Help support TMP


"ritual execution among the ants?" Topic


20 Posts

All members in good standing are free to post here. Opinions expressed here are solely those of the posters, and have not been cleared with nor are they endorsed by The Miniatures Page.

Please be courteous toward your fellow TMP members.

For more information, see the TMP FAQ.


Back to the Science Plus Board


Areas of Interest

General

Featured Hobby News Article


Featured Link


Featured Showcase Article

Elmer's Xtreme School Glue Stick

Is there finally a gluestick worth buying for paper modelers?


Featured Workbench Article

Basing With Stucco Crack Repair

Personal logo Editor in Chief Bill The Editor of TMP Fezian tries a stucco repair product to contour his bases.


Featured Profile Article

Happy 80th Birthday for Katie's Grandmother

Personal logo Editor Katie The Editor of TMP surprises her grandmother on her 80th birthday.


Current Poll


888 hits since 27 Apr 2015
©1994-2024 Bill Armintrout
Comments or corrections?


TMP logo

Membership

Please sign in to your membership account, or, if you are not yet a member, please sign up for your free membership account.
Great War Ace27 Apr 2015 9:29 p.m. PST

TMP link

"Ants have the most complicated social organization on earth next to humans."

That is possibly an understatement, to judge by a singular experience I once had in the woods involving ants.

I was thinking again of my very weird carpenter ant story. Had I shared this on TMP before? A search didn't give me any joy.

I must share this one every few years, to see if anyone reading it knows of a similar experience/observation:

This took place in the Wasatch Mountains of Utah, in the first week of July, 1982.

We were using chainsaws to cut old fallen trees into manageable pieces to haul back to camp for firewood. My cousin would throw a chain around the pieces and drag them along the gravel road behind his three-wheel Honda ATV, and then somebody would split them up to burn.

I was walking around the end of a fallen stump that he had cut off. He had moved further into the trees, looking for more fallen wood. I was looking for the strategic places to apply the chainsaw to cut the rest of the dead tree into sections.

The stump, before it had been cut off, had been elevated, as the entire dead tree had been lying across another beneath it for some years. The stump had dropped c. two and a half feet to the ground. The tree was very old. All that remained of the roots were a few blunted ends. The wood was sun baked, sans bark, smooth and pale grey.

So as I walked around to the sunlit side, the shiny, black patch of ants packed together in a dense circle instantly caught my attention. It was directly under the afternoon sun. You could have drawn a ninety degree angle from the sun's position directly to the shimmering circle of ants.

I bent down for a closer look. Some scores of large ants (over a hundred, two hundred ants? I couldn't tell because they were so close together that no grey wood showed beneath them) were all facing inward. My eyes followed their facing to the center of the circle. There was something going on, or about to happen there: at first I couldn't accept what I was seeing, as four warrior ants held a fifth by the two rear legs and feelers. A sixth warrior ant climbed onto the pinned one, and there was a slight pause of some seconds.

As if on a signal, the entire "congregation" of ants turned as one and broke up their circle (about the size of a dinner plate) and wandered off in all directions.

As they were moving away, the ant mounted on the back of the pinned ant, sawed through the joint of thorax and abdomen with a few deft scissor cuts of her jaws, the hinder part falling in the grass below. Then the "executioner" turned and beheaded her. The ants holding the feelers let go and the head dropped into the grass. The "executioner" got off the headless, truncated body, and the two ants holding the rear legs let go. The rest of the dead ant joined its fore and aft parts in the grass. The squad of executioners then wandered off in solitary directions.

Of course I was stunned. There was so much of the ceremonial or ritual about it all. It was so anthropomorphic. I looked up and yelled something and yet it was too late. Nobody had seen it but me. It had lasted less than two minutes.

My cousin heard my story and treated it casually. It sounded so made up or imagined. He dragged the stump back to camp, jouncing and banging on the road behind his ATV. But the ladies in the family did not want an ant-infested stump near our campfire, so it was dragged across the road and pitched in the scrub beneath the pine trees.

