darthfozzywig | 29 Aug 2009 8:58 p.m. PST |
Not that I'm going to give in to temptation (curse you, GZG and Rebel Minis!), but if
just IF I lost my mind and started into 15mm sci-fi madness, are there any suggestions for Hammer's Slammers-style combat cars BESIDES Old Crow's? I know they're the "official" ones (even if they look nothing like any cover art or illustration I've seen), but they look too much like shoes for my taste. Granted, they do add a more literal aspect to "kicking" ass or giving someone a "taste of the boot" while fighting
|
Legion 4 | 29 Aug 2009 9:13 p.m. PST |
Ah
regardless of the old book covers
the Old Crow models were approved by Drake himself
So If Drake likes them thats good enough for me
|
Top Gun Ace | 29 Aug 2009 9:56 p.m. PST |
I like the looks of the hover jeeps they sell. I agree on the vehicles though. They look nothing like the book covers, sadly. |
Eli Arndt | 29 Aug 2009 10:33 p.m. PST |
I'm not so sure you'll find anything in 15mm other than the Old Crow stuff. You could try kitbashing your own or look at Force XXI. As for book covers, I tend to place little merit in the "accuracy" of book covers ever since I learned that in many if not most cases, the author has absolutely no say on what goes on the cover his book. That being said, there is some really good stuff done on book covers. GZG's 25mm Combat Cars are cool and I always wish they would do 15mm versions of them. I am not sure if that flies in the face of the licensing agreements for the various game products for the Slammers game, but maybe someday Jon will do 15mm Combat Cars of his own. There are some flat bed vehicles in GZG's line that might make a good start for building your own 15mm Combat Cars. -Eli leadpeople.blogspot.com |
Dropship Horizon | 30 Aug 2009 12:24 a.m. PST |
Depending how big you envisage your Combat Cars, I suggest using as a basis for conversion either: GZG V15-45A High-tech Grav Armoured Carrier Sled (open flatbed) or smaller: GZG V15-43A High-tech Grav Light Tank The top of the hull is removeable on the Light Tank and provides a good working area for a samllish combat car. I suggest the tank because it's the same price as the other High-tech Light Grav models and you can use the turret as a defence turret or kitbash another vehicle. Cheers Mark dropshiphorizon.blogspot.com |
darthfozzywig | 30 Aug 2009 5:43 a.m. PST |
I totally missed the armored carrier sleds, Mark. Those look like a great base to start from. Great idea! GZG's 25mm Combat Cars are cool and I always wish they would do 15mm versions of them. Indeed. :) Thanks for the suggestions, folks! |
Legion 4 | 30 Aug 2009 7:01 a.m. PST |
But
most of those covers were done before the Old Crow models were made & later approved by Drake
I know one of the model designers told me it took Drake a number of attempts before he decided on these
So if he wanted a version from one of the book covers
he would have chosen one of those instead on the Old Crow versions
However do what works for you
And I was not a fan of any of the book covers
Frankly, for me this link says it all
link He said this was what he was thinking of when he wrote the books
|
Eli Arndt | 30 Aug 2009 9:13 a.m. PST |
Thanks for the heads-up on the GZG models Mark. I' not familiar enough with their line to give as detailed a suggestion as you did. Also, I was not aware that the light tank had a removable troop deck like that. I may have to pick a few up to kill two birds with one stone. I need some light turrets and would like to make some combat cars too. Went and checked the site and all of the V15-43 through V15-45 would work well to capture the style of the Combat Cars depicted on many of the covers and even in GZG's own 25mm line. The only thing really missing are the fan ducts in the top deck. -Eli leadpeople.blogspot.com |
Agent Smith | 30 Aug 2009 10:28 a.m. PST |
Darthfozzywig, While I don`t do; or am ever likely to do 15mm, I couldn`t agree more with you about the Old Crow Hammer's Slammers vehicles, excellent castings that they are, they sure are ugly and I have always prefered the GZG designs which look like tanks and combat cars and not like training shoes LOL. My real aim is to get Jon to do some 6mm versions of his 25mm stuff, although if he did 15mm slammers I may have to buy some models in that scale to do HS justice, but I would much prefer 6mm. One can hope though, good luck with the search. AS |
Legion 4 | 30 Aug 2009 10:49 a.m. PST |
Hopefully Old Crow will do their official Slammer M2, M9, Jeep & Hog in 6mm
