Help support TMP


"Macabre question on generals who failed their sovereign" Topic


9 Posts

All members in good standing are free to post here. Opinions expressed here are solely those of the posters, and have not been cleared with nor are they endorsed by The Miniatures Page.

Please do not post offers to buy and sell on the main forum.

For more information, see the TMP FAQ.


Back to the General Historical Discussion Message Board


Action Log

03 Jan 2019 6:09 p.m. PST
by Editor in Chief Bill

  • Removed from Utter Drivel board
  • Crossposted to General Historical Discussion board

Areas of Interest

General

Featured Hobby News Article


Featured Link


Featured Ruleset


Featured Showcase Article

Stan Johansen Miniatures' Painting Service

A happy customer writes to tell us about a painting service...


Featured Workbench Article

Deep Dream: Getting Personal

Generating portraits using Deep Dream Generator.


Featured Profile Article

The da Vinci Jr. 1.0 3D Printer: Unboxing & Test Print

Personal logo Editor in Chief Bill The Editor of TMP Fezian unpacks and sets up an inexpensive 3D printer, and prints a test object.


651 hits since 3 Jan 2019
©1994-2024 Bill Armintrout
Comments or corrections?

Korvessa03 Jan 2019 12:06 p.m. PST

Something I read the other day got me to wondering when was the last time various countries executed one of their own generals for failure?

I know Germany & Soviet Russia did during WWII.
France did during the Revolutionary Wars.
So far as I know, USA never has.

But what of the other countries that have been great powers within the last few centuries?
Great Britain, Austria, Italy, Spain, Poland, Sweden?
Any one know

Cerdic03 Jan 2019 12:18 p.m. PST

The last British one I can think of was Admiral Byng? Mid 18th Century.

"Pour encourager les autres" and all that…

22ndFoot03 Jan 2019 12:19 p.m. PST

Last one for Great Britain was probably Admiral Byng in 1757 "pour encourager les autres." After his failure in the Battle of Minorca, Byng was tried by court martial and aquitted of personal cowardice but convicted of "failing to do his utmost" which meant a mandatory death sentence under the Articles of War. Various political machinations meant that the recommended clemency was not granted.

dapeters03 Jan 2019 12:20 p.m. PST

the Ottomans

Gerard Leman03 Jan 2019 12:47 p.m. PST

I agree that France did during the Revolutionary Wars. I'm not sure that I'd characterize the German and Russian generals executed during W.W.II as being due to their failures – they were executed because they posed a threat to the applicable dictator. Byng was court-martialed for loosing Minorca (through no fault of his how, IMHO), but the Articles of War at the time only provided for the death penalty and no lesser penalty, so the court found him guilty and imposed the death penalty, but unanimously urged the Lords of Admiralty to petition the king to reduce his sentence. King George II refused to do so, apparently for political reasons. So my take is that execution of generals for military failures only occurs when the head of state is not dependent on the support of the political class from which the generals derive, or alternately, when the class from which the generals derive is fractured, and the head of state wants to use a military defeat as a pretext for getting rid of political opponents.

Personal logo Mserafin Supporting Member of TMP03 Jan 2019 2:16 p.m. PST

I'm not sure that I'd characterize the German and Russian generals executed during W.W.II as being due to their failures

Pavlov, commander of Western Front in 1941, was ostensibly executed for failure. In reality it was more like he was executed as a scapegoat for Stalin's failures, but the official reason given was failure to do those things Stalin's orders forbade him from doing.

emckinney03 Jan 2019 11:46 p.m. PST

Heck, the US Army has stopped relieving generals for failure. Or incompetence, or defying orders and causing a fubar.

Walking Sailor04 Jan 2019 8:46 a.m. PST

The USA? It depends on who you believe got to Gen. Patton. evil grin

Puster Sponsoring Member of TMP05 Jan 2019 9:35 a.m. PST

Afaik Germany in WW2 did not execute Generals for failure in the field, but for political reasons. Most were executed for their real or aligned part in the assassination attempt.

Sorry - only verified members can post on the forums.