Next morning, I wandered over there to take a look at the stump, curious if there were any ants still in evidence. Man! were there ever: the space between the derelict stump and the nearest pine tree (a space around a yard wide) was a battlefield. The stricken colony, they of the "ritual execution" the day before, had been dumped by us upon the territory of another carpenter ant colony living in the base of the live pine tree. It was of course impossible for a human to tell ant from ant, so no way to tell who was winning. In some places dead and dying ants and pieces of ants were already several bodies deep. I stayed on my elbows and knees all morning and afternoon watching the mutual carnage. Warrior ants could be seen displaying the most horrific damage possible, and still fought on. Some were missing parts of legs, antennae, even abdomens. Some sported the severed heads of worker and warrior ants with frozen jaws still clamped to their legs or feelers. Some ants were lying still, with no visible mark on them, apparently expired nevertheless. Others were completely bereft of legs, with only stumps remaining to churn the ground and bodies beneath, while they fought on with champing jaws amidst a swarm of enemies still trying to chew them to pieces.

It was the most engrossing thing in Nature that I have ever seen, made more so by the large size of the ant species: warriors could be as large as half an inch long or slightly more.

But always in the front of my thoughts was the question: What had I seen happen yesterday? What did the concerted actions of the entire ant colony mean? What are the implications, vis-à-vis intelligence and awareness in creatures?…

Terrement28 Apr 2015 5:36 a.m. PST

I've known for a long time of "ant wars" and have seen a few in action. But the execution is something I've never seen or even heard of before. It must have been quite a sight.

Have you ever contacted any entomologists about this?

JJ

Great War Ace28 Apr 2015 8:14 a.m. PST

When National Geographic did a really fine article on ants, I sent in a letter with my story and the enquiry. No response. I've never met an entomologist….

Streitax28 Apr 2015 8:25 a.m. PST

Obviously it was an attempt to appease the Chainsaw God. It is equally evident that he sacrifice failed and the colony was punished for its transgressions by being cast among the heathens. You, sir, are a vicious, capricious, callous God.

On a serious note, you really should send a letter to the editor of one of the magazines that specializes in entomology. I'm sure they would publish it and it would probably get some responses.

Great War Ace28 Apr 2015 8:32 a.m. PST

I actually created a short story version which did exactly what you just had fun with. :) This was years ago, and in order to share I'd have to transcribe it onto my 'puter….

Personal logo etotheipi Sponsoring Member of TMP28 Apr 2015 8:48 a.m. PST

No SandAnt ever ran.

Cool. I like the idea of superficially higer order behaviours in lower animals.

Great War Ace28 Apr 2015 8:57 a.m. PST

entsoc.org

Done it, Streitax. That link is to the Entomological Society of America. They have a quarterly magazine too, but I thought that approaching with the story first would be better than appearing is if I wanted this published. I would find publication interesting of course. But what I really am after is input from others "in the field" as it were….

MHoxie28 Apr 2015 10:15 a.m. PST

Have you ever seen the movie "Phase IV"?

YouTube link

Ditto Tango 2 328 Apr 2015 10:33 a.m. PST

Very cool.

I've watched red on black ant wars. The thorax usually runs around after the head and abdomen are severed and the jaws go in biting. I don't know for how long. I assume carpenter ants are similar.

But ant wars are indeed very common. They even have scouts who find other colonies nearby. Maybe you witnessed what happened to a captured scout?
--
Tim

Mithmee28 Apr 2015 4:48 p.m. PST

Many years ago (I.E. back in the early 1970's) there were two colonies of ants one black and the other Red/Black that collided right in front of a friend's house.

They fought for over a week.

Andrew Walters28 Apr 2015 6:45 p.m. PST

You need to find an entomologist and relate this story. If they can explain it, we'd all love to know what's going on. If they can't, that's not much help but it would be good to know.

That's the craziest story I've heard all day.

Great War Ace28 Apr 2015 7:38 p.m. PST

@MHoxie: What a cutie Lynne Frederick was. I'd never heard of this film. Thanks. That was fun. "Incredible photography", yes to that….