they said they would but
|
Eli Arndt | 30 Aug 2009 11:03 a.m. PST |
Personally, I don't mind the Old Crow designs but think there is nothign wrong with having more designs available or making your own. Heck, if anything, you could have two forces using different types of Combat Cars. -Eli |
darthfozzywig | 31 Aug 2009 8:26 a.m. PST |
He said this was what he was thinking of when he wrote the books In that case, happily, he never described them "accurately". "Tribarrels blazing, the giant iridium track shoe slipped over the hill, racing down the slope as if in the 100-meter sprint. Powerguns sent bursts streaming forth like angry shoelaces
" Prior to receiving a check for licensed miniatures (and an RPG supplement from Mongoose), his basis for the combat cars was the ACAVs in Vietnam. Come to think of it, I might look into converting those
|
Eli Arndt | 31 Aug 2009 8:33 a.m. PST |
Prior to receiving a check for licensed miniatures (and an RPG supplement from Mongoose), his basis for the combat cars was the ACAVs in Vietnam. Come to think of it, I might look into converting those
"Basis" is a very broad term. His vehicles have always been described with an open crew deck. They sound a lot more like the improvised gun trucks as far as the deck is concerned. I do have a bunch of ACAVs gathering dust that might need some sort of similar conversions, just the same. -Eli |
Dropship Horizon | 31 Aug 2009 11:01 a.m. PST |
I totally missed the armored carrier sleds, Mark. Those look like a great base to start from. Great idea! I know, I'm amazed by my own brilliance sometimes! LOL! Now I've seen the new GZG pintle gunners, picture I'm tempted to create my own GZG Combat Cars! Cheers Mark |
Dropship Horizon | 31 Aug 2009 11:57 a.m. PST |
Just done a quick test using a GZG V15-43A High-tech Grav Light Tank. I can fit 2 gunners easily and a third with a bit of a squeeze. I'll pop it up on the blog tomorrow. Cheers Mark dropshiphorizon.blogspot.com |
darthfozzywig | 31 Aug 2009 12:24 p.m. PST |
Just done a quick test using a GZG V15-43A High-tech Grav Light Tank. I can fit 2 gunners easily and a third with a bit of a squeeze. I love you. |
Top Gun Ace | 31 Aug 2009 1:00 p.m. PST |
You could probably use their skimmers/air-rafts as combat cars, especially if you arm them with the new GZG releases. |
Dropship Horizon | 31 Aug 2009 2:02 p.m. PST |
Sorry Top Gun, I think they remain just an armed skimmer/air-raft. Take a look at my idea which I've demonstrated in outline here on Dropship Horizon: link Once I get a set of the pintle gunners from Jon, I'llkitbash a Combat Car in full this week. Cheers Mark |
Eli Arndt | 31 Aug 2009 2:29 p.m. PST |
Mark, It looks good, but I don't suppose we could get a top down pic? It's a bit hard to judge the overall spacial relation in the open back section at the angle in your pic. Looks way too small in that pic. Love the idea and cataloguing it in "must use" file. -Eli |
Dropship Horizon | 01 Sep 2009 3:09 a.m. PST |
Will do Eli once I start my full kitbash later in week. Cheers Mark |
Legion 4 | 01 Sep 2009 9:30 a.m. PST |
Well besides the pic of Drake holding the O/C M2 & M9
which sold it for me
I commanded a company of M113's('87-'89), which is a same as an ACAV save for the small turret around the TC's hatch
Which we had on our M113s in the ROK('84-'85). Believe an M113 is not a very good ballistic design
The only basis for an M113/ACAV and an M9 Combat Car is the fact that the M113 has a .50 HMG on the TC's cupola and an M60 MG can be mounted on both sides of the Troop hatch behind the TC's position
The 3 Tri-barrels are mounted in a similar manner on the M9
Besides I read all the Slammer books and commanded an M113 Mech Co.
So I'm sticking with O/C's Drake Approved M9s
But as I always say
Do what works for you
|
darthfozzywig | 01 Sep 2009 9:42 a.m. PST |
Hi Legion! I see you've made four posts on this "suggestions BESIDES Old Crow's" thread
three of which are saying "BUT DRAKE APPROVED OLD CROW!!!!" That cry for attention really should be heeded. We're all really glad you like Old Crow's design and are happy it got a stamp of approval from Mr. Drake. That really is super! Yay! For my part, I couldn't care less what the author approves of in hindsight after getting a paycheck. It's pretty clear he never really had a clear idea of what a combat car looks like, since he never really went into a very detailed description. It just wasn't that important to the story. Now that someone handed him a design he could say "Yeah, sure, that's great!" Good for him!
