they were held in reserve flying CAP over the Nile. When the Americans began flying desperately needed supplies into the Israeli held el-Arish airfield in northern Sinai, the EAF decided to committed their few Mirages to attempt a low level strike on the airfield. Flying at surface level over the Mediterranean the Egyptians hope to slip in undetected. However, a USN E-2 Hawkeye spotted the approaching Egyptian Mirages, and informed the Israelis. A pair of Neshers heading towards the Suez Canal were vectored to intercept the oncoming strike.

Setup, the Egyptians have a cloud of Mirage 5s (10 aircraft broken into 2 elements, a lead element of 4 Mirages, and a trail element of 6 with a mix of 6 green pilots and 4 skilled), these are loaded with bombs and do not carry Air to Air Missiles, as they were outfitted to carry AIM-9 Sidewinders, but the Americans had not provided the Libyans with any, and the Egyptians had not had the time to convert the fittings to carry Atolls. However the Mirages are valuable so +1 VP per kill.

The Israelis have a pair if Neshers armed with a pair of deadly Shafrir II missiles with a veteran and a skilled pilot.

The table is 45x30 hexes with the long axis North-South. The North 2/3 are considered water, the airfield located in the Southern third of the table, is defended by 3 light AAA positions and a HAWK battery. Nominally the Egyptians have surprise, so the lead element sets up very close to the airfield, and will reach it in a couple of turns. (There is a possibility the airfield will not react to their arrival and not fire till the first attack by variable rule). The trail element will enter the Northern End of the table on a variable turn, and the Neshers will enter the South West bottom or Edge of the table also on a variable turn.

Startup: The Israelis roll the worst possible variable result: "Americans on the ramp" (+1 VP for bomb hit), the Egyptians got to exchange a green pilot for a veteran pilot and ran him in the lead element.

The Israelis rolled an early entry (turn 1) and entered the South West edge and to tried to intercept the first wave of bombers. As the EAF Mirages closed on the airfield, each Neshers each launched a single Shafrir. One smoked a green EAF Mirage, and the second missed with the second. Score: Israel 3, Egypt 0.

The first missile hit!

The following turn the Mirages attacked the airfield. Only a single Mirage hit the airfield, but the EAF Vet, bulls eyed a C-141Starlifter for 6 VP (2 VP per hit, +1 per hit for variable rule). Score: Israel 3, Egypt 6 (Tricky Dick is going to have a tough time explaining this).

Seeing Egyptian lead element had done its damage, the Israelis Immelmanned away from the airfield and turned towards the second element to try to intercept the next wave of 6 Mirages. The Skilled pilots of the Egyptian lead element then circled around and started to chase the Neshers. The Egyptian Vet, went HAWK hunting, and managed to miss on his first run, while the HAWK reached out and smoked an incoming green Mirage. Score: Israel 6, Egypt 6.

The EAF Mirages bank away from the airfield in pursuit

The Israelis had a problem, they had to move towards the pack of 5 Mirages, and not give the Egyptians a ton of shots at the oncoming Neshers. So they kept an outside line, and burned towards the Egyptians, while the pair of Mirages from the first strike chased. The HAWK failed to lock on a new target, as the Egyptian Vet missed another gun run on it.

The chase is on, the bombers to the left, the Neshers in the middle, the lead element Mirages to the right. Note the smoke to the left the HAWK kill, and the Vet strafing the HAWK battery in the upper right

The Israelis Neshers then Split S into the rear of the bomber formation and got a crappy gun shot at a passing Mirage, and missed. Due to the Split S, they were unable to launch Shafrir. The Israelis added speed so they could chase the fleeing bombers (bad mistake). The chasing EAF Mirages from the lead element where close to the Neshers. The HAWK locked and smoked another Green Mirage. Score: Israel 9, Egypt 6.

To the Israeli player's horror, he realized I could only make Extreme turns (and thus unable to launch missiles), at speed, the Israelis were at an angle to cross the bomber formation, and away from the chasing Mirages. So, the Israelis ended up behind the formation, but unable to use the Shafrir. The Israeli's got a long range gun shot, and missed.

Neshers unable to get a good shot, the chasing EAF Mirages, burn to close in on them.

The EAF Vet had to Immelmann for another run at the HAWK. The HAWK locked and fired and missed, then died to the Vet.

Now, the Israelis were in real trouble, EAF Mirages on all sides and only 3 loaded ones left (one had unloaded on its own to take on the Neshers) The Israeli skilled pilot was not in position to move last, and ended up moving early in the sequence, and got into trouble, some of the trailing element Mirages had reached the airfield and where bombing, the AAA was ineffective, and the loaded Mirages made their run on the airfield. The Israelis launched their last Shafrirs, at them, one hit for 48 points (and he shook it off!), the second Shafrir fell dead off the rail. However, both bombers missed on their bombing run.

The chasing EAF Mirages, snapped around and lined up the skilled Israeli pilot and hit him twice, he shook off the first hit, and blew up on the second. Score: Israel 9, Egypt 12.

A Sky full of Mirages, before the Death of Amit (the skilled Israeli pilot), the sole loaded Mirage is the one with the gray dice.


A single loaded Mirage remained; it turned south to make his run on the airfield, with the Israeli veteran pilot on his tail. The Israeli was unable to prevent the Egyptian from dropping his bombs, but, he fired a burst and smoked the skilled Mirage. Score: Israel 15, Egypt 12.

But the bomber had dropped his bombs, if he missed the Israelis won, if he hit, they tied. He rolled boxcars, another burning Starlifter, 2 hits 6 points! Final Score: Israel 15, Egypt 18.

