Help support TMP


POLL: Ideal "Universal Handshake" Game? (Round 1)


512 votes were cast by total voters.


Back to POLLS home page


Personal logo piper909 Supporting Member of TMP writes:

Another vote for Pulp Alley. The basic rules are very clean, fast-playing, and almost infinitely flexible to accommodate all sorts of adventure gaming. I even use them for historical skirmish games now. You can use almost any terrain OR figures at hand and you don't need a huge amount of either for a simple entry-level game.


Back to the Homepage



1,065 hits since 11 Jun 2015
©1994-2017 Bill Armintrout
Comments or corrections?

If you were a member of this website, you could participate in website polls. Would you like a free membership?

VOTING RESULTS
AnswerVotes%Chart
Aeronef
7
1%
bar of chart
AK47
15
3%
bar of chart
Battletech
14
3%
bar of chart
Blood Bowl
10
2%
bar of chart
Car Wars
9
2%
bar of chart
Circus Maximus
7
1%
bar of chart
De Bellis Antiquitatis
51
10%
bar of chart
Dreadball
3
1%
bar of chart
Dystopian Wars
3
1%
bar of chart
Empire
5
1%
bar of chart
Epic Armageddon
2
0%
bar of chart
Fields of Glory
4
1%
bar of chart
Firestorm Armada
0
0%
 
Flames of War
25
5%
bar of chart
Form Line of Battle
1
0%
bar of chart
General Quarters
12
2%
bar of chart
Gruntz
4
1%
bar of chart
Hordes of the Things
34
7%
bar of chart
Infinity
3
1%
bar of chart
Johnny Reb
10
2%
bar of chart
Lord of the Rings/Hobbit Strategy Battle Game
12
2%
bar of chart
Ludus Gladiatorius
1
0%
bar of chart
Mars Attacks
0
0%
 
Mighty Armies/Mighty Armies: Ancients
4
1%
bar of chart
Newbury 'Fast Play' Ancients
2
0%
bar of chart
Saga
19
4%
bar of chart
Song of Blades and Heroes
25
5%
bar of chart
Sword and the Flame, The
53
10%
bar of chart
Terry Wise's ACW rules
3
1%
bar of chart
Tomorrow's War
11
2%
bar of chart
Uncharted Seas
0
0%
 
War & Conquest
0
0%
 
Warhammer 40000
14
3%
bar of chart
Warhammer Ancient Battles
8
2%
bar of chart
Warhammer Fantasy Battle
11
2%
bar of chart
Warmachine/Hordes
0
0%
 
Warmaster/Warmaster Ancients
11
2%
bar of chart
Wings of War/Wings of Glory
34
7%
bar of chart
X-Wing
23
4%
bar of chart
other (explain)
15
3%
bar of chart
no opinion
6
1%
bar of chart
there can be no such thing
41
8%
bar of chart
POLL IS CLOSED
POLL DESCRIPTION

Rhoderic III and counting Inactive Member observes...

In your ideal world, what would be the undisputed "universal handshake" game of the miniature wargaming hobby? In other words, the game that every hobbyist would ideally dabble in quite apart from any other projects and interests they have in the hobby to the extent that they know the rules and have at least one painted army/warband/fleet/whatever for it (or several, if it's a game where only certain faction match-ups are allowed). The game for which the average hobbyist would naturally bring a standard-sized force (and some terrain and possibly a playing surface, if needed) to any hobbyists' get-together for potential pick-up battles, even with strangers.

This is a question not only about your personal favorite game, but also about which game you would find most practical and serviceable for that purpose, taking into account factors like ease of painting/collecting, ease of learning the rules, ease of lugging around, broadness of appeal, and suitability for the imperfect conditions of most pick-up gaming sessions.

It has to be a miniatures game. It would be peremptory of me to disallow "no opinion" or "there shouldn't be one" as answers, but I ask you to keep in mind that this question is about your fantasy of the miniature wargaming hobby ideal.

Myself, I think I'd want it to be Aeronef. The rules are simple and beer-and-pretzel-oriented, gameplay is fairly fast, the models are easy to paint (and even relatively easy to scratchbuild for those who want to take that approach), Brigade Models has a large and ever-growing range (and there are other sources for models as well), it's fairly cheap, fleet-building is free-form (there's a ship construction system and no defined factions), no terrain is needed, the setting is open-ended and fantastical enough for pretty much any match-up to feel reasonable without being a case of "there is only WAR!", it also allows fans of history to play around with historical elements, and the easygoing premise of gentlemens' wars in the big blue sky is hard not to like. In the words of Tony from Brigade Models, their Aeronef range has been a constant strong seller for 15 years, which keeps justifying new releases. Everyone should have an Aeronef fleet, says I. The only downsides are that it's usually played on a 6' x 4' table, and the production values of the rulebook might turn some people off. Personally, I'd love to see a sleeker-looking 2nd edition Aeronef rulebook.

My second choice would be Song of Blades and Heroes in 28mm, and my third would be either Dreadball or Tomorrow's War in 15mm played with small forces on a small board. I'm aware DBA in 15mm might be the most realistic contender in regard to its actual popularity and its suitability for casual pick-up games, but personally I'm not too fond of the visual aspect of it.

Poll set up by Personal logo Editor in Chief Bill The Editor of TMP Fezian, based on this pre-poll discussion.