But as I always say
Do what works for you
That's why I started a thread saying "suggestions BESIDES Old Crow's". ;) Feel free to start your own "David Drake said he approves Old Crow's design – I love no other!" thread. I'll even be a sport and not post over and over on it pointing out how much like a featureless shoe it is. :) |
Eli Arndt | 01 Sep 2009 10:49 a.m. PST |
Um
Darth
relax. Though I agree Legion may be a bit off point with his remarks, the direct attack on his posts really isn't warranted. As for your opinions on Drake, I think that it's pretty clear based on the lack of really solid Drake-based gaming stuff over the long years of fandom and attempts at gaming his stuff, that he's really not the money-grubbing sort who would slap his name on anyone who drove a hovertruck full of money up to his door. You are right that he never clearly defines what they look like, but that doesn't mean that the artist working on Old Crow's project didn't finally show him somethign that was what in his mind's eye had been seeing. Also, we don't know how amny designs got scrapped. I'd love to see some of the interum designs, myself and maybe see them made into alternate miniatures to fill out the line. Though, with the nature of computer modelling there may not be any early designs as they may simply have tweaked the same one until they got it right. Bringing it all together, the M113 ACAV to hover gun car isn't a bad idea. I worked up a cheap and dirty picture edit in Paint to show how the addition of a simple skirt would work. picture Nothing pretty but a little scifi drag should do it good. I'd love to see Jon convert some of his 25mm Slammers style stuff to 15mm. They even fit the styling of his current line of 15mm Eli leadpeople.blogspot.com |
ZeroGee2 | 01 Sep 2009 10:57 a.m. PST |
The problem is that the combat car as described in the books is a bit Tardis-like – you simply CANNOT make it work as written. I suspect that David had the overall size of the M113 ACAV in mind when he wrote the books, and of course that is a vertical-slab-sided box; but in at least one of the books, the combat car is described as having a sloped deck all around the fighting compartment that it is possible to stand on (albeit precariously), and then the skirt flares out from there – the end result of trying to represent this is that the footprint of the vehicle is HUGE, almost a big as the blower tanks. In an attempt to get round this, when I did our early design (after much discussion with John Treadaway for the original Warlords' Slammers game) I did the skirt slanted inwards rather than out – and STILL had to make the sides of the hull almost vertical. This is the problem that Jez had with his OC design – by the time you've put the fighting compartment in the middle, there simply isn't room to keep it within the kind of overall size the books imply, while still following the rest of the written descriptions – hence it either ends up WAY too big, OR like a baby's trainer! ;-) Jon (GZG) |
Eli Arndt | 01 Sep 2009 11:10 a.m. PST |
I never got the impression they were all that small in the stories, so it never phased me. BTW, Jon, please scale down the Blowers and Combat Cars you did for the Warlords games. -Eli |
Dropship Horizon | 01 Sep 2009 11:11 a.m. PST |
I'm glad I don't do Slammers. Falkenberg's Legion are my boys. Cheers Mark |
Legion 4 | 01 Sep 2009 12:12 p.m. PST |
|
Eli Arndt | 01 Sep 2009 1:21 p.m. PST |
It's amazing what you can do with images found online. -Eli |
darthfozzywig | 01 Sep 2009 4:00 p.m. PST |
Sorry, Legion, I think I went overboard there. :D |
Eli Arndt | 01 Sep 2009 4:31 p.m. PST |
We still love you Darth This topic is very interesting, to be honest. I am a big fan of making one thing into another. I have turned M20 Scout Cars from WW2 into hover scouts and M557 Sheridans into hovertanks link Let us know what you come up with and please show them when you have something to show. -Eli |
darthfozzywig | 01 Sep 2009 6:38 p.m. PST |
Oooooh nice project, Eli! By the way, a friendly curse to all of you who are luring me into 15mm sci-fi. I really didn't want to switch scales, but I find myself inching well over the line. And you should see the pile of 15mm MBA buildings that just arrived from my GenCon order. Yes, I've lost my mind. @_@ |
Legion 4 | 01 Sep 2009 6:40 p.m. PST |
|
Eli Arndt | 01 Sep 2009 6:59 p.m. PST |
Correction, should have been M551 not M557. I have both in my collection and get them confused. Darthy, thanks for your kind words. Welcome to 15mm. You too will soon know the madness of tiny men. I suggest you really try bashing out your own vehicles. Nothing like bringing a vehicle to the table that nobody else has. -Eli |
Legion 4 | 01 Sep 2009 7:19 p.m. PST |
Yes, I had an M577 Command Track in Korea
Not an M551 Light Airborne Amphibious Assault Vehicle
The only guys who use those are the 82d Airborne & the OPFOR at NTC
|
Eli Arndt | 01 Sep 2009 7:22 p.m. PST |
The M551 is really good conversion bait for sci-fi. -Eli |
John Treadaway | 08 Sep 2009 1:48 a.m. PST |
|
Dropship Horizon | 08 Sep 2009 3:11 a.m. PST |
take a look at the Force XXI Grav and GEC 'trucks' lot's of potential there. Cheers Mark |