Final toll: 4 dead Mirage 5s, 3 green 1 skilled (All KIA). 1 dead Nesher (KIA) and 4 runway hits.

Close game everyone liked it. The Scenario can be found in the Check Your 6! Yahoo Group, in the files under: Jet Age player designed scenarios

BTW for the EAF Mirages camo, I used Vallejo Ocher Yellow as the base, with Reflective Green and French Mirage Blue, over Pale Blue.

RazorMind13 Nov 2011 6:47 p.m. PST

Nice looking game, where did you get those stands?

Windward13 Nov 2011 7:55 p.m. PST

Those are standard Litko flight bases with a custom dice holder overlay, with a d6 and a d8. They work great and are easy to read across the table. Litko should have the design on file. You have to slightly modify the base to mount the post at a 30 to 40 degree angle so it doesn't interfere with the d8. But I like the look of the forward leaning pole!

Windward13 Nov 2011 9:11 p.m. PST

Btw the dice tray Litko number is Q20110720-003

foxbat13 Nov 2011 11:46 p.m. PST

Excellent report! Your minis look beautiful.
Are your hexed mats Holtz products?

Windward14 Nov 2011 6:27 a.m. PST

Yes, I have two mats I just laid one over the other.

Mako1114 Nov 2011 6:44 p.m. PST

Nice looking jets!

Thanks for sharing your battle report.

tuscaloosa27 Nov 2011 8:47 a.m. PST

Very nice looking planes, and I like the unique use of dice to show height.

Windward02 Dec 2011 10:39 p.m. PST

Since most CY6:JA game are two CAB, if the front altitude die (d6) matches the speed die (d8) then you are in the lower CAB, if not your in the higher CAB. Makes reading the height from across the table much easier.

Joep12304 Dec 2011 6:35 p.m. PST

Great report and photos.
I also like the aircraft and stands with the dice.
Are the aircraft 1/300 scale?
Thanks
Joe

Windward05 Dec 2011 9:10 p.m. PST

Hi Joe

No those are 1/600th Tumbling Dice. You can field the entire force both sides with 4 packs of Mirage Vs (with 2 extra Neshers!).

For Jet Age, the 1/600s are a good size, the price at $3.28 a pack (from Brookhurst) is a good deal.

The planes paint up wonderfully, I painted up the entire Egyptian force in 3 evenings.

Windward06 Dec 2011 11:24 a.m. PST

Btw all the decals, are from Dom's Decals, he also carries Tumbling Dice aircraft as well.

Windward01 Apr 2014 7:20 p.m. PST

Btw a correction, the Libyan Mirage 5s where to be armed with Matra Magics, and were wired to carry them. The wiring was not compatible with either the AIM-9 or Atoll. The French had not provided then to Libyans with them at the time of the transfer to Egypt.

hindsTMP14 Apr 2014 9:32 a.m. PST

Looks nice, although photos a bit blurred. I am not seeing any EAF insignia on the planes.

MH

Windward25 Apr 2014 7:01 p.m. PST

They are there, the roundels are really small. The Israeli ID triangles are easy to spot (by design) Thus the problem the Israelis faced when they found out the Egyptians had the Mirage too.

OldGlory Andy29 Aug 2014 2:26 a.m. PST

Interesting – I'm starting to look at jet combat very new to this, – though I want to use 1/100 aircraft simply because I like the model size and it matches my ground troops .
I've looked at the Tumbling dice models and yes they are very nice but Teeny – TINY .
I've done 1/100th WW2 but jets are .. as I'm findfing out- a bit different
However having just released a 1/100th Hawker Hunter its a "mastermind moment"- I've started so I'll finish …

gameboards29 Aug 2014 7:21 a.m. PST

I admire and respect very much how well you researched this era in israeli history and the work you did to paint up those marvelous miniatures jets

I think a better game board would make this scenario really spiffing

a uniform, three dimensional cardboard-layered wargame board, painted yellow, without the dice, flocked with real sand, tiny trees, and blue-plexiglass water, would make this whole game even better. you could choose the exact part of the sinai penninsula you want to game on, and make the board look exactly like it would look from a bird's eye view

by the way, I really do like this kind of scenario, very specific, very realistic

also, do your rules use the different kinds of aerial maneuvers to determine the chances of getting a good shot at the enemy?

Deadone31 Aug 2014 7:28 p.m. PST

Wow. That was a great read. Awesome looking game too.

2 burning Starlifters cue Soviet MiGs v USAF F-4s for next game!

Windward28 Sep 2014 3:48 p.m. PST

Thank you

Andy, if you want to go big look at Armaments in Minature 1/200th scale minis. Resin, light weight and roughly the cost of lead. Also F-4s are huge beasts in 1/100th scale.

Windward28 Sep 2014 3:56 p.m. PST

Gameboards the rules are fairly simple there are only a few modifiers for shooting. Not the most realistic but very playable and realistic enough for government work.

Windward02 Dec 2014 8:45 p.m. PST

I did a reorder of dice trays and got a new number:

link

Joep12308 Dec 2014 10:05 p.m. PST

Hi Windward;
I just re-read this AAR…still a great read.
And taking your advice back 3 years ago I went with 1/600 for my Korean War Jet Age.
Thanks again;
Joe

acctingman186914 Dec 2014 8:29 p.m. PST

Winward

What size magnets are those and where did you get the round metal balls from?

What glue did you use?

Thanks

Windward03 Jan 2015 3:59 p.m. PST

Acctingman The balls are 3/16" diameter steel balls the magnet rings are 1/8" x1/16" x1/16" from K & J Magnetics I found Slow Zap CA as the best glue, it doesn't snap off on shock of attaching.

Sorry - only verified members can post on the forums.