"Favorite pie?" Topic

With all of the negativity going on this week, perhaps a poll about something dear to many of us will calm the waters somewhat so that we can resume talking about games and miniatures (fat chance, I know, but at least it's an attempt).

So what's your favorite pie?

I'll start the nominations with the ones I like best:

Nesselrode
Blueberry
Chocolate pecan
Cherry
Raspberry

Since most of you (with the possible exception of the OFM) probably don't know what a nesselrode pie is, here's a link: link

In the interests of full disclosure, I must state for the record that I don't like ice cream diluting the purity of my pie experience. I love ice cream, just not on top of pie.

So what's your favorite?

Whatever Olivia Munn from G4 is jumping in.

Wow, now that's a tought provoking question! I like them all!

Raspberry and Lemon would be my two favourites, with apple (yes, à la mode) not far behind. And any pie my mother makes is obviously MUCH better.

Oh, and does Tourtière link counts? Add that to my favourites!

Pecan

and it is pronounced Puh CAHN not PEE can

My wife makes the best peanut butter pie in the whole flppin' world. She even makes her crust from scratch. It would not be a life without this home made treasure. She also makes a great apple pie with apples picked from a local orchard.

Chess!

Meat and Tattie.

Key Lime.

Pork from Melton Mowbray with a slather of mustard.

Key lime with chocolate grahamn cracker crust & sliced strawberries on top,
and cheesecake.

Coconut Creme with whipped cream in place of meringue. Wyatt's Cafeteria used to make a great one.

I have to vote for:

Pecan
Pumpkin
Shoofly
Blackberry

Oatmeal pie from Country Fare in Myerstown, PA

Pork Pie wins for me as well, although French Silk Pie is a close second.

Pear (made from a medieval French recipe, as a matter of fact).

Doug

Key Lime (graham cracker crust), Apple Crumble, Pork, Pecan, Coconut Cream, Banana Cream, Macadamia Nut Cream, Pumpkin, Blackberry/Boysenberry, Cheesecake

Pork
Steak and Kidney
Chicken and Mushroom

Seal flipper.

Hoser

Melton Mowbray Pork Pie

Steak or Steak and Kidney for main course.
Apple for pudding.

Historicalgamer: I never had the pleasure to try oatmeal pie. I may need to beg you to bring me some for Fall In.

DK

I am intolerant of your pie(s). All of them. I prefer cake. :)

YouTube link

Nothing finer.

"This video contains content from Vevo, who has blocked it in your country on copyright grounds."

odd, what is it then?> UK here.

A sweet apple crumble with lashings of custard.

Steak and kidney with nice puff pastry….

Apple followed by Blueberry followed by Banana Cream.

Blackberry
Pecan
Strawberry Cream
Apple

sweet potato

Mongo

Bricole

Apple or pumpkin. I can't decide.

Dave

Only apple pie is real pie--other pies are shoddy, third-rate corruptions of real pie. People who prefer or produce other pies should be given incentives to emigrate.

Boston Cream Pie (it's actually a cake); with Pineapple Cream pie a very close second.

Humble.

FRENCH apple (with a lattace top).

PEE-can, with 'lasses !

Actually, any dessert pie ! Love 'em all !

I used to do a mean lemon meringue, using my great-grandmother's recipe.

I wonder if I can remember it (or find it; I must have written it down somewhere)?

My sainted mother's blueberry.

Claim-Jumper's Chocolate Silk Pie – really more like ice cream than pie, but it is delicious.

A good Key Lime is probably next – most aren't.

Lemon Meringue.

Did I mention I actually prefer cake – Butter Cake, with Milk Chocolate frosting.

Pound Cake with a Lemon and Sugar glazing, heavy enough to soak into it, to make it ultramoist.

Cherry Chip too, though the mix for it is hard to find, and the frosting is next to impossible to locate. Use vanilla frosting, and add cherry flavoring, red food coloring, and maraschino cherry chips. Delicious.

Homemade for most of the above is best.

Pizza

Apple pie and a close second is Sweet Potato.

How about a big slice of humble pie?
VR
James Mattes

Lemon, key lime….I can't think of any others at the moment.

pecan and sugar cream…..mmmmm

Apple w/ crumbly crust n topping.

Pumpkin with whipped cream.
Cherry a close second.

Mississippi Mud Pie! Astoria, New York 30 Ave and 33 st Greek Cafe!

Calves' heart pot pie for the meal, peach cream pie for dessert.

I love a good pie – steak pie, steak and pepper pie, chicken pie, chicken curry pie, shepherds pie, leek and bacon pie, pork pie, egg and bacon pie and even a pie floater (a meat pie in pea and ham soup).

Grans lancashire meat and potato pie followed by hot apple pie and Ice cream. good pie day all round.