Help support TMP


"Review of Wargames, Soldiers & Strategy #69" Topic


21 Posts

All members in good standing are free to post here. Opinions expressed here are solely those of the posters, and have not been cleared with nor are they endorsed by The Miniatures Page.

Remember that you can Stifle members so that you don't have to read their posts.

For more information, see the TMP FAQ.


Back to the Magazines and Periodicals Message Board


Areas of Interest

General

Featured Hobby News Article


Featured Ruleset


Featured Workbench Article

Crayola Bases for Trees

A simple way to make scenic bases.


Current Poll


Featured Book Review


2,568 hits since 5 Nov 2013
©1994-2024 Bill Armintrout
Comments or corrections?

ubercommando05 Nov 2013 4:05 a.m. PST

Are you all sitting twosquare comftybold on the botty? Then I'll begin…

FIRST IMPRESSIONS: The front cover is black. Starless and bible black. The words "COUNTDOWN TO DOOMSDAY" are writ large with a picture of Soviet spetznaz forces in action. The theme is hypothetical WW3. I'm having a flashback moment of '80s nuclear paranoia, wimmin chaining themselves to Greenham Common fences, Frankie Goes To Hollywood and dodgy 80s nuclear war TV miniseries.

EDITORIAL: Guy raids his Sun Tzu quotation book for an appropriate saying about beating your enemy without having to go into battle; an apt summary of the Cold War and this editorial is quite sobering about the war we didn't fight.

REVIEWS: Mainly 28mm, with a lovely looking Peter Pig Viking Longship and 6mm buildings an exception but the figures under review aren't your usual suspects but some interesting AWI highlanders, a figure inspired by Sean Connery from The Wind and the Lion and some True Grit inspired ones to name but a few.

THIS GAMING LIFE: Rick Priestly talks about the hobby and The Hobby (tm). Is GW and Battlefront's corporate approach by marketing The Hobby (tm) really evil or misguided or a rational approach to luring capital and being more professional? And should we get all bent out of shape about it? Rick argues for vive le difference.

MARCHING TO THE FIFE & DRUM: An interview with Jim Purky, owner of Fife & Drum miniatures and his approach to designing and marketing his realistically proportioned 28mm figures.

BITESISE BATTLES, ALBA TRIUMPHANT: A mediaeval English v Scots battle designed for Warhammer Ancient Battles. It can be adapted for other rules but I wish the author hadn't chosen an out of print rules set in the first place.

SABRE IN HAND, SWEARING LIKE A PAGAN: A look at Hussars in the Napoleonic Wars with an emphasis on the writings of Antoine De Brack, a cavalryman himself who wrote the definitive light cavalry manual. Interesting stuff about tactics which isn't national specific or straight history. As a bonus, there's a skirmish scenario as well which would suit Sharp Practice.

A SEA OF SAND: A scenario for Long Range Desert Group or SAS missions in North Africa. Not tied to any specific rules set but it does list a number of scenario templates.

WHAT DID YOU DO IN THE COLD WAR, DADDY? Into this issue's theme, this is an overview of the military situation in Europe in the 1980s and the backdrop for a potential WW3. There's a bit on the literature of that era which depicted hypothetical wars (General Sir John Hackett's Third World War remains the definitive work) and some pop culture references as well. -1 victory point for mentioning Nena's 99 Luftballoons though. I still drink to forget that song.

FULDA GAP, NOVEMBER 1983: An interesting article about how a NATO exercise called Able Archer '83 almost led the Soviets to panic and launch a real attack. The author is a US army veteran from that time who gives a nice personal history touch to the article. So you get the background info and a scenario. Finally, there's a bit on what happens in the scenario if the Americans use a tac nuke in desperation. "Game Over, nul pointes all round" is the answer.

KENNEDY V KHRUSCHEV: I must admit if I was going to do any hypothetical WW3 game, I would set it not in the 80s but in the 60s and this is a megagame scenario set in that time. It's a wonderfully simple system that allows each player to do anything, imagination the only limit but with the proviso that you have to come up with an action, the result you want and 3 reasons why it is possible to carry out this action. The umpire then sets a target number to be achieved on a roll of 2D6 based on how feasible and difficult the action is.

RED STAR RISING: Our US army veteran returns with a look at Soviet forces and just how good or bad they were. Along the way he dispels some myths (a mindless hoarde with rubbish equipment as if they're merely an extension of 1942 era Soviets). If I have a quibble, and this applies to the other articles in this theme, is that it's very interesting when talking about conventional warfare but at some point the articles "go nuclear" and once that's discussed, the articles end. Now, that might be how a potential WW3 might have ended up but in wargaming terms it doesn't offer much. Once a nuke is used in a game, it's all over. So translating the cold war gone hot into a game, the emphasis must be on the conventional and I feel some of these articles don't cover enough of that before talking about nuclear weapons.

