Help support TMP


"Waterloo AAR from Soldiers of Oxfordshire Museum" Topic


5 Posts

All members in good standing are free to post here. Opinions expressed here are solely those of the posters, and have not been cleared with nor are they endorsed by The Miniatures Page.

Please be courteous toward your fellow TMP members.

For more information, see the TMP FAQ.


Back to the Napoleonic Battle Reports Message Board

Back to the Wargaming in the United Kingdom Message Board

Back to the 19th Century Discussion Message Board


Areas of Interest

General
Napoleonic
19th Century

Featured Hobby News Article


Featured Link


Current Poll


Featured Book Review


1,041 hits since 26 Oct 2015
©1994-2024 Bill Armintrout
Comments or corrections?

ChrisBBB26 Oct 2015 6:44 a.m. PST

Just over 200 years ago, in June 1815, the 52nd (Oxfordshire) Regiment played a notable part in defeating Napoleon's Imperial Guard as he threw the dice for the last time at Waterloo. We therefore laid on a BBB demonstration/participation game of Waterloo at the Soldiers of Oxfordshire Museum (SOFO).

We really didn't know what to expect. It's a decent museum but not a major tourist attraction, so while we hoped we'd have dozens of visitors, I feared it might be closer to zero. So our objectives were two-fold. If any members of the public did come by, we would give them our full attention, pause the game, and seek to engage, educate, and entertain them. To that end, we had Nigel's photos and souvenirs from the Waterloo 200 re-enactment, Ben's "Waterloo Companion" reference work, and other informational material. But in between times, we would play the game as normal, in a leisurely way.

As it turned out, it was an epic day. It got off to a great start. We had just finished setting up, shortly after the doors opened, and a young teenager looked into the room we'd been given and said "That looks cool!". In short order we'd got him seated next to Napoleon, rolling dice, and being briefed about the battle, about Napoleonic warfare, and about wargaming in general. Turned out he was the son of one of the museum staff, he knew of Warhammer but hadn't played. He stayed for the duration, earned more brownie points by periodically saying things like "This is really fun", asked lots of newbie questions about uniforms and weapons and ranks and everything … he was a good lad, genuinely interested, and we may well have attracted a new member to the hobby. If so, the day was worth it just for that.

Apart from our new recruit, visitors were a trickle rather than a flood, but every half hour or so someone would stick their nose in. People's reactions were very positive, admiring the layout, asking questions, happily rolling a few dice, and we had some good conversations. I think we gave a good impression and weren't too anorakish – some of us had even showered and shaved – and enhanced the visitor experience. We must have, because SOFO has invited us to do more such events in future.

Oops, I nearly forgot to talk about the actual game. Did I mention it was an epic day? It was an epic battle. It turned out to be perfectly paced. Apart from me as referee, and our young drummer boy, we had four players initially, and a fifth arrived later in time to command the Prussians. Two of the players were experienced wargamers but had not played BBB before. Despite novice players, and interactions with the public, and a leisurely lunch at the museum cafe, we finished the game in 6 hours, in time to pack up just before the museum closed.

[To see photos, look at the BBB Blog:]
link

The French players had learned from a previous playtest. Anton having rashly lost the game last time by committing the Guard very early and getting them destroyed, this time kept them out of harm's way garrisoning Plancenoit. He and Dave had decided there was no future in attacking on the right, nor in the centre. Their plan was for D'Erlon to switch left and help Reille to take Hougoumont, then drive on Mont St Jean. Lobau was to shift right to pin Picton and screen against the eventual Prussian threat.

Well, the plan went pear-shaped on Turn 2. Anton noticed the garrison of La Haye Sainte was mildly discomfited by French artillery fire and had a Ney-like rush of blood to the head. Napoleon's order headed "Hougoumont" went in a ditch, and D'Erlon attacked La Haye Sainte. A couple of difficult turns ensued for the French. On their right, Milhaud and other cavalry made repeated efforts to dislodge Saxe-Weimar's Nassau brigade from Papelotte. A combination of poor French coordination and good Nassau dice made these a costly failure. La Haye Sainte fell, but by that time Reille, obliged to attack Hougoumont unsupported, had lost a division. A French grand battery formed up on the French left, on the ridge SW of Hougoumont, but it was slow to get into position and slower to warm up its dice.

Emboldened by the arrival of the first Prussians on Turn 4, and by Reille's repulse, Wellington decided to attack on his right in order to break up the grand battery before it could do serious damage.

Chassé's Dutch, the Brunswick corps, and Mitchell's and Clinton's brigades surged across the lanes and hedges. French cavalry fell back in disarray and the flank of the grand battery was in dire peril. Meanwhile, a first attempt having failed, a second Allied counterattack retook La Haye Sainte. Repulsed on their right, ejected in the centre, assailed on the left, and with Prussians looming closer, the French position looked desperate.

