"British Cruiser tanks, France 1940" Topic
12 Posts
All members in good standing are free to post here. Opinions expressed here are solely those of the posters, and have not been cleared with nor are they endorsed by The Miniatures Page.
Please do not use bad language on the forums.
For more information, see the TMP FAQ.
Back to the WWII Discussion Message Board
Areas of InterestWorld War Two on the Land
Featured Hobby News Article
Featured Link
Top-Rated Ruleset
Featured Showcase Article
Featured Workbench Article
Featured Profile ArticleThe Editor is invited to tour the factory of Simtac, a U.S. manufacturer of figures in nearly all periods, scales, and genres.
Featured Movie Review
|
Somua S35 | 03 Sep 2010 12:21 p.m. PST |
With the release of FOWs 1940 cruisers, I was wondering how many of these tanks were in France during the 1940 campaign. I remember vaguely the armored division being involved in the defense of Callais. Also remember on paper this being a very large division (in tanks anyway). Anyone have any numbers off the top of their heads what formations fought in France, how many tanks total? Thanks for any help or a point in the right direction. |
Jeff Ewing | 03 Sep 2010 1:13 p.m. PST |
Well, a quick search on "BEF 1940 oob" yields this from this site: link "HQ BEF 4/7 Dragoons: 28x Mk VI lt 13/18 Hussars: 28x MkVI lt 1st Armoured Reconnaissance Brigade 1st East Riding Yeomanry: 28x Mk VI lt 1st Fife and FOrefar [sic] Yeomanry: 28x MkVI lt 2nd Armoured Reconnaissance Brigade 5th Dragoon Guards: 28x Mk VI lt 15/19 Hussars: 28x MkVI lt 1st Army Tank Brigade 4th Royal Tank Regiment: 50x A10 cruiser, 5x MkVI lt 7th Royal Tank Regiment: 27x A10 cruiser, 23x Matilda I, 7x MkVI lt 1st Armoured Division A mix of 143x cruisers (A9, A10, and A13), and 114x Mk VI lt. Division consisted of: 2nd Armoured Brigade: The Queen's Bays, 9th Queen's Royal Lancers, 10th Royal Hussars 3rd Armoured Brigade: 2nd Bn Royal Tank Regiment, 5th Bn Royal Tank Regiment" So around 220 cruisers. |
Neroon | 03 Sep 2010 1:16 p.m. PST |
I think those numbers were pulled from this site link cheers |
Red Line | 03 Sep 2010 1:16 p.m. PST |
1940 Armoured Division: Consisting of- 2 Armoured brigades, each of 3 Armoured Regiments with 56 Cruiser Tanks a piece. A Support Group of 2 Motor Battalions, 1 RHA regiment and a light AA/AT regiment. Royal Engineers had 1 Field Squadron and 1 Field Park Troop. There was also a Signals group. This came to a total of: 10750 officers & men 475 light MG 364 2" mortar 254 Anti-tank rifles 16 25 pdr guns 24 40mm AA guns 649 motorcycles 88 Bren Carriers 602 vans/trucks 858 lorries/tractors 2 light tanks 36 close support tanks 304 cruiser tanks WWII Databook |
Doms Decals | 03 Sep 2010 1:39 p.m. PST |
1st Army Tank Brigade 4th Royal Tank Regiment: 50x A10 cruiser, 5x MkVI lt 7th Royal Tank Regiment: 27x A10 cruiser, 23x Matilda I, 7x MkVI lt Umm, no
. Matilda I not A10 cruiser, Matilda II not Matilda I – they were the sole infantry tank formation. Dom. |
aecurtis | 03 Sep 2010 2:27 p.m. PST |
Shirley, someone has this right online somewhere? I *think* Killer Woobie's link is correct. Allen |
RedSalmon | 03 Sep 2010 2:32 p.m. PST |
I seem to remember that most of the support kit for these formations was stuck in the docks. |
donlowry | 03 Sep 2010 2:41 p.m. PST |
|
Martin Rapier | 03 Sep 2010 3:01 p.m. PST |
Zalogas 'Blitzkrieg Armor Camouflage and Markings' has the numbers, as do the Bellona special issues on the various cruiser models. Yes there were a few hundred, but 1st AD never fought as a complete formation and lost the lot in France. Many of the the formations were mixed cruiser/light units. The defence of Calais was aided by a single mixed armoured regiment, 4th RTR, which was largely destroyed in a single battle with 10th Panzer Div. |
Somua S35 | 04 Sep 2010 7:56 a.m. PST |
You hear and read a lot about the Matildas at Arras, not as much about the cruisers. Had the feeling their combat was more fragmented. Neat looking tanks. Interesting the I tank vs cavalry ideas in both the Brit and French armies. The Germans seemed to have bypassed those two schools of thought. |
Doms Decals | 04 Sep 2010 8:59 a.m. PST |
Allen – yes, Killer Woobie's link looks at least in the right ballpark – the figures look they may well be the same as Zaloga, in which case there's the odd vehicle misplaced, but they're more or less right. The hellish part is (a) figuring out who had which carriers, and how many, in the recce formations, and (b) breaking down 1st armoured division into which types in which regiments and squadrons – I've yet to see a convenient breakdown of those anywhere, and never found the spare money and time to chase down all the relevant regimental histories and/or war diaries
. |
Fall Rot | 04 Sep 2010 9:33 a.m. PST |
PRODUCTION figures from "British and American Tanks of WWII" by Chamberlain & Ellis: 172 Mk II (A10) 125 Mk I (A9) 65 Mk III (A13) 655 Mk IV (A13 mk II) Doesn't say which ones were sent to France (surely only a few of the Mk IVs as most of these were produced after June 1940) Zaloga's "Blitzkrieg" has it at 150 Cruiser Tanks in the 1st Armoured as of May 10th, but no further breakdown. Again, probably not ALL where in France at that time. According to accounts in "Calais" by Cooksey, the the 3rd Batttalion RTR in action around Calais was slightly understrength with ~9 cruiser tanks in each A,B,& C squadron, with one A9 tank functioning at battalion HQ. Seemed to be a mix of A9 & A10s & A13s. Also just found this quote on the Axis History Forum but there are no sources cited: "Beside the battle of Arras, British tanks were e.g. involved in Abbeville and around Calais. The 3rd RTR (48 tanks of the 1st AD) was completely lost in Calais without achieving anything. The first attack on Abbeville was led by the 1st AD, which lost 120 tanks out of 165 (73% losses), the attack failed in only 2 hours. Most of the remaining British tanks were simply abandoned or lost due to mechanical breakdowns and could not be recovered and repaired in front of the advancing German troops. " oh, and I just checked the online version of Ellis' "The War in France and Flanders" and found the relevant chapter concerning the tank action of 1st AD at Abbeville: link
and, here's the General orbat for the 1st AD on wikipedia: link -CH
|
|