I have been a wargammer for 25+ years, starting with boardgames and progressing to miniatures. Over those years, I have played many different sets of rules covering almost every period for which miniatures are made.
When I play a new set of rules, I never made hasty judgments but instead play numerous times before deciding if I like them.
Ultimately, I want a feel for the period, playability, speed (I like to keep players fully engaged and not sitting around), and fun.
Pick Kevin and I to review the rules, and we will fully test them and honestly report their strengths and weaknesses.