But then on the last couple of turns, the balance shifted again. The grand battery finally found its range and blew away Clinton and the Brunswickers. Reille rallied a couple of divisions and some cavalry and was able to smash the Union Brigade and KGL cavalry, who in the finest tradition of the British mounted arm had exploited their success a little too far. Suddenly the British Guards holed up in Hougoumont looked dangerously isolated, while the Nivelles road to Mont St.Jean lay open, a French advance impeded only by mobs of fleeing Allied soldiery.


Lobau on the French right had finally succeeded in expelling the Nassauers from Papelotte. He then fought a skilful delaying action against Bluecher, such that only the Prussian advance guard cavalry had a chance on the last turn of defeating a French cavalry screen to seize Plancenoit.

For Plancenoit had meanwhile been vacated by the Old Guard. Our new junior member had been urging this for hours. At last Anton's caution was overcome and columns of bearskins nodded up the road towards La Haye Sainte. Allies stormed forward to meet them. This backfired somewhat, as the OG defeated the brigade that attacked them, and then stormed the reduced garrison of La Haye Sainte. All Allied reserves had been committed, so here too the road to Mont St.Jean was open, albeit covered by some Allied artillery. However, the Allied advance had succeeded in shattering the last of D'Erlon's corps and part of Lobau's, leaving the Guard surrounded without support.

This was a battle which become more and more tense and exciting as it went on, building to a real climax on the last turn. Three objectives were all contested – Hougoumont, La Haye Sainte and Plancenoit – with the French needing all three for a win, and the Allies needing two. The Guard seizing LHS had earned a draw. Could Reille take Hougoumont for a win? French infantry and cavalry converged on the chateau – but Allied fire drove some off, and the weakened assault failed. Then it was the Allies' turn. Could they retake either LHS or Plancenoit? A feeble attempt on LHS predictably bounced off. All now rested on von Buelow's cavalry … who were repulsed.

Thus the French were left in possession of Plancenoit and La Haye Sainte. Both the French and Anglo-Dutch armies were pretty much exhausted; the Prussians, having been too slow to get into any serious fighting, were fresh but still mostly at some distance. End result: in historical terms, Bonaparte barely thwarted and doomed to eventual defeat; but in game terms, an honourable draw.

The full scenario is in the BBB Yahoo group files, and also in Flickr, with more photos and commentary.

Chris
Bloody Big BATTLES!
link
bloodybigbattles.blogspot.co.uk

Who asked this joker26 Oct 2015 7:17 a.m. PST

What a great battle report! An interesting decision to go straight into Hougomont. Assuming a historical deployment, Wellington was overly concerned about defending his right and really loaded up that flank with his reserves. By going all in on the Hougomont, the French were essentially attacking the allied strength.

The two historical criticisms of the first two assaults were that 1) the French did not send enough cavalry to support the D'erlon and 2) the second attack was almost pure cavalry with no infantry support at the point of attack. I wonder why the French commander did not try to correct these problems? Of course, when attacking Wellington's left, you are also playing with a shorter clock as the Prussians would have a lesser distance to travel.

ChrisBBB26 Oct 2015 9:55 a.m. PST

Glad you enjoyed the report. Having fought this scenario three times in the past month or so, with different French plans each time, I think the three basic options left/ centre/ right each have roughly equal merits. But in each case, a French win needs not just competent French command but also some Allied errors or lucky dice.

Fair to say that in our game at SOFO the French plan was reasonably sound in conception, but the French command didn't have its best day. They masked their own guns, sent in cavalry unsupported by infantry, and infantry unsupported by cavalry. Anton got distracted by La Haye Sainte and deviated from the agreed plan, which I think frustrated his team-mate into a futile and doomed assault on Hougoumont. But they did other things well, a good delaying action vs the Prussians, and got it together late in the day on their left. So they earned their draw.

In the first playtest Hougoumont was taken, but it was late in the game after all the supporting Allied units had been driven back or destroyed, leaving it vulnerable to overwhelming concentric attack from three directions.

Chris

vtsaogames26 Oct 2015 2:05 p.m. PST

Sounds like a great game. I must give it a try sometime, after testing Champions Hill.

ChrisBBB26 Oct 2015 4:36 p.m. PST

It really was a special game. The boys are already talking about doing it again to see if Napoleon can crack it. For the Allies it's mostly a case of just reacting sensibly to what the French do. But for the French players it's a real conundrum, a proper brain-teaser.

Chris

KTravlos27 Oct 2015 7:07 a.m. PST

Fun game indeed!

Sorry - only verified members can post on the forums.