WARGAMES & WMDs: Case in point. A nice review of Post-War rules suitable for WW3 games (most out of print) but with the emphasis on whether they cover nuclear weapons or not. I'm not sure that's what we should be looking for: Once you use one in a tabletop game, you may as well pour petrol on your table and set fire to it, as some wag put it.

GAMING THE COLD WAR: A look at some of the figures and vehicles available for gaming the cold war. A good range in a variety of scales (yes! Thank you Guy!) from 28mm, 20mm, 15mm and 6mm courtesy of Heroics & Ros. A question for you manufacturers out there: Where are the non-Jungle uniform US infantry from 1960-1985? Pre-Fritz helmet and with early M16s? Especially in 28mm, this is a gap in the market.

NO ONE BUT US: How the author made the Spetsnaz diorama on the front cover. There's a nice bit about how to paint Soviet camouflage.

DEVIL'S ADVOCATE: Mark "Not Mark Lamarr" Latham poses the question, is gaming bad? Or is merely collecting and painting bad? Which one are you? Does it matter? Like Rick Priestly's earlier article, this thoughtful piece challenges some of those divides that seem to cause arguments in the hobby (not The Hobby (tm)).

THE PHILOSOPHER'S PORTABLE BATTLEFIELD: How to make your own nice looking terrain mats using a lot of DIY material, artist canvass and modelling bits. Very nice results, but I think I'll stick to buying TSS terrain boards. The work and fumes involved put me off trying to make my own.

I DID IT ONE PIECE AT A TIME: How the author makes armies for Impetus by buying pre-painted armies on ebay or at bring and buy stands and re-basing them. Nicely written and full of detail but, like the previous article, it all seems like too much work.

LET'S PLAY LONGSTREET: Following on from Sam Mustafa's own piece on his game in Wargames Illustrated here is a play test of the rules. Goes into the card driven mechanics, how a game plays out and it all seems like fun although the author does warn that the rules aren't very well laid out. What's missing is a look at the wonderful campaign rules for Longstreet but the author does mention he hasn't tried them yet.

GAME REVIEWS: Gods and Mortals (Osprey) and Hail Caesar Britannia are covered here.

UP FRONT: Richard Clarke talks about technology and wargaming, how rules PDFs, tablets and online magazines can be a boon but computer moderated games and dice rolling apps are perhaps a development too far.

BOARDGAMES REVIEWS: Covers Five Points (a game about the Gangs of New York, but without violent punch ups which makes it akin to a standard political Eurogame) and an addition to the Spartacus game.

BOOK REVIEWS: Features the Wargaming Compendium and that "niche" subject; German Imperial Colonial Overseas Troops 1885-1918 which I mentioned in the review of the last Miniature Wargames (with Battlegames) and got into trouble for saying it was niche.

OVERVIEW: Very readable and with the emphasis on history in the articles rather than straight up wargaming scenarios. I mean, the scenarios are there but this time the historical background info is more prominent. The theme was interesting, the DIY modelling was a bit complicated for my tastes but then I say that of every DIY piece in all the magazines. If you have the time, patience and tolerant family who don't mind having their home smell of solvents, then give them a try. I think WSS is strongest in terms of opinion pieces and in playtesting and reviewing games, with Let's Play… being an excellent series. I think the thematic approach is done very well.

Grand Dragon05 Nov 2013 4:43 a.m. PST

I thought it was a good issue and very interesting , especially the pieces on the Soviet army and the Napoleonic light cavalry.

Joes Shop Supporting Member of TMP05 Nov 2013 5:17 a.m. PST

Interesting, thanks!

Badgers05 Nov 2013 5:55 a.m. PST

Very much agree with the reviewer. More, better and bigger articles on conventional warfare at various levels. For how long has this period been effectively ignored?

Gary Mitchell Sponsoring Member of TMP05 Nov 2013 6:29 a.m. PST

Curses! Didn't like the Nena ref :) It's a classic (Eurovision) example of 'let's call the whole thing off' propaganda. Anyone think of other songs that explore the zietgiest of an era? The two world wars spring to my mind…

ubercommando05 Nov 2013 7:09 a.m. PST

Gary I'm going to stop you right there…Zeitgeist songs of the 80s will only lead us into a world of cringe. If we accept that Genesis gets a free pass for "Land of Confusion" then we're looking at "Two Tribes" (gulp), "Russians" by Sting (surely the song that ended the Cold War) and then down the rabbit hole with "War is Stupid" by Culture Club…surely the worst anti-war song ever written. What are we left with then? David Hasselhoff performing on the rubble of the Berlin Wall, that's what!