Personal logo Parzival Supporting Member of TMP29 Apr 2015 10:50 a.m. PST

Two possibilities (among many):

1.) Ants identify ants of their colony by pheromones. If another ant smells different, it will be killed. Incidentally, there are certain parasite bugs that can mimic or acquire ant pheromones and use this ability to invade hives and feast on the members. It is also possible that a diseased ant might have altered pheromones, and thus is (instinctively) killed, preventing the spread of the disease (or, sense ants cannibalize dead bodies, contributes to the spread of the disease. "Ma, this leg tastes funny!" "Shut up and eat your uncle!"

2.) It is not unusual in some species for a new queen to execute the old queen. Perhaps the pheromones released during this activity attract the attention of workers and drones. Either they are adapting to the pheromones of the new queen, or they are waiting to act until the "fight" pheromones end and the scents go back to normal, after which they return to their usual habits in service to the queen (only now they have new one). "The Queen is dead, long live the Queen."

Great War Ace29 Apr 2015 8:30 p.m. PST

Wouldn't all such scenarios of killing an alien bug, or perceived alien bug, be instantaneous and on the spot? Why go to all the length of restraining the victim, then gathering what appeared to be the entire colony, then executing the victim only after the colony had turned away?…

Personal logo Parzival Supporting Member of TMP30 Apr 2015 8:25 a.m. PST

The colony might not have been "gathered," they just may have been there. If you've ever seen an ant's nest, it's a pretty populated place, So a stranger's pheromones simply attract the attention, of the ants currently in the area, either for instinctive defense or offense, until the closest ants kill the invader, and the pheromone ceases or is altered. Or, it might be that ants who detect an invader release a pheromone to attract their kind to (instinctively) assure that the invader is killed, even if he survives, avoids or defeats the initial ants to discover him.

All speculation, of course, but based on the known facts about ants with regards to pheromones as a central guide of ant behavior (that's how ant trails are created; an ant deposits chemicals along a path once it's found a source of food or water, which attracts other ants of the colony to follow that same path).

So what appears to be a ritualistic gathering is simply an auto response to chemical changes in an ant's environment. Of course, if ritual activity among ants is creepier, you use that for your game or story! :-)

Great War Ace01 May 2015 8:44 a.m. PST

Oh it is definitely creepier! And the timing was thus: dinner plate-sized circular patch of ants, not moving, all facing inward; dispersal of said-ants; "execution" of victim by five ants restraining and snipping; dispersal of "execution squad"….

Bowman02 May 2015 4:43 a.m. PST

Be careful you are not anthropomorphizing too much and imbuing the ants with human like characteristics. Your 8:30 pm entry seems to be such an interpretation.

Parzival hits the nail on the head. It seems much less creepy when you fully appreciate that the ants communicate by pheromones. The foreign ant is held down by worker ants and is dispatched by a soldier ant. Both are "programmed" by a response to the pheromone given off by the interloper. The crowd of ants that turned away were probably given another chemical order of "the danger is over, now go about your business". (how's that for anthropomorphizing? wink)

To a pattern seeking human it looks just like a crowd milling about to watch an upcoming hanging. A better analogy would be with a foreign object (like a bacterium) setting off our immune cascade, by being "marked" by complement binding, by certain immune cells. Then the foreign cell is then hunted down by other "killer" cells such as macrophages and neutrophils.

For a good read on ants, how about this Pulitzer Prize winner?:

link

There is even a chapter on the role of learning in colony level recognition.

Great War Ace03 May 2015 3:53 p.m. PST

Look at those prices!? Not going to happen.

Actually the first thing was sawing off the end of the stump. Whump! went the stump. Out came the ants, gathering into their patch. This was maybe ten minutes, tops, after my cousin chain sawed the stump off. Nice coincidental timing, finding that "enemy scout" right after that happened.

Too many weird coincidences of timing to just pass it off as "enemy caught" and pheromones. I know about pheromones (sound and touch should be added). That's why the whole thing lies in the realm of weird….

Great War Ace03 May 2015 4:41 p.m. PST

I did order the paperback, "Journey to the Ants", by the same authors, which is evidently a distillation of the gigantic book (with the gigantic price)….

Great War Ace30 Jul 2015 1:16 p.m. PST

Finished the book. Commented on it here: TMP link

Sorry - only verified members can post on the forums.