Ironwolf05 Nov 2013 7:17 a.m. PST

I really enjoy this magazine and since I can't find it at Barnes & Noble any longer. I'm gonna purchase a subscription as my xmas present to meself. lol

Ben Waterhouse05 Nov 2013 8:44 a.m. PST

Outstanding review! As a part time former cold war warrior (aka weekend beerdrinker)I love all the subtle 80s references…

Grand Dragon05 Nov 2013 9:12 a.m. PST

Gary I'm going to stop you right there…Zeitgeist songs of the 80s will only lead us into a world of cringe. If we accept that Genesis gets a free pass for "Land of Confusion" then we're looking at "Two Tribes" (gulp), "Russians" by Sting (surely the song that ended the Cold War) and then down the rabbit hole with "War is Stupid" by Culture Club…surely the worst anti-war song ever written. What are we left with then? David Hasselhoff performing on the rubble of the Berlin Wall, that's what!

Here's some more ( anti-war/anti-nuclear ) :

Enola Gay – OMD
Dancing With Tears In My Eyes – Ultravox
Ask – The Smiths
World War – The Cure
The Lebanon – Human League
Breathing – Kate Bush
Army Dreamers – Kate Bush
2 Minutes To Midnight – Iron Maiden
Forgotten Sons – Marillion
Living Through Another Cuba – XTC
Sunday Bloody Sunday – U2
Seconds – U2

Grand Dragon05 Nov 2013 9:20 a.m. PST

And this was a classic , although probably not as famous as some of the others :

youtube.com/watch?v=pHEhL34zeHg

ubercommando05 Nov 2013 10:18 a.m. PST

…ah, I remember how much I hate 80s music now.

All these prissy anti-war songs by gender bending synth poppers can't hold a candle to the greatest and most vitriolic anti-war song of all time. I give you Barry McGuire's version of "Eve of Destruction". Sixties protest songs v Eighties protest songs: No contest, the hippies win.

M1Fanboy05 Nov 2013 12:56 p.m. PST

Geez people, I like 80s music (just not the protest songs)…

nevinsrip05 Nov 2013 2:25 p.m. PST

"some interesting AWI highlanders,"

What !!! Those are Kings Mountain Miniatures, I'll have you know.

Volleyfire06 Nov 2013 8:49 a.m. PST

I'm still wading my way through this mag, there is just so much interesting content in it to read. I to feel that the Cold War scenarios and articles went nuclear too quickly, a lot more info about conventional would have been more useful and interesting. I'm sure I recall reading an article about a British force on one of these exercises and how they managed to hold the Red horde back with the Soviets deemed to have resorted to tac nukes in frustration on about day 7? Anyway, this mag has pushed this months WI reading onto the back burner,FP war looks interesting reading, and BMW has gone in the bin, only took me half an hour to flick through it I'm afraid and couldn't really find anything that caught my eye.

I thought Sunday Bloody Sunday was about Derry and the IRA? Hardly a proper anti war dirge?
Now how about Capt Sensible and 'Glad it's all over? '

ubercommando17 Nov 2013 3:43 p.m. PST

Good luck with that FPW stuff in WI. A real mixed bag of quality with them.

Having read the latest offerings from all three, I'd have to rank them as WSS 69 #1, MW(w/BG) #2 and WI 313 #3.

battleeditor18 Nov 2013 3:57 a.m. PST

Not entirely a direct 'level playing field' comparison, of course, because there are two issues of MWBG and WI to every one of WSS. I remember the luxury of a bi-monthly schedule…

Henry

ubercommando18 Nov 2013 5:10 a.m. PST

True. Would it help if I said there was only a smidgeon between the latest WSS and MW(w/BG) and a gulf between you and WI?

battleeditor18 Nov 2013 5:39 a.m. PST

LOL!

Thanks for that, but I wasn't fishing really. I think WSS is a cracking magazine, but I also think back wistfully to the time I had to lavish on BG when it was bi-monthly compared to the breakneck pace of my current schedule. By the time you're commenting on an issue here, I'm already well into putting the next one together, and it dawned on me that I have to do that twice for every one that Guy and his team produce. No wonder he looked healthy when I saw him at Warfare and I look like I've been force-fed an aging potion!

Henry

Gennorm23 Nov 2013 2:31 p.m. PST

I cursed when I received my copy and saw the theme. I Ain't Been Muked Mum is nearing completion and I could have sent the editor some details had I known about the theme before, especially as the rules review focused on old out of print sets. Good to see the era highlighted though.

AncientWarfare23 Nov 2013 2:53 p.m. PST

Hi Nick
Please contact Guy anyway, I know he'll want to hear about that and there's always a next issue!

Jasper

Gecoren24 Nov 2013 6:01 a.m. PST

What Jasper said! Always happy to look at new rules and ideas etc.

Guy

Sorry - only verified members can